End of 2021-22 QB Rankings

[megalodon30]

1. Mahomes - KC
2. Rodgers - GB
3. Burrow - CIN
4. Allen - BUF
5. Brady - TB
6. Wilson - SEA
7. Stafford - LAR
8. Herbert - LAC
9. Jackson - BAL
10. Jimmy G - SF
11. Prescott - DAL
12. Mayfield - CLE
13. Murray - AZ
14. Carr - LV
15. Jones - NE
16. Wentz - IND
17. Tua - MIA
18. Tannehill - TEN
19. Hurts - PHI
20. Ryan - ATL
21. Fields - CHI
22. Wilson - NYJ
23. Cousins - MIN
24. Heinicke- WAS
25. Mills - HOU
26. Siemien - NO
27. Darnold - CAR
28. Lock - DEN
29. Jones - NYG
30. Lawrence - JAX
31. Goff - DET

We’ll see who’s starting in Pittsburgh next season. If I had to rank Ben, I’d probably put him just after Matt Ryan, just outside the top 20. But I’m assuming he’s retiring now.

 

[tlance]

1. Mahomes - KC
2. Rodgers - GB
3. Burrow - CIN
4. Allen - BUF
5. Brady - TB
6. Wilson - SEA
7. Stafford - LAR
8. Herbert - LAC
9. Jackson - BAL
10. Jimmy G - SF
11. Prescott - DAL
12. Mayfield - CLE
13. Murray - AZ
14. Carr - LV
15. Jones - NE
16. Wentz - IND
17. Tua - MIA
18. Tannehill - TEN
19. Hurts - PHI
20. Ryan - ATL
21. Fields - CHI
22. Wilson - NYJ
23. Cousins - MIN
24. Heinicke- WAS
25. Mills - HOU
26. Siemien - NO
27. Darnold - CAR
28. Lock - DEN
29. Jones - NYG
30. Lawrence - JAX
31. Goff - DET

We’ll see who’s starting in Pittsburgh next season. If I had to rank Ben, I’d probably put him just after Matt Ryan, just outside the top 20. But I’m assuming he’s retiring now.

Have to put Allen ahead of Burrow. Maybe Rodgers too?

Russ at 6 feels like living in the past. Should be like 9 or 10.

Jimmy G at 10? No way.

Mayfield at 12? Yuck

And Cousins is WAY too low. No justifiable reason to rank him 13 spots below Jimmy G and 11 behind Baker.

Cousins should be around 10-12.

 

[DJ]

Have to put Allen ahead of Burrow. Maybe Rodgers too?

Russ at 6 feels like living in the past. Should be like 9 or 10.

Jimmy G at 10? No way.

Mayfield at 12? Yuck

And Cousins is WAY too low. No justifiable reason to rank him 13 spots below Jimmy G and 11 behind Baker.

Cousins should be around 10-12.

Meg is a moron.

In love with Jimmy G.

 

[DJ]

And Goff is a better QB than Jones, Mills, Darnold, Lock, Semen and Lawrence.

 

[tlance]

Here is my order:
1: Mahomes
2: Allen
3: Rodgers
4: Brady
5: Burrow
6: Herbert
7: Stafford
8: Dak
9: Lamar Jackson
10: Murray
11: Russ Wilson
12: Cousins
13: Carr
14: Jimmy G
15: Mac Jones
16: Mayfield
17: Tannehill
18: Wentz
19: Tua
20: Hurts
21: Fields
22: Ryan

And after that the rest were bad enough that it doesn’t really matter.

But Semian has to be last. He was truly awful.

 

[DJ]

Here is my order:
1: Mahomes
2: Allen
3: Rodgers
4: Brady
5: Burrow
6: Herbert
7: Stafford
8: Dak
9: Lamar Jackson
10: Murray
11: Russ Wilson
12: Cousins
13: Carr
14: Jimmy G
15: Mac Jones
16: Mayfield
17: Tannehill
18: Wentz
19: Tua
20: Hurts
21: Fields
22: Ryan

And after that the rest were bad enough that it doesn’t really matter.

But Semian has to be last. He was truly awful.

Agree.

Semian is really bad.

 

[RememberTheKoy]

1. Mahomes - KC
2. Rodgers - GB
3. Burrow - CIN
4. Allen - BUF
5. Brady - TB
6. Wilson - SEA
7. Stafford - LAR
8. Herbert - LAC
9. Jackson - BAL
10. Jimmy G - SF
11. Prescott - DAL
12. Mayfield - CLE
13. Murray - AZ
14. Carr - LV
15. Jones - NE
16. Wentz - IND
17. Tua - MIA
18. Tannehill - TEN
19. Hurts - PHI
20. Ryan - ATL
21. Fields - CHI
22. Wilson - NYJ
23. Cousins - MIN
24. Heinicke- WAS
25. Mills - HOU
26. Siemien - NO
27. Darnold - CAR
28. Lock - DEN
29. Jones - NYG
30. Lawrence - JAX
31. Goff - DET

We’ll see who’s starting in Pittsburgh next season. If I had to rank Ben, I’d probably put him just after Matt Ryan, just outside the top 20. But I’m assuming he’s retiring now.

Mayfield is trash. No idea why you have him as high as 12. Also Jimmy G at 10 is equally as confusing.

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

Lol.

 

[Shanemansj13]

1. Mahomes - KC
2. Rodgers - GB
3. Burrow - CIN
4. Allen - BUF
5. Brady - TB
6. Wilson - SEA
7. Stafford - LAR
8. Herbert - LAC
9. Jackson - BAL
10. Jimmy G - SF
11. Prescott - DAL
12. Mayfield - CLE
13. Murray - AZ
14. Carr - LV
15. Jones - NE
16. Wentz - IND
17. Tua - MIA
18. Tannehill - TEN
19. Hurts - PHI
20. Ryan - ATL
21. Fields - CHI
22. Wilson - NYJ
23. Cousins - MIN
24. Heinicke- WAS
25. Mills - HOU
26. Siemien - NO
27. Darnold - CAR
28. Lock - DEN
29. Jones - NYG
30. Lawrence - JAX
31. Goff - DET

We’ll see who’s starting in Pittsburgh next season. If I had to rank Ben, I’d probably put him just after Matt Ryan, just outside the top 20. But I’m assuming he’s retiring now.

No way Burrow is ahead of Brady or Allen if these are end of year rankings.
I get Baker was hurt but you still judge him on this season and it was bad. He either gets a N/A or he drops.
Jimmy G at 10 is very generous.

 

[Clayton]

Here is my order:
1: Mahomes
2: Allen
3: Rodgers
4: Brady
5: Burrow
6: Herbert
7: Stafford
8: Dak
9: Lamar Jackson
10: Murray
11: Russ Wilson
12: Cousins
13: Carr
14: Jimmy G
15: Mac Jones
16: Mayfield
17: Tannehill
18: Wentz
19: Tua
20: Hurts
21: Fields
22: Ryan

And after that the rest were bad enough that it doesn’t really matter.

But Semian has to be last. He was truly awful.

This looks closer to what I have. I agree with the order of the top 7 even if Burrow has been better down the stretch.

I would have Lamar above Dak for sure.

 

[megalodon30]

No way Burrow is ahead of Brady or Allen if these are end of year rankings.
I get Baker was hurt but you still judge him on this season and it was bad. He either gets a N/A or he drops.
Jimmy G at 10 is very generous.

Wilson and Baker I both gave benefit of the doubt to. I’m guessing there underperforming was due to injury and not regression. We shall see next year…

 

[tlance]

This looks closer to what I have. I agree with the order of the top 7 even if Burrow has been better down the stretch.

I would have Lamar above Dak for sure.

Yeah, I made the most pretty quickly, so didn’t put a ton of thought into it.

That 1 is pretty close. I think the best version of Lamar is probably top 5.

 

[tlance]

Wilson and Baker I both gave benefit of the doubt to. I’m guessing there underperforming was due to injury and not regression. We shall see next year…

After about 13, there is a whole lot of meh.

But Baker and Jimmy G definitely are not in the top 13. They are in the meh group.

Baker can get back up the list a bit next year, but he hasn’t achieved enough to deserve the benefit of the doubt.

And if we are being honest, his play this year was pretty comparable to guys like Goff and Daniel Jones.

 

[megalodon30]

After about 13, there is a whole lot of meh.

But Baker and Jimmy G definitely are not in the top 13. They are in the meh group.

Baker can get back up the list a bit next year, but he hasn’t achieved enough to deserve the benefit of the doubt.

And if we are being honest, his play this year was pretty comparable to guys like Goff and Daniel Jones.

I’m just gonna give him the benefit of the doubt for now. Shoulder injuries are no joke for someone that gets payed to throw the ball. If he plays the same next year, I’ll drop him like a rock in the next rankings…

 

[tlance]

I’m just gonna give him the benefit of the doubt for now. Shoulder injuries are no joke for someone that gets payed to throw the ball. If he plays the same next year, I’ll drop him like a rock in the next rankings…

What is your reasoning for putting Cousins so low?

He is nothing special and not worth his contract, but solidly above average QB.

Baker hasn’t been that since his rookie season.

 

[megalodon30]

What is your reasoning for putting Cousins so low?

He is nothing special and not worth his contract, but solidly above average QB.

Baker hasn’t been that since his rookie season.

Cousins once again put up huge numbers, yet was below .500. He’s basically the new Stafford. Or Minnesota is the new Detroit. Or both…

 

[Shanemansj13]

What is your reasoning for putting Cousins so low?

He is nothing special and not worth his contract, but solidly above average QB.

Baker hasn’t been that since his rookie season.

Baker was definitely above average the 2nd half of last year, he was actually better than above average or Cousins ceiling so far but a full season? We have yet to see it but overall 2020 was a very good season for him. Final 12 games in 20-21 season Baker went 20 TD's 3 INT's- 8W-4L. 2022 will likely decide his future and possibly his career.

 

[Clayton]

1. Mahomes
2. Allen
3. Brady
4. Rodgers
5. Lamar
6. Burrow
7. Herbert
8. Stafford
9. Wilson
10. Dak
11. Cousins
12. Carr
13. Jimmy G
14. Murray
15. Mayfield
16. Tannehill
17. Tua
18. Ryan
19. Hurts
20. Mac Jones


Without combing through stats I'd make it this. Lamar and Rodgers generally rule the regular season. Brady still scares me but not as much as the guys who can't be sacked on 4th and 13 and can run or pass it anywhere.

Herbert and Burrow can still move up. Stafford has always had a big arm but sometimes makes bad mistakes. Wilson didn't win games last year but I wouldn't put him out of the top 10.

Murray is probably my hot take here but he keeps hitting a wall. Maybe it's a lack of surrounding talent without Hopkins. Not sure.

 

[DJ]

Mayfield is trash. No idea why you have him as high as 12. Also Jimmy G at 10 is equally as confusing.

He riding Jimmy's dick.

 

[DJ]

I hope Denver acquires Jimmy G.....LOL.