MarcoPolo
Huge member
I definitely hear ya, he sucks at the x's and o's, very Ozzie Guillen like.
But the dude took 3 different teams to the playoffs, one of the few to do that. Stays a long time each stop. So the question becomes, is managing kind of meaningless, where a shitty one can ride high on 3 different groups of talent, because he's kind of irrelevant? Or is he possibly kind of good at whatever managing is (motivation, tactics, whatever combo)?
I lean more toward the manager doesn't make that much difference.
Look at the teams "he" took to the playoffs - not chopped liver. He got handed great talent and fucked it up (and fucked up the talent in a few cases).