McNabb vs Kelly (HOFer)

[broncosmitty]

What is McNabb going to do in the next 4 years that will either make him HOF worthy or not?

Hopefully get a turkey leg stuck in his big fat mouth. Cuz I'm tired of listening to his fatass already. I think this conversation is silly. Chunky Soup is not a HOFer. Not now, not tomorrow, not evah.

 

[Ilovemesomeme]

I'm on the line. He could be the best QB and then the worst QB. I tired of seeing him throw balls directly in the dirt but I also felt when he was on he could make every throw.

I'm with you. He threw a lot of groundballs...................I don't think he should get in, personally I think it's a pretty easy call.

 

[jonvi]

Haters.

 

[JDM]

I'm with you. He threw a lot of groundballs...................I don't think he should get in, personally I think it's a pretty easy call.

I think it's silly that this is a topic. I don't think he's worthy of a discussion.

 

[RoboticDreams]

I'm with you. He threw a lot of groundballs...................I don't think he should get in, personally I think it's a pretty easy call.

His inconsistency is what turns my thumb down. He threw a better dirt ball than Tebow. That in itself shows his instability helped them lose. At his best he could carry a team but at his worst he could close the door on his team.

 

[jonvi]

37,276 yards worth of incosistency and ground balls.

 

[skins]

37,276 yards worth of incosistency and ground balls.

something in there about YAC




I think i just opened up a can of worms between BIS and Meat

 

[jonvi]

something in there about YAC

The only receiver of any quality was T.O. and he was a nut case. I guess during all that yac'n they got the ball to themselves.

But really...it's a valid debate. I like the guy....cause I saw him play since he got to SU. But I can see everyone's point about him not winning a superbowl.

 

[JDM]

37,276 yards worth of incosistency and ground balls.

That's good for 17th all time and he played in an era slanted heavily to the pass. It does not a hall of famer make.

 

[skins]

The only receiver of any quality was T.O. and he was a nut case. I guess during all that yac'n they got the ball to themselves.

But really...it's a valid debate. I like the guy....cause I saw him play since he got to SU. But I can see everyone's point about him not winning a superbowl.

it is a pass heavy league and mcnabb had a lot of receivers get over 500 yards catching in one season but no true #1 until that one season with TO.

 

[buried_in_snow]

Einstein, just curious as to why a Giants fan is tooting the horn of a known enemy so much?

First of I'm not tooting McNabb's horn. Just keeping things in perspective.
Second of all he's not a known enemy to me. Sports aren't that serious.
Third of all it's called "objectivity." Something one needs in order to participate in rational discourse.

Is there a racial aspect to this

jesus fucking christ... are you serious?

is he a sure fire HOF'r in your eyes?

Are you literate?

I'm not saying he's a lock to make the HOF... or even worthy of being inducted.

 

[buried_in_snow]

He's black.

only from the waist down

Kinda figured. Just wanted to know the variables before I commented further.

lol @ your desperation

 

[PhoenixEagles1]

He will make the Hall of Fame but not 1st ballot. He is top 10 in playoff wins and put mediocre teams on his back in the early 2000s and went deep in the playoffs. He also didnt choke in the SB. He had 386 yards passing and 3 TDs in that game. People say he choked cause he threw up but they forget a few plays after throwing up he threw an incredible pass for a TD with 5 mins left to bring Philly within 3 points. He was NEVER very accurate but who take WRs Torrance Small and James Thrash and RB Darnell Autry within in points of beating the "greatest show on turf" to make the 01 SB? He fizzled but 2000 to 2005 he was a complete star.

 

[JDM]

He burned clock on that drive that cost them a chance to score on their last drive. He also turned the ball over the drive immediately before. He may have had a good statistical game but he made mistakes that cost them badly. T.O. also went off for nine catches for 122 yards in a game he had no business playing. But at the end the mistakes cost them.

 

[UnrealTerm04]

Kelly!