Ranking all 32 QBs for 2019.

[rmilia1]

I'll just do top 12

1. Brady
2. Mahomes
3. Brees
4. Wilson
5. Ryan
6. Rivers
7. Luck
8. Rodgers
9. Goff
10. Watson
11. Prescott
12. Mayfield

 

[Tapey]

I'll just do top 12

1. Brady
2. Mahomes
3. Brees
4. Wilson
5. Ryan
6. Rivers
7. Luck
8. Rodgers
9. Goff
10. Watson
11. Prescott
12. Mayfield

Lol

 

[rmilia1]

Lol

Where do you disagree most ?

 

[megalodon30]

1. Brady
2. Wilson
3. Brees
4. Rodgers
5. Luck
6. Roethlisberger
7. Rivers
8. Mahommes
9. Ryan
10. Wentz
11. Goff
12. Watson
13. Stafford
14. Newton
15. Foles
16. Garappollo
17. Prescott
18. Mayfield
19. Cousins
20. Dalton
21. Trubisky
22. Mariota
23. Keenum/Haskins
24. Carr
25. Winston
26. Flacco/Lock
27. Darnold
28. Jackson
29. Allen
30. Rosen
31. Manning/Jones
32. Murray

 

[Tapey]

Where do you disagree most ?

With Goff and Watson being top 10

 

[rmilia1]

With Goff and Watson being top 10

Interesting . 8-12 or so is really close imo but id think most would have those 2 top 10. Maybe top 12

 

[Tapey]

Interesting . 8-12 or so is really close imo but id think most would have those 2 top 10. Maybe top 12

I would put Dak, Wentz, Mayfield and probably even Newton in front of Watson and Goff

 

[megalodon30]

I would put Dak, Wentz, Mayfield and probably even Newton in front of Watson and Goff

Goff is in line with Mahommes. Both proved they have talent last season, they just need to prove they can perform consistently. One good year does not make a QB elite. Unless Mrs. Chaney is watching you play.

 

[Tapey]

Goff is in line with Mahommes. Both proved they have talent last season, they just need to prove they can perform consistently. One good year does not make a QB elite. Unless Mrs. Chaney is watching you play.

Right which is way I wouldnt put Goff in the top 10

 

[BostonBlackie]

1. Brady

2. Wilson - overrated
3. Brees - overrated
4. Rodgers - overrated
5. Luck - overrated
6. Roethlisberger - overrated
7. Rivers - overrated
8. Mahomes - overrated
9. Ryan - overrated
10. Wentz - overrated
11. Goff - overrated
12. Watson - overrated
13. Stafford - overrated
14. Newton - overrated
15. Foles - overrated
16. Garappollo - overrated
17. Prescott - overrated
18. Mayfield - overrated
19. Cousins - overrated
20. Dalton - overrated
21. Trubisky - overrated
22. Mariota - overrated
23. Keenum/Haskins - overrated
24. Carr - overrated
25. Winston - overrated
26. Flacco/Lock - overrated
27. Darnold - overrated
28. Jackson - overrated
29. Allen - overrated
30. Rosen - overrated
31. Manning/Jones - overrated
32. Murray - overrated

 

[NWPATSFAN]

My top five...

Rodgers/Green Bay
Rodgers/Green Bay
Rodgers/Green Bay
Rodgers/Green Bay
Rodgers/Green Bay


FIFY

 

[megalodon30]

@Across The Field what's funny about my rankings? Curious of your rating.

 

[Clayton]

@Across The Field what's funny about my rankings? Curious of your rating.

Keenum/Haskins at 23 seems pretty bold. I thought Keenum was one of the worst QBs in the league last year.

Mahomes at #8 is interesting because he has already beat your team 3 times so some might see it as homerish. I don't think thats a terrible ranking, though, because you could argue that he is in for regression because we don't have a massive sample size.

On the other end, though, Brady and Brees might be in for regression because of their age. As such, these rankings are pretty silly as a whole to even do because when the old guys fall off a cliff, its going to be pretty steep. Until then, though, I agree with the consensus that you respect what they've done and rank them at and near the top.

edit - just saw you had Mayfield at 18. Thats probably what he was laughing at

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Were it not for Mahomes, Mayfield's performance as a 1st year starter would be generating a great deal more hype, I suspect.

 

[megalodon30]

Keenum/Haskins at 23 seems pretty bold. I thought Keenum was one of the worst QBs in the league last year.

Mahomes at #8 is interesting because he has already beat your team 3 times so some might see it as homerish. I don't think thats a terrible ranking, though, because you could argue that he is in for regression because we don't have a massive sample size.

On the other end, though, Brady and Brees might be in for regression because of their age. As such, these rankings are pretty silly as a whole to even do because when the old guys fall off a cliff, its going to be pretty steep. Until then, though, I agree with the consensus that you respect what they've done and rank them at and near the top.

Keenum proved in Minnesota that with decent enough coaching, he can manage a game well enough. He didn't have decent coaching in Denver.

Mahommes I'm hesitant to put higher. Part of that is he's a rival, but part of it is I want to see him prove he is legit. The 10th game Colin Kaepernick ever started was a Super Bowl. He was out of the league just a few short years later. If Patrick can prove last year was who he really is on a cosistnent basis, he'll have the #1 spot on these lists for a good long while.

And I was really hesitant to put a lot of the older guys on this list so high as well. Brees I wanted to put lower, Ben, Rodgers, Rivers. I just don't see a whole lot of younger talent being at these guys level, at least when these guys were in their prime. So their rankings are for services rendered while the young guys continue to develop.

And until Brady misses a Super Bowl, he's still No. 1 as far as I can see.

 

[Clayton]

Keenum proved in Minnesota that with decent enough coaching, he can manage a game well enough. He didn't have decent coaching in Denver.

Mahommes I'm hesitant to put higher. Part of that is he's a rival, but part of it is I want to see him prove he is legit. The 10th game Colin Kaepernick ever started was a Super Bowl. He was out of the league just a few short years later. If Patrick can prove last year was who he really is on a cosistnent basis, he'll have the #1 spot on these lists for a good long while.

And I was really hesitant to put a lot of the older guys on this list so high as well. Brees I wanted to put lower, Ben, Rodgers, Rivers. I just don't see a whole lot of younger talent being at these guys level, at least when these guys were in their prime. So their rankings are for services rendered while the young guys continue to develop.

And until Brady misses a Super Bowl, he's still No. 1 as far as I can see.

I can get being hesitant on Mahomes for a small sample size but then you turn around and say Keenum is legit because of one year while ignoring the other 4+ years where he played like a backup.

 

[Across The Field]

@Across The Field what's funny about my rankings? Curious of your rating.

1. Brady - Still a good QB, but if this is a ranking of just QBs for the season, he's not #1. He didn't come close to leading the league in any category last year. Admittedly, he's the GOAT, but he's not the best QB in the NFL anymore.

8. Mahommes - You've gotta be kidding me having him this low. He's the reigning MVP and you barely have him top 10 at his own position? Come on.

9. Ryan - This is also far too low. 3rd in yards, 3rd in TD, 4th in QB rating, with only 7 INTs. He's top 5.

13. Stafford - You have to be kidding me having him in the top 15. Having him ahead of Newton, Prescott, Mayfield, and Cousins is absurd.

16. Garappollo - Based on what? The guy has proven nothing whatsoever.

17. Prescott - While I don't think he's elite, he's a top 15 QB no questions asked.

18. Mayfield - Breaks the rookie TD record in 13 games, was rated the 8th best QB per PFF, adds one of the top WRs in the NFL, and he's barely top 20? Give me a break.

19. Cousins - 70% comp, 30 TD, 10 INT, 4300 yards, the guy is a top 10 QB.

 

[megalodon30]

I can get being hesitant on Mahomes for a small sample size but then you turn around and say Keenum is legit because of one year while ignoring the other 4+ years where he played like a backup.

I said he proved he can manage a game. He has proved throughout his career he is a mediocre QB. Not like 23 is a great ranking. Are the 9 below him considerably better than him?

Either way you slice it, I have Keenum a bottom 10 QB and Mahommes a top 10 QB. Do either deserve much different?

 

[Clayton]

19. Cousins - 70% comp, 30 TD, 10 INT, 4300 yards, the guy is a top 10 QB.

Redskins literally thought he was too mediocre to pay.

On the Vikings he had 7.1 YPA and managed to miss the playoffs with one of the most talented teams in the league. Only had 1 4th quarter comeback last year and 0 game winning drives. Ranked 14th-19th in various footballoutsiders rankings.

He is a Matt Stafford and not a franchise QB until he proves it imo. I might be a little low on him but he isnt anywhere near top 10

 

[rmilia1]

Most of these rankings occur in groupings . QBs in the 4-12 range are all similar same for 13-17 and on and on . I've got Ryan at 5 but if someone wants to put him at 9 it's not going to outrage me . I've got Rodgers at 8 when most have him higher but 8 shouldn't make anyone angry . Now if someone ranks a guy 15 spots too high or low then we can talk