The Mahomes GOAT thread (since this comes up in multiple threads)

[cincygrad]

He is the best QB in the league and has been for several seasons. He's definitely the guy you are most scared of if you are a fan of a team that has to play the Chiefs.

To me, his status as GOAT will depend on how he and the Chiefs handle the inevitable challenges of change to their team. Reid won't be there forever, so they'll have to hire the right coach. I don't think Mahomes will be as impacted by players changing teams as others, but it will be worth watching what happens when Kelce is finished. And, as everyone says - Can he stay healthy?

 

[R.J. MacReady]

Don't care how Mahomes is ranked in comparisons.

Just finally having a quarterback in KC who has played in a winning way in the biggest games is what matters to me. He's already accomplished everything you could ask for from a franchise quarterback.

I like this "taking nothing for granted" point of view over the "he can walk on water"


.

 

[boogiewithstu2007]

He’s a great player, not the GOAT though, after his career is over people can reflect on that, he’s gotta keep it going …

 

[Black Adam]

He’s a great player, not the GOAT though, after his career is over people can reflect on that, he’s gotta keep it going …

Yeah, that's keeping it real. Wait'll we get towards the end of his career. Then make all the comparisons you want. Too early for this...

 

[Chief Cola]

I like this "taking nothing for granted" point of view over the "he can walk on water"


.

Well from 1985 to 2019 every super bowl I watched had somebody else's team in it. It was a mindbender to finally see the Chiefs play in the super bowl.

So ya and especially compared to guys like Brees and so far Rodgers to get there three times and win twice is pretty great.

 

[R.J. MacReady]

Well from 1985 to 2019 every super bowl I watched had somebody else's team in it. It was a mindbender to finally see the Chiefs play in the super bowl.

So ya and especially compared to guys like Brees and so far Rodgers to get there three times and win twice is pretty great.

Pretty great indeed.

 

[Black Adam]

Well from 1985 to 2019 every super bowl I watched had somebody else's team in it. It was a mindbender to finally see the Chiefs play in the super bowl.

So ya and especially compared to guys like Brees and so far Rodgers to get there three times and win twice is pretty great.

I saw our first one and before our current run I thought I'd be taking a dirt nap before I'd see another one...

 

[Wamu]

Mahomes really isn't that good because he didn't play at Minnesota.

signed- fredisdeadfriend

 

[Chief Cola]

I saw our first one and before our current run I thought I'd be taking a dirt nap before I'd see another one...

It actually didn't fully register in my mind until the super bowl party got underway before the game in 2020.

Before then it had always been about the refreshments more than the game istelf lol.

 

[PDay8810]

I saw our first one and before our current run I thought I'd be taking a dirt nap before I'd see another one...

I've been told I'll die before I'll see another Cowboy championship.

Entertainment remains the very best part of keyboard opinions.

 

[ducky]

Mahomes really isn't that good because he didn't play at Minnesota.

signed- fredisdeadfriend

Fred would classify him as a Minnesotan (the little guy is him):

 

[Wamu]

Fred would classify him as a Minnesotan (the little guy is him):

Even at the young of an age he could throw a football better than Tebow.

 

[eaglesnut]

You really think the Chiefs would hire someone that wouldn’t revolve the entire offense around what Mahomes wants? Andy Reid is a hell of a coach but we can’t pretend it’s all him, Reid has had several good QB’s and none have come close to the number Mahomes has.

Reid has had a dumb piece of shit for a QB and then he rehabilitated Alex Smith into a QB. Mahomes can run the offense. It's a magnificent offense.

 

[wazzu31]

Reid has had a dumb piece of shit for a QB and then he rehabilitated Alex Smith into a QB. Mahomes can run the offense. It's a magnificent offense.

Your saying McNabb was stupid? Alex Smith wasn’t terrible. He got the Philly job because of Brett Favre. So we can’t pretend it is just him, Mahomes is the best QB and no coach KC would hire would come in and drastically change anything.

 

[eaglesnut]

Your saying McNabb was stupid? Alex Smith wasn’t terrible. He got the Philly job because of Brett Favre. So we can’t pretend it is just him, Mahomes is the best QB and no coach KC would hire would come in and drastically change anything.

Mcnabb was worse than stupid, but I was being nice.

 

[Wamu]

Mcnabb was worse than stupid, but I was being nice.

Stupid QB's don't go 92-49-1 in 11 seasons (with the eagles). I get it, you don't like him. But to call him stupid is kinda silly.

Here's a stupid QB- Johnny outta Football.

 

[eaglesnut]

Stupid QB's don't go 92-49-1 in 11 seasons (with the eagles). I get it, you don't like him. But to call him stupid is kinda silly.

They do with Andy Reid.

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

Your saying McNabb was stupid? Alex Smith wasn’t terrible. He got the Philly job because of Brett Favre. So we can’t pretend it is just him, Mahomes is the best QB and no coach KC would hire would come in and drastically change anything.

Mcnabb was an idiot and as a QB he was a very good regular season QB

 

[Dude]

Mcnabb was an idiot and as a QB he was a very good regular season QB

Why? Because of the Chunky Soup commercials? You guys are ruthless.

 

[wazzu31]

Why? Because of the Chunky Soup commercials? You guys are ruthless.

No shit, it’s like you are an irrelevant team until he gets there and took them to what 5 championship games?