LOL! @ Rosenthal's QB Rankings

[TKO]

Brees isn't elite.

Really? Brees has been phenomenal since joining New Orleans but here are two seasons for comparison sakes:

2011: 46 Tds -- 14 Ints -- 5476 yds
2012: 43 Tds -- 19 Ints -- 5177 yds

Prior to this year Peyton Manning threw for over 40 Tds only one time and has NEVER thrown for over 5000 Yds.
Tom Brady has done it only once and thrown for over 5000 yds once as well.
Rodgers has gone over 40 one time and never passed for over 5000 Yds

IMO Brees is elite.

 

[bunchofpixels]

The only reasoning one could have to claim Brees isnt elite actually works against Brady as well: they are dink and dunk QBs(especially Brady). Then again. same person claims Dobson is the best WR on the team.

 

[Southieinnc]

Well come on now, get on record. Who would you put ahead of Romo?

Edelman

 

[redseat]

Rosenthal's 11-15 is funny too:

11. Stafford
12. Vick
13. Tannehill
14. Kaepernick
15. Roethlisberger

So Brady is four slots better than Tannehill now...LOL!

This guy needs a urinalysis to check for drugs.

So Tannehill has a pretty good 4 games so far and he is 13th?

 

[fordman84]

Brady
Manning
Rodgers
Brees
Ryan
Flacco
Stafford
Rivers
Alex Smith
Luck

There are at least 5 more before romo or cutler, but I can't be bothered with more names right now.

alex freakin smith? Come on now, you are just trolling now. That lifetime 79 QBR is sure something to be proud of. Of course he breaking out of that average with his 89 this year

Maybe Romo and his career 96 QBR can aspire to be as good as Alex, or his 105 this year.

 

[Checkmate]

After todays game Brady shouldn't even be in the top 10

 

[HammerDown]

After todays game Brady shouldn't even be in the top 10

He's not.

 

[Checkmate]

My picks:

The Elites
1. Manning...better long ball than Brady
2. Brady
3. Brees
4. Rodgers

The rest are not elite. End of story...

That must be some good stuff you are smoking.

 

[briz almighty]

<yawn> not playing with a te is killing the o wait till gronk gets back. brady is still the best qb. you make manning play with no te and two rookie wrs and he will play like a scrub too.

 

[Checkmate]

<yawn> not playing with a te is killing the o wait till gronk gets back. brady is still the best qb. you make manning play with no te and two rookie wrs and he will play like a scrub too.

Make Manning play with a new team and he can still win 13 games.