Tell the future- Pick a QB

[cwalke3408]

Not close IMO...

I would easily take QB 2... I like my young QBs throwing the ball... don't care whether they throw interceptions...

I agree that I would like my QB to push the ball but with QB1 and QB2 having the same YPA/YPC, hard to say if QB2 pushes the ball downfield more than QB1. It looks like QB2 just have more pass attempts

 

[rmilia1]

Am I in an Abbott and Costello skit???
It isn't a start unless he starts

STats are through 64 starts but do NOT include only starts in the stats. I dont see how thats confusing lol.

Its like a baseball player playing in 160 games but he only starts 148. His stats are still from all 160

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I agree that I would like my QB to push the ball but with QB1 and QB2 having the same YPA/YPC, hard to say if QB2 pushes the ball downfield more than QB1. It looks like QB2 just have more pass attempts

well, I may have been tricked in that cousins played 6 more games than QB1... so the TDs #, and total yards might not be as impressive...

 

[rmilia1]

I guess if a QB goes in at the end of a game, take 3 kneel downs to end the game that counts.

Well sure but hed have no stats either in that game and its irrelevant anyway as all stats are through 64 starts

 

[Chewbaccer]

I’ll take QB1. Wins more and a whole lot less ints.

 

[Chewbaccer]

Well sure but hed have no stats either in that game and its irrelevant anyway as all stats are through 64 starts

He’d have stats, he’d have negative rushing yards. Somebody lost the SportsHoopla fantasy league a few years back because Jay Cutler kneeled down and lost rushing yards to end the game

 

[rmilia1]

well, I may have been tricked in that cousins played 6 more games than QB1... so the TDs #, and total yards might not be as impressive...

QB1 played in 75 games to get 64 starts although total minutes played in the 2 careers through 64 starts are about equal so youre ok with Cousins still if thats who youd take

 

[cwalke3408]

STats are through 64 starts but do NOT include only starts in the stats. I dont see how thats confusing lol.

Its like a baseball player playing in 160 games but he only starts 148. His stats are still from all 160

It's not that confusing and it's not necessary to answer the original question

 

[rmilia1]

He’d have stats, he’d have negative rushing yards. Somebody lost the SportsHoopla fantasy league a few years back because Jay Cutler kneeled down and lost rushing yards to end the game

True but neither of these 2 just came in to do kneel downs so we are ok lol

 

[molsaniceman]

ill take qb 1 tyvm

 

[rmilia1]

So
4 votes for QB1

2 for QB2

And 2 confused Cowboys fans

Seems right

 

[jarntt]

Total TDs is the key. Kaepernick

 

[rmilia1]

Total TDs is the key. Kaepernick

There you go!!

 

[Jiddy]

*crosses fingers*

Please not Trubisky...Please not Trubisky...

 

[rmilia1]

With all the talk of whether a team should sign him i just thought it was an interesting comp considering the buzz was "he wants starter money but isnt starter quality " when no one signed him in 17 yet Cousins ( with comparable stats/results ) got 84M guaranteed.

 

[jarntt]

There you go!!

This wording was the issue. It was hard to decipher what you were saying IMO

"through 64 starts regardless of whether the QB started"

You should have said something more like: total stats through the first 64 starts by the player regardless of how many total games played it took to get to those 64 starts.

when you look at how many fewer pass attempts by QB 1 it kind of changes the view on the interceptions. 59% comp % was my issue with QB 1 from the beginning. That's horrible.

 

[eaglesnut]

QB1s team actually had far more playoff success

No shit. That was easy to figure from the stats.

 

[Manster7588]

Total TDs is the key. Kaepernick

Dang it. I looked at him before it was said Playoffs are included. I saw 58 starts and didn't deep dive the numbers.

 

[Schmoopy1000]

All stats are through 64 starts by each QB so 64 W/L and yes they overlapped

how can you compare stats that way.

if he doesnt start but plays in 16 games in a 2 or three year span. You add those stats to his starting stats. but the other QB only has the 64 games of stats because he only played in games that he started.

Your stats will be skewed.

 

[rmilia1]

how can you compare stats that way.

if he doesnt start but plays in 16 games in a 2 or three year span. You add those stats to his starting stats. but the other QB only has the 64 games of stats because he only played in games that he started.

Your stats will be skewed.

Theyre not. So its ok lol