Ranking QBs by division

[Battlelyon]

AFC North:
Big Ben
Jackson
Mayfield
Burrow

AFC East:
Allen
Fitsmagic
Darnold
Stidham

AFC West:
Mahommes
Carr
Lock
Herbert

AFC South:
Watson
Rivers
Tannehill
Minshew

NFC North:
Rodgers
Cousins
Stafford
Foles

NFC East:
Wentz
Prescott
Jones
Haskins

NFC West:
Wilson
Goff
Jimmy G
Murray

NFC South:
Brady
Brees
Ryan
Bridgewater

 

[rmilia1]

Are we supposed to be rankings these guys based on their career so far or based on our opinion of them going forward from this year on? Obviously that changes a shit ton of the rankings

 

[megalodon30]

Are we supposed to be rankings these guys based on their career so far or based on our opinion of them going forward from this year on? Obviously that changes a shit ton of the rankings

It's all opinion so rank them how you wish. I went this year and moving forward. It's why I have Brady 3rd in the NFC South. I see other's have him no. 1 in the division. But for me looking ahead, there's no way I'm putting him ahead of Brees and even saying he is currently better than Matt Rayn is a bit of a stretch.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

AFC North:

Jackson
Mayfield
Roethlisberger
Burrow

AFC East:

Tagovailoa
Darnold
Stidham
Allen

AFC West:

Mahomes
Carr
Lock
Taylor

AFC South:

Watson
Tannehill
Rivers
Minshew

NFC North:

Rodgers
Stafford
Cousins
Foles

NFC East:

Prescott
Wentz
Jones
Haskins

NFC West:

Wilson
Murray
Garoppolo
Goff

NFC South:

Brees
Ryan
Brady
Bridgewater

 

[Wamu]

Wentz ahead of Prescott right now? Now that's a joke. Dak's yet to miss a game & has won in the playoffs. Carson can't stay health. In 4 years has only started all 16 games in a season twice. And has yet to win a playoff game.

And Mayfield ahead on BigBen?

 

[Fountain City Blues]

I stopped when I saw Baker ahead of Ben. Go get some fresh air pal

Ye have more faith in that elbow of Ben's than I do.

 

[megalodon30]

AFC North:

Jackson
Mayfield
Roethlisberger
Burrow

AFC East:

Tagovailoa
Darnold
Stidham
Allen

AFC West:

Mahomes
Carr
Lock
Taylor

AFC South:

Watson
Tannehill
Rivers
Minshew

NFC North:

Rodgers
Stafford
Cousins
Foles

NFC East:

Prescott
Wentz
Jones
Haskins

NFC West:

Wilson
Murray
Garoppolo
Goff

NFC South:

Brees
Ryan
Brady
Bridgewater

I really like these rankings. Gold star to Moose.

I was tempted to put Tua up in the East; they're all just big question marks in that division really.

 

[rmilia1]

AFC WEST

MAHOMES
CARR
LOCK
TAYLOR

AFC SOUTH

WATSON
RIVERS
TANNEHILL
MINSCHEW

AFC EAST

ALLEN
TUA
DARNOLD
STIDHAM

AFC NORTH

JACKSON
BURROW
MAYFIELD
BIG BEN

NFC WEST

WILSON
MURRAY
GOFF
JIMMY G

NFC SOUTH

RYAN
BREES
BRADY
BRIDGEWATER

NFC EAST

DAK
WENTZ
JONES
HASKINS

NFC NORTH

RODGERS
COUSINS
STAFFORD
FOLES

- I did mine looking forward for who id want the next 3 years

 

[megalodon30]

AFC WEST

MAHOMES
CARR
LOCK
TAYLOR

AFC SOUTH

WATSON
RIVERS
TANNEHILL
MINSCHEW

AFC EAST

ALLEN
TUA
DARNOLD
STIDHAM

AFC NORTH

JACKSON
BURROW
MAYFIELD
BIG BEN

NFC WEST

WILSON
MURRAY
GOFF
JIMMY G

NFC SOUTH

RYAN
BREES
BRADY
BRIDGEWATER

NFC EAST

DAK
WENTZ
JONES
HASKINS

NFC NORTH

RODGERS
COUSINS
STAFFORD
FOLES

- I did mine looking forward for who id want the next 3 years

I'm not huge on Burrow, but good list. I agree with most of it. If we're looking 3 years ahead, I'd be tempted to move Teddy B over Brady.

 

[rmilia1]

I'm not huge on Burrow, but good list. I agree with most of it. If we're looking 3 years ahead, I'd be tempted to move Teddy B over Brady.

I thought about having him at 2 actually and i probably would if i knew for sure he was going to start past this year . I think Brees and Brady are both done within 2 years. Same for Big Ben

 

[sonnyblack65]

Ye have more faith in that elbow of Ben's than I do.

When the NFL picks back up, we can do a 1 month AV bet on who has better stats. You can even give me Mark Mangino, if you choose

 

[sonnyblack65]

I really like these rankings. Gold star to Moose.

I was tempted to put Tua up in the East; they're all just big question marks in that division really.

Moose is a homer, he has Mahomes over Lock??

 

[Southieinnc]

Jimmy G is not better than Goff, Jimmy G was carried to the Super Bowl while playing like complete garbage at home during the playoffs. Goff was at least decent and won on the road. Not to mention Jimmy G has only had one good season and is older. Goff's best season was better too.
So there is no argument for Jimmy G over Goff.

13 - 3?????

 

[megalodon30]

Moose is a homer, he has Mahomes over Lock??

Yes, Moose is a homer. But even I have to admit Mahomes has a slight edge over Lock right now.

 

[Battlelyon]

13 - 3?????

So what, the 49ers didn't go 13-3 because of Jimmy G, they had a great defense and the second best running game.

 

[Southieinnc]

So what, the 49ers didn't go 13-3 because of Jimmy G, they had a great defense and the second best running game.

Goff 3 points in SB
Garappolo 20 points.

You said there is no argument.....

 

[jarntt]

Is it? If half of your wins are close wins, it means that either you're carrying a trash franchise or you aren't getting enough done the other 3 Quarters.

Now, there is a good argument that the Raiders have just been completely garbage but if Carr has the Worst W/L record in the NFL then I think its fair for people to push him down the rankings

You said half of his wins are come from behind wins. That is an absolute measure of being a good QB and something that QBs are graded and praised on and so are close wins. I don't think you are arguing what you think you are.

 

[Clayton]

You said half of his wins are come from behind wins. That is an absolute measure of being a good QB and something that QBs are graded and praised on and so are close wins. I don't think you are arguing what you think you are.

I think your overall win percentage matters, though. If you're on a good team and you have a lot of heroics then you're a good QB. If your record is the worst in the NFL and half of your wins are tight games then you just might stink.

Amari Cooper is better on the Cowboys, right?

 

[jarntt]

I think your overall win percentage matters, though. If you're on a good team and you have a lot of heroics then you're a good QB. If your record is the worst in the NFL and half of your wins are tight games then you just might stink.

Amari Cooper is better on the Cowboys, right?

I totally agree that winning % matters, but I think sometimes that is out of your control to an extent. I don't think any one stat is the "be all end all" indicator, but most of them are to at least some degree pertinent

 

[Battlelyon]

Goff 3 points in SB
Garappolo 20 points.

You said there is no argument.....

By your logic Flacco won the Super Bowl in spite of his great defense. Hell the Ravens scored 34 in the Super Bowl