QB Rankings 2: Who is the Second Best QB in 2015?

[MHSL82]

Pretty straight forward. Right now, given their current age, not past prime (Peyton) or future prime (Luck), for 2015, who is the best QB in the NFL? If you believe either of those two will be the best NFL QB next year, vote for them, of course. Assume health (besides age or current known issues) and average to above average supporting cast.

Remember, this is for this coming year only.

Aaron Rodgers won by a landslide the first poll, getting 35 of the 50 votes. Big Ben got 6, followed by Andrew Luck (4), Tom Brady (3), and Peyton Manning (2). QB Rankings 1: Who is the Best QB in 2015?

I'm adding a lot of QBs in as options, but I do not think all will have a real case for being second ranked. Joe Flacco and Eli Manning are there because they've won SB(s). Matt Ryan, Philip Rivers, Matthew Stafford, and the rest will be added as we go. If you have an issue with someone being on the list, oh well. If you have an issue with someone not on the list, write in your choice.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Big Ben.

 

[NEPatsfan]

Pretty straight forward. Right now, given their current age, not past prime (Peyton) or future prime (Luck), for 2015, who is the best QB in the NFL? If you believe either of those two will be the best NFL QB next year, vote for them, of course. Assume health (besides age or current known issues) and average to above average supporting cast.

Remember, this is for this coming year only.

Aaron Rodgers won by a landslide the first poll, getting 35 of the 50 votes. Big Ben got 6, followed by Andrew Luck (4), Tom Brady (3), and Peyton Manning (2). QB Rankings 1: Who is the Best QB in 2015?

I'm adding a lot of QBs in as options, but I do not think all will have a real case for being second ranked. Joe Flacco and Eli Manning are there because they've won SB(s). Matt Ryan, Philip Rivers, Matthew Stafford, and the rest will be added as we go. If you have an issue with someone being on the list, oh well. If you have an issue with someone not on the list, write in your choice.

Like the approach, especially since the second placers, if you will, were mostly team fan votes I would bet.

 

[night]

Big Ben.

I've always thought of him as overrated.

 

[NEPatsfan]

I've always thought of him as overrated.

I always thought of his as top of the 2nd level list.

 

[night]

I always thought of his as top of the 2nd level list.

He's still pretty good and got a heck of a lot better all of the sudden in the past 3 seasons but he is definitely not top 5.

 

[Money]

I've always thought of him as overrated.

I always thought of his as top of the 2nd level list.

You both aren't taking into account that he plays in a very QB unfriendly division.

 

[PDay8810]

Remember, this is for this coming year only.

key point to all the madness...now hurt feelings commence

 

[boogiewithstu2007]

Brady, Manning is 3rd I'll cast my vote now ....

 

[DHoey]

If Peyton is healthy, I would have voted for him.

 

[cwood]

Gotta go with the GOAT, Mr. Peyton Manning. He'll be healthy again.

 

[sonnyblack65]

Brady, Manning is 3rd I'll cast my vote now ....

Manning was 3rd behind Rodgers and Brady when healthy, lets see if he stays there or drops

 

[boogiewithstu2007]

Manning was 3rd behind Rodgers and Brady when healthy, lets see if he stays there or drops

I agree with that...

 

[HammerDown]

Manning was 3rd behind Rodgers and Brady when healthy, lets see if he stays there or drops

Please, @sonnyblack65

How soon you forget just how bad he was last year.

 

[Scooby-Doo]

The fact that somebody voted for Tony Romo kinda makes me wanna vomit in my mouth.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

He's still pretty good and got a heck of a lot better all of the sudden in the past 3 seasons but he is definitely not top 5.

He's been top 5 or real close the last two or three years. He's got a heck of a receiving corp this up coming season. He's going to put up some really good numbers.
Broncos started going to a more base running offense last half of the season, not sure if that continues, but I think it does. Payton numbers will take a hit if it does. Brady looks to be missing some games. Yup I like Bens chances next season.

 

[Oldschool739]

The poll said for 2015, so although PM and Brady have been great, they are clearly on the downside of their careers and won't be around much longer, may not even get through this season uninjured, especially Forehead....
So with AR as the clear best with 4 or 5 yrs still to go, and Ben with maybe 3....
Call me a homer but my boy Joe Cool is 2nd best for 2015 and beyond IMO....
His record stands for itself, it's actually better than AR's in some aspects but AR is the man right now....

 

[GNG]

Tony Romo of course.

 

[GNG]

The fact that somebody voted for Tony Romo kinda makes me wanna vomit in my mouth.

Is this you?

 

[sonnyblack65]

Please, @sonnyblack65

How soon you forget just how bad he was last year.

He wasnt that bad, you forget Peyton was injured last few games when he threw like 10 int in 4 games, he deserves a pass