Foot Style trade approach

[Barilko]

Rogers + Demarco for Luck and J Hill

PPR Keeper

what side do you like

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I actually like the Luck side significantly more...

it is all because of Hill over demarco Murray...

 

[averagejoe]

What? No IDP?

Seriously... off the top of my head, with the addition of Gore, maybe Indy doesn't pass as much. Rodgers' and Luck's numbers were pretty close (except for the 22 turnovers Luck had (which was 2nd only to Cutler)).

And maybe Murray shares with Mathews, but he may still get goalline work. And since this is PPR, Murray is a good RB catching the ball. (64 targets last season).

I'm not saying that Hill has a bad year, but when it comes to the red zone, he still has to compete with AJ (6 TD), Bernard (7 TD) and Sanu as a fill-in had 6 TD (which might be ear-marked for Marvin Jones). Factoring PPR, Hill is low on targets/receptions.

I may stick with the Rodgers side.

 

[Barilko]

I have Murray..and have had him since day 1 im expecting some calls for him this year...

i have also had Gio Bernard since day 1
i saw Hill coming a mile away but one of my league partners surprised the you know what out of me and drafted him one spot ahead of me

he has Luck and loves Rodgers which had me thinking of chasing Hill
im pretty sure he would go for it..

However Joe i must say thank you for the homework and maybe i'll cool my jets and stand pat for now...

 

[wilwhite]

I would make that trade.

1. Youth is nice in a keeper league
2. Hill stays in his system; Murray goes from an awesome front line, dangerous QB and legit deep threat to... whatever's happening there in Philly
3. Murray's reception history is moot with Sproles on the team (not to mention Mathews)
4. Hill is 1-for-1 in playing all 16 games in a season; Murray is 1-for-4
5. Kelly might trade Murray to Jacksonville tomorrow for 3 punters and a mechanical banana

 

[leftypower]

I would make that trade.

1. Youth is nice in a keeper league
2. Hill stays in his system; Murray goes from an awesome front line, dangerous QB and legit deep threat to... whatever's happening there in Philly
3. Murray's reception history is moot with Sproles on the team (not to mention Mathews)
4. Hill is 1-for-1 in playing all 16 games in a season; Murray is 1-for-4
5. Kelly might trade Murray to Jacksonville tomorrow for 3 punters and a mechanical banana

 

[The Foot]

I would choose to have the Rodgers side. As good as Luck is Rodgers is still better and Murry has lost some value with the possible time share role in Philly but I think he is still worth more than a the time share that Hill will have in CIN.

 

[TKOSpikes]

I agree with Wil. Except for maybe his point number 5.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

What are the keeper rules and how long can a player be kept???

 

[Barilko]

I would make that trade.

1. Youth is nice in a keeper league
2. Hill stays in his system; Murray goes from an awesome front line, dangerous QB and legit deep threat to... whatever's happening there in Philly
3. Murray's reception history is moot with Sproles on the team (not to mention Mathews)
4. Hill is 1-for-1 in playing all 16 games in a season; Murray is 1-for-4
5. Kelly might trade Murray to Jacksonville tomorrow for 3 punters and a mechanical banana

Thanks WW and that no:5!

 

[Barilko]

What are the keeper rules and how long can a player be kept???

Too many Keeper rules to update here...we have franchised players and players Grandfathered from old rules to the new

however they can be kept for ever

basically the top 4 costs your 4 best draft spots....

 

[TREFF]

I'm firmly on the Luck side of this one. Colts seem poised to have an elite offense for years to come, I honestly have Luck ahead of Rodgers at this point for next season. And Hill will be a beast for longer than whatever time Murray had left

 

[The Foot]

I think I am going to switch to the luck side if you can keep them forever.

 

[Dawg]

I have andrew luck in my dynasty keeper league. Something about him tell me he's going to be a fantasy beast for the next 10 years. Can't believe i got him in the 2nd round when he came out of college. He's not there yet with rodgers,but he is very,very close. I like the luck and hill better. Murray has lost some value!!!!

 

[Barilko]

Thanks Dawg welcome back