Except my post was in response to an A-Rod post by you. I included Henderson in my list because he was also a Yankee for part of his career and you were promoting him as well.
I assume this is your “Other” vote?
It was unnecessary of me to bring up the homer accusation. It was a dumb thing to say. Whether its true or not true, it wasn't worth the comment on my part. I am sorry that I made it.
I thought I saw it in the guys that you were bringing up throughout this process that others were saying it was too soon. Now one of them (Mantle) gained enough traction with others to get voted in. Another (ARod) hasn't yet gotten traction but others are starting to consider him. A third (Henderson) wasn't initially your push but you've gotten on that push pretty quickly. And I don't disagree that Rivera was the best closer of all time but you brought him up in discussions as an example of the best of something and it could be seen as a sneaky way to introduce another name to the discussions. That is where I'm picking up homeristic tendencies.
