Seahawks vs Cowboys

[Sportsdude101]

I like the Seahawks and I like the Packers. I went to a few game back when Chuck Knox was the coach (better uniforms too)

 

[SonnyCID]

I'll admit that Seattle has improved since that play but it was still a bad call. Of course you homer Seahawks fans can never admit it.

Why can't you admit that whether they blew the call or doesn't matter? The tape doesn't show the safety complete the play.

 

[GNG]

I like the Seahawks and I like the Packers. I went to a few game back when Chuck Knox was the coach (better uniforms too)

I agree. The Seahawks once had nice looking uniforms.

 

[Sportsdude101]

Why can't you admit that whether they blew the call or doesn't matter? The tape doesn't show the safety complete the play.

Disregard the tape for a minute, why did 2 refs standing 5 feet apart come up with different conclusions?

 

[GNG]

I agree. The Seahawks once had nice looking uniforms.

The Cowboys have classic looking uniforms.

 

[octagondd]

I'll admit that Seattle has improved since that play but it was still a bad call. Of course you homer Seahawks fans can never admit it.

Based on what? Tate touched the ball first, Tate controlled the ball through out the catch, at no point did one player control the ball over another player, Tate hit the ground first. What part of the simultaneous catch rule do you have an issue with. Was Miles Austin's catch a catch or an interception by Cromartie?

 

[GNG]

Disregard the tape for a minute, why did 2 refs standing 5 feet apart come up with different conclusions?

These were replacement refs in over their heads and afraid to make the correct call because of a possible fan riot.

 

[Sportsdude101]

Disregard the tape for a minute, why did 2 refs standing 5 feet apart come up with different conclusions?

Because they were idiot virgin refs

 

[octagondd]

Disregard the tape for a minute, why did 2 refs standing 5 feet apart come up with different conclusions?

Because one could only see the backs of the players and not the ball and the other saw the ball throughout the catch.

 

[GNG]

Based on what? Tate touched the ball first, Tate controlled the ball through out the catch, at no point did one player control the ball over another player, Tate hit the ground first. What part of the simultaneous catch rule do you have an issue with. Was Miles Austin's catch a catch or an interception by Cromartie?

If you think Tate actually had possession I have some swamp land I'd like to sell you.

 

[Sportsdude101]

Based on what? Tate touched the ball first, Tate controlled the ball through out the catch, at no point did one player control the ball over another player, Tate hit the ground first. What part of the simultaneous catch rule do you have an issue with. Was Miles Austin's catch a catch or an interception by Cromartie?

You're wrong, it's obvious the Packer defender had his hands on the ball first

 

[GNG]

Fans throughout the nation knew the refs made the wrong call except Seattle fans.

COMEDY GOLD !!

 

[GNG]

You're wrong, it's obvious the Packer defender had his hands on the ball first

Agreed.

 

[Dolemite censored]

No argument here.

The ability to instantly recognize and act in open situations is his gift.

Montana is a good comparison.

They will never forget.

Seattle has been the better team ever since, a reversal of that win wouldn't change that.

Its not even significant as the Immaculate Reception and the Tuck Rule, which were in playoff games.

 

[octagondd]

If you think Tate actually had possession I have some swamp land I'd like to sell you.

Both of you need to read the link given and actually read the rule for simultaneous catch. If you think one handed catches are not control or possession I have a bridge in Arizona for you.

 

[GNG]

I didn't realize by bringing up the Fail Mary Pass that I'd get such a negative response. It must be like pulling a scab off an old wound.

 

[Sportsdude101]

In any event.. the Packers and Seahawks will meet in the NFCCG and the Seahawks will be a 3 point favorite. I won't bet on that game

 

[octagondd]

Fans throughout the nation knew the refs made the wrong call except Seattle fans.

COMEDY GOLD !!

That is comedy gold, because ya know, fans know the rules better than trained referees.

 

[GNG]

Both of you need to read the link given and actually read the rule for simultaneous catch. If you think one handed catches are not control or possession I have a bridge in Arizona for you.

You most likely never played football. It is obvious from your lack of knowledge.

 

[Dolemite censored]

You're wrong, it's obvious the Packer defender had his hands on the ball first

But he did not complete the process.

While in the air, Tate established simultaneous possession and hit the ground first with possession.

End of argument.