Wilson rated by the so called experts

[JDM]

13 is perfectly fair. At least that many would have won a Super Bowl with that team.

 

[SonnyCID]

13 is perfectly fair. At least that many would have won a Super Bowl with that team.

The fact that other QBs could win with this team doesnt make them better than Wilson.

 

[bksballer89]

You guys get your Jimmy's rustled too easily. Is Wilson hands down better than any of the 12 listed? You can make a case either way

 

[JDM]

The fact that other QBs could win with this team doesnt make them better than Wilson.

It doesn't, but Wilson hasn't shown anything to indicate he is better than anyone.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

13 is perfectly fair. At least that many would have won a Super Bowl with that team.

Mmmm, funny that you didn't think the Seahawks were all that good and your money was on the 49ers all the way last year, you still think their better this year. Yet you come here and say a dozen QBs would of won the Super Bowl with that team( the Seahawks). Your opinions conflict JDM and aren't logical.

 

[JDM]

Wilson did nothing to make the difference. Nothing at all. QB play was a complete non factor in the Super Bowl run.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

It doesn't, but Wilson hasn't shown anything to indicate he is better than anyone.

Sure he has, but you would have had to see all the Seahawks games to understand. We'll revisit this subject next off season, I'm betting your singing a different tune then.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Wilson did nothing to make the difference. Nothing at all. QB play was a complete non factor in the Super Bowl run.

Your full of shit JDM.

 

[Dolemite censored]

13 is perfectly fair. At least that many would have won a Super Bowl with that team.

Wilson is much better right now than all other QBs, except Brady and Manning.

I got to watch all of his games and what struck me is that he creates time to throw (never to just run when the pocket breaks down), is accurate, has touch, has a gun for an arm, makes intelligent decisions, doesn't take big hits and doesn't panic, and is in complete control of the offense.

His preparation regimen is better than Brady's or Mannings.

He should have been the SB MVP.

 

[Dolemite censored]

Wilson is much better right now than all other QBs, except Brady and Manning.

I got to watch all of his games and what struck me is that he creates time to throw (never to just run when the pocket breaks down), is accurate, has touch, has a gun for an arm, makes intelligent decisions, doesn't take big hits and doesn't panic, and is in complete control of the offense.

His preparation regimen is better than Brady's or Mannings.

He should have been the SB MVP.

On the contrary, RGIII takes HUGE hits as shown here:

 

[RoboticDreams]

Wilson did nothing to make the difference. Nothing at all. QB play was a complete non factor in the Super Bowl run.

I like this guy.

 

[jakedog56]

Seahawks fans who have had to live with some horrible QBs over the years can certainly tell the difference between good and bad. Wilson has "it" and he is a winner. He carries himself better on the field than any other Seahawk QB ever.

You have to remember that Hasselback, Moon (only 2 seasons), Krieg, and Zorn were the best QBs of this franchise. In the meantime it was the likes of Jon Kitna, Stan Gelbaugh, Dan McGwire, Rick Mirer, Kelly Stouffer, Jeff Kemp, John Friesz, etc.

 

[bksballer89]

Wilson is much better right now than all other QBs, except Brady and Manning.

I got to watch all of his games and what struck me is that he creates time to throw (never to just run when the pocket breaks down), is accurate, has touch, has a gun for an arm, makes intelligent decisions, doesn't take big hits and doesn't panic, and is in complete control of the offense.

His preparation regimen is better than Brady's or Mannings.

He should have been the SB MVP.

Wow so Wilson is the 3rd best QB in the league?

 

[Smart]

13 is perfectly fair. At least that many would have won a Super Bowl with that team.

It doesn't, but Wilson hasn't shown anything to indicate he is better than anyone.

Right...did you see the Super Bowl? Did you see the way Peyton Manning responded to pressure? Do you really think Seattle would have home field advantage with him at QB? Would they have beaten Carolina in the opener with Peyton getting blitzed no-stop with no running game to save him? Do you really think Manning throws less than three interceptions, let alone zero? What about the Tampa or Houston games?

I'll go out and say it. Aaron Rodgers is the only QB in the league other than Wilson who would have led Seattle to a Super Bowl. Seattle had a terrible line, and Rodgers is the only elite QB besides Wilson who had shown he could handle pressure.

And as for the trollish second post, it's just beyond hilarious. #2 QB Rating in NFL history. #2 in YPA in NFL History. #1 in TD Percentage in NFL History. Yep, nothing at all that would indicate he is better than anyone else....

 

[SonnyCID]

Wilson did nothing to make the difference. Nothing at all. QB play was a complete non factor in the Super Bowl run.

Yea, and a lot of QBS could have won SBs with Ty Law and Willie McGinest breaking postseason records on the other side.

 

[SonnyCID]

It doesn't, but Wilson hasn't shown anything to indicate he is better than anyone.

I guess it will take a couple of years of him outplaying Brady before you realize whats happening.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Right...did you see the Super Bowl? Did you see the way Peyton Manning responded to pressure? Do you really think Seattle would have home field advantage with him at QB? Would they have beaten Carolina in the opener with Peyton getting blitzed no-stop with no running game to save him? Do you really think Manning throws less than three interceptions, let alone zero? What about the Tampa or Houston games?

I'll go out and say it. Aaron Rodgers is the only QB in the league other than Wilson who would have led Seattle to a Super Bowl. Seattle had a terrible line, and Rodgers is the only elite QB besides Wilson who had shown he could handle pressure.

And as for the trollish second post, it's just beyond hilarious. #2 QB Rating in NFL history. #2 in YPA in NFL History. #1 in TD Percentage in NFL History. Yep, nothing at all that would indicate he is better than anyone else....

Right on the money Smart, but don't waste your breath on facts with JDM. He never let's facts sway him.

 

[boogiewithstu2007]

Wilson did nothing to make the difference. Nothing at all. QB play was a complete non factor in the Super Bowl run.

I will assume your being sarcastic...

 

[SeattleCoug]

Wilson did nothing to make the difference. Nothing at all. QB play was a complete non factor in the Super Bowl run.

I doubt you watched all 19 games then. I specifically recall them being down 10-0 in the NFC championship game and Wilson scrambling around to find Baldwin on a 50 yard bomb. That play arguably changed the game because the offense had done nothing up to that point. Not every QB makes that play.

Also they were down double digits in games against Houston and Tampa Bay when the defense wasn't having its best day and he made plays to bring them back to win those games. Look the defense won a lot of games sure but not all of them. Without Russell and insert T Jack they probably finish around
10-6 or so.

Guys like Stafford, Romo may throw for a lot of yards because they need to but have they shown they can make plays in December/January with the game on the line. Isnt that what the QB rankings should be about?

 

[SeattleCoug]

It doesn't, but Wilson hasn't shown anything to indicate he is better than anyone.

Most wins for a QB in his first two years. Tied for most TD passes for a rookie and through the first two years. Career QB rating of 100.6 with 52 Tds and 19 Ints.

In the playoffs he is 4-1 career. He has 6 Tds and 1 Int with a rating of 102. The one Int he threw came on a Hail Mary before halftime. In the one loss @ Atlanta he set a rookie record for passing yards with 385 and nearly single handedly brought them back from a 20 point deficit.

But he has shown nothing your right