Justinkm83
Well-Known Member
For the money being paid Fielder will be a fielder. Know its of marginal importance but #6AL FPCT versus #4AL FPCT at 1b between the two doesn't make that much difference.
I honestly would not be surprised to see Mitch gone by ST. Great guy and fan favorite but carrying two LH 1bmen with near identical fielding strength just to DH one of them creates a backup problem ... unless you have a backup catcher like Chirinos.
Platoon's don't work.
Fielder only had 6 errors last year which is much less than he normally has. He is a poor defender though. Fielder's WAR was -2.9, and Mitch's was -0.6. It's not as close as you think. Mitch saves a lot of errors on throws by his IF's. Fielder is not good at scooping them out of the dirt. I'm not sure why you think their fielding is near identical.