RememberTheKoy Presents: The Definitive Ranking of the 32 Starting QBs in the NFL as of April 2023

[RememberTheKoy]

1. Mahomes
2. Hurts
3. Burrow
4. Allen
5. Herbert
6. Jackson
7. Rodgers
8. Tua
9. Prescott
10. Lawrence
11. Goff
12. Cousins
13. Geno
14. Purdy
15. Jimmy G
16. Murray
17. Daniel Jones
18. Fields
19. Carr
20. Minshew
21. Pickett
22. Watson
23. Stafford
24. Brissett
25. Mac Jones
26. Love
27. Ridder
28. Tannehill
29. Dalton
30. Russell Wilson
31. Mayfield
32. Mills

 

[Dude]

Not a bad list but hardly definitive.

 

[Lake Shore Drive]

I'll just touch on a number of these:

1. Mahomes - The undisputed king
2. Hurts
3. Burrow
4. Allen - One too many dumb INTs prevents him from being #2 on this list
5. Herbert
6. Jackson
7. Rodgers- Two years ago this ranking would have been embarrassingly low, now it may be too high
8. Tua
9. Prescott
10. Lawrence - Something tells me by year end he'll end up in the top 5
11. Goff
12. Cousins
13. Geno
14. Purdy - Love that a "Mr. Irrelevant" has had such a huge start to his career, but I'm not sure he's an upper tier QB yet
15. Jimmy G
16. Murray
17. Daniel Jones
18. Fields - Rootin' for my dawg to end this season in the top 10, but right now ranked #18 might be a touch generous
19. Carr
20. Minshew
21. Pickett
22. Watson
23. Stafford - One year and a couple injuries removed from the SB and suddenly he's just the 23rd best?
24. Brissett
25. Mac Jones
26. Love
27. Ridder
28. Tannehill
29. Dalton - Beware the wrath of one Mrs. Chaney
30. Russell Wilson - He had a bad '22 no doubt, but a career 100.2 QB rating deserves a higher ranking
31. Mayfield
32. Mills

 

[RememberTheKoy]

I'll just touch on a number of these:

1. Mahomes - The undisputed king
2. Hurts
3. Burrow
4. Allen - One too many dumb INTs prevents him from being #2 on this list
5. Herbert
6. Jackson
7. Rodgers- Two years ago this ranking would have been embarrassingly low, now it may be too high
8. Tua
9. Prescott
10. Lawrence - Something tells me by year end he'll end up in the top 5
11. Goff
12. Cousins
13. Geno
14. Purdy - Love that a "Mr. Irrelevant" has had such a huge start to his career, but I'm not sure he's an upper tier QB yet
15. Jimmy G
16. Murray
17. Daniel Jones
18. Fields - Rootin' for my dawg to end this season in the top 10, but right now ranked #18 might be a touch generous
19. Carr
20. Minshew
21. Pickett
22. Watson
23. Stafford - One year and a couple injuries removed from the SB and suddenly he's just the 23rd best?
24. Brissett
25. Mac Jones
26. Love
27. Ridder
28. Tannehill
29. Dalton - Beware the wrath of one Mrs. Chaney
30. Russell Wilson - He had a bad '22 no doubt, but a career 100.2 QB rating deserves a higher ranking
31. Mayfield
32. Mills

I strongly believe that Stafford might just be washed at this point. A lot of miles and a lot of wear and tear on him. He's 35 so it's not like it's abnormal for him to have fallen off a cliff. Guys like Brady, Rodgers, Favre and Manning aren't the norm to continue to bre great into their late 30s and sometimes into their 40s.

Same goes for Russell although he hasn't had to deal with the injuries but he looked like absolute ass last season. Doesn't help matters that he's become a bit of a diva who his teammates hate.

 

[SteelersPride]

I strongly believe that Stafford might just be washed at this point. A lot of miles and a lot of wear and tear on him. He's 35 so it's not like it's abnormal for him to have fallen off a cliff. Guys like Brady, Rodgers, Favre and Manning aren't the norm to continue to bre great into their late 30s and sometimes into their 40s.

Same goes for Russell although he hasn't had to deal with the injuries but he looked like absolute ass last season. Doesn't help matters that he's become a bit of a diva who his teammates hate.

I agree with all of this. Pretty decent list too. Few id flip but but not bad at all.

 

[Anointed One]

Probably going to get some hate but Dak is too high for me... I'd rather have 5 or 6 QB's over him beginning with Goff, Lawrence, Carr, Jones, Geno, Cousins, Stafford...

Purdy is too high as well...

 

[Cyder]

Probably going to get some hate but Dak is too high for me... I'd rather have 5 or 6 QB's over him beginning with Goff, Lawrence, Carr, Jones, Geno, Cousins, Stafford...

Purdy is too high as well...

Dak was really bad last year so your point is valid. Same with Purdy, he was a solid game manager until getting hurt but didn't exactly light it up.

 

[Thruthefog]

LOL @ a QB nobody wants being ranked #6.

 

[jarntt]

1. Mahomes
2. Hurts
3. Burrow
4. Allen
5. Herbert
6. Jackson
7. Rodgers
8. Tua
9. Prescott
10. Lawrence
11. Goff
12. Cousins
13. Geno
14. Purdy
15. Jimmy G
16. Murray
17. Daniel Jones
18. Fields
19. Carr
20. Minshew
21. Pickett
22. Watson
23. Stafford
24. Brissett
25. Mac Jones
26. Love
27. Ridder
28. Tannehill
29. Dalton
30. Russell Wilson
31. Mayfield
32. Mills

You lost your right to post your BS, biased crap opinions when you hid like a little girl after your team lost and your months of bravado and shit talking blew up in your face

 

[RememberTheKoy]

You lost your right to post your BS, biased crap opinions when you hid like a little girl after your team lost and your months of bravado and shit talking blew up in your face

Where is the bias in this list?

 

[ducky]

Hurts had a great year last year but I have a tough time rating him over Allen or Burrow still.

....maybe if he replicates it. But he needs to replicate before you can get him that far up the list.

 

[PDay8810]

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Hurts had a great year last year but I have a tough time rating him over Allen or Burrow still.

....maybe if he replicates it. But he needs to replicate before you can get him that far up the list.

The weakness of the NFC at that position seems to be clouding some minds there along with recency bias. Burrow and Allen still exist, as you've mentioned.

 

[Rowdy]

I'll just touch on a number of these:

1. Mahomes - The undisputed king
2. Hurts
3. Burrow
4. Allen - One too many dumb INTs prevents him from being #2 on this list
5. Herbert
6. Jackson
7. Rodgers- Two years ago this ranking would have been embarrassingly low, now it may be too high
8. Tua
9. Prescott
10. Lawrence - Something tells me by year end he'll end up in the top 5
11. Goff
12. Cousins
13. Geno
14. Purdy - Love that a "Mr. Irrelevant" has had such a huge start to his career, but I'm not sure he's an upper tier QB yet
15. Jimmy G
16. Murray
17. Daniel Jones
18. Fields - Rootin' for my dawg to end this season in the top 10, but right now ranked #18 might be a touch generous
19. Carr
20. Minshew
21. Pickett
22. Watson
23. Stafford - One year and a couple injuries removed from the SB and suddenly he's just the 23rd best?
24. Brissett
25. Mac Jones
26. Love
27. Ridder
28. Tannehill
29. Dalton - Beware the wrath of one Mrs. Chaney
30. Russell Wilson - He had a bad '22 no doubt, but a career 100.2 QB rating deserves a higher ranking
31. Mayfield
32. Mills

Sounds like you think brissett will start over Howell? It wouldn’t surprise me if he did

 

[Ickey Shuffle]

2. Hurts
3. Burrow

 

[PDay8810]

Probably going to get some hate but Dak is too high for me... I'd rather have 5 or 6 QB's over him beginning with Goff, Lawrence, Carr, Jones, Geno, Cousins, Stafford...

Purdy is too high as well...

shit no dude. You are correct. It's hard to see Prescott get better after his last season.

no hate...your opinion is as good as the next guys.

 

[RememberTheKoy]

Both have taken their teams to the Super Bowl in their second season as starter. Jalen Hurts though played much better in the Super Bowl. Jalen Hurts unlike Burrow has been named an All Pro QB and has received a MVP vote.

 

[PDay8810]

Both have taken their teams to the Super Bowl in their second season as starter. Jalen Hurts though played much better in the Super Bowl. Jalen Hurts unlike Burrow has been named an All Pro QB and has received a MVP vote.

you really should just read the threads for the most part and ease back in.
Being the tallest Philly SportsHoopla fan midget really isn't all that great.

 

[Lake Shore Drive]

Sounds like you think brissett will start over Howell? It wouldn’t surprise me if he did

Not really, I just didn't feel like commenting on every single QB that's ranked here. I do like Brissett tho and was kinda hoping the Bears would ink him, altho it would have been strictly as a backup. And I feel he's earned the right to at least try to win the starting job.

 

[RememberTheKoy]

Hurts had a great year last year but I have a tough time rating him over Allen or Burrow still.

....maybe if he replicates it. But he needs to replicate before you can get him that far up the list.

Allen is way too reckless with his passes. He had some really bad interceptions last year, especially in the red zone. I can't put someone who consistently makes such bad decisions higher than Hurts when Hirts is coming off a season where he would have won MVP if he didn't miss two games and then had a historically great Super Bowl performance.