End of 2021-22 QB Rankings

[Clayton]

My controversial take on QB ratings right now.

Allen over Mahomes.

I don't think it's that controversial.

The Chiefs coaches seem to be better than the Bills coaches and if they switched teams then Allen might have more success.

Although maybe that's controversial, too

 

[Schmoopy1000]

The proper rankings:


1. Mahomes
2. Allen
3. Brady
4. Rodgers
5. Herbert
6. Jackson
7. Burrow
8. Wilson
9. Stafford
10. Prescott
11. Carr
12. Murray
13. Cousins
14. Tannehill
15. Wentz
16. Hurts
17. Mac Jones
18. Jimmy G
19. Mills
20. Ryan
21. Tua
22. Bridgewater
23. Mayfield
24. Siemien
25. Heinicke
26. Jones (Giants)
27. Goff
28. Fields
29. Lawrence
30. Darnold
31. Wilson (Jets)

now that about where Jimmy G belongs.
In the 16 to 19 range

 

[Schmoopy1000]

I personally think just about everyone over rates Lamar jackson (as a QB) because of his running highlight reels.

I would hate to have Lamar Jackson as my QB. I would take any top tenish QB over Lamar.

Now turn Lamar into a Deebo position & you would have something there.

 

[Anointed One]

After reading the rankings 10-32 on the OP post...

 

[megalodon30]

I personally think just about everyone over rates Lamar jackson (as a QB) because of his running highlight reels.

I would hate to have Lamar Jackson as my QB. I would take any top tenish QB over Lamar.

Now turn Lamar into a Deebo position & you would have something there.

I give him a bump because he’s got an MVP. Hardware gets a little respect in my rankings…

 

[Schmoopy1000]

I give him a bump because he’s got an MVP. Hardware gets a little respect in my rankings…

Ok I could see that in a way. Dont agree, but to each their own.
but I thought the rankings were for now, not for their career.

 

[Clayton]

I personally think just about everyone over rates Lamar jackson (as a QB) because of his running highlight reels.

I would hate to have Lamar Jackson as my QB. I would take any top tenish QB over Lamar.

Now turn Lamar into a Deebo position & you would have something there.

He took over a team that went 24-27 over a long stretch with Joe Flacco and turned Baltimore into one of the most exciting offenses in the league.

Ravens at one point this season has the one seed and they've been totally wrecked with injuries and bad coaching.

I do think most NFL fans would take Burrow or Herbert over him in a heartbeat, though.

 

[Schmoopy1000]

He took over a team that went 24-27 over a long stretch with Joe Flacco and turned Baltimore into one of the most exciting offenses in the league.

Ravens at one point this season has the one seed and they've been totally wrecked with injuries and bad coaching.

I do think most NFL fans would take Burrow or Herbert over him in a heartbeat, though.

that is the point I make about him being overrated. When they talk about his "game" It isnt his QBing they are talking of. It is his highlight reel.

I dont think Harbaugh is a bad coach, but having QBs like Lamar (or Vick) is a coach killer however.

 

[Clayton]

that is the point I make about him being overrated. When they talk about his "game" It isnt his QBing they are talking of. It is his highlight reel.

I dont think Harbaugh is a bad coach, but having QBs like Lamar (or Vick) is a coach killer however.

Vicks career YPA is 7.0 and Jackson is 7.5. I realize that's still not elite but it's the difference between being bad at passing and being serviceable at passing.

 

[dtgold88]

What is your reasoning for putting Cousins so low?

He is nothing special and not worth his contract, but solidly above average QB.

Baker hasn’t been that since his rookie season.

while I can see ranking Baker where you did or even lower Baker was better in 2020 than his rookie year. Probably a lot better.

 

[Clayton]

Baker was hurt...week 2? I was ranking him mostly ignoring this year but he played like a backup from week 10 on. The 6 Ints and 14 sacks in the last two games are probably worse than most backups.

He played well as a rookie but honestly looking beyond the stats he was actually pretty decent in 2020. So he is probably somewhere around 15 if you believe the injury held him back. Somewhere around 30th if you don't.

 

[Wamu]

I wouldn't be surprised.

So you think the Browns will offer Mayfield a contract extension this summer when he's already under contract for next season? You sure have some oddball thinking.

 

[Wamu]

I honestly have no idea

 

[RememberTheKoy]

So you think the Browns will offer Mayfield a contract extension this summer when he's already under contract for next season? You sure have some oddball thinking.

Whether it's this year or the following year, I bet they try to extend him. Trash QB.

 

[Wamu]

Whether it's this year or the following year, I bet they try to extend him. Trash QB.

Now keep in mind that I'm one of the Browns fans who isn't a Mayfield fan. But if he's a trash QB what does that make Wentz? No playoff wins.

And speaking of Wentz it's funny you have him ranked higher than Jimmy G. Here's a quick comparison of the two.

Jimmy G: 33-14 & 4-1 in the playoffs

Wentz- 44-40-1 & 0-1 in the playoffs

Also it was hilarious that you guaranteed the Eagles would win their final 8 games this season. Sometimes you're more full of shit than a clogged toilet.

 

[RememberTheKoy]

Now keep in mind that I'm one of the Browns fans who isn't a Mayfield fan. But if he's a trash QB what does that make Wentz? No playoff wins.

And speaking of Wentz it's funny you have him ranked higher than Jimmy G. Here's a quick comparison of the two.

Jimmy G: 33-14 & 4-1 in the playoffs

Wentz- 44-40-1 & 0-1 in the playoffs

Also it was hilarious that you guaranteed the Eagles would win their final 8 games this season. Sometimes you're more full of shit than a clogged toilet.

Wentz is better than both Mayfield and Jimmy G. Browns and 49ers would be better with Wentz than Mayfield and Jimmy G. Wentz has issues and I don't have him rated that high but he is still better than those two.

 

[Clayton]

The problem with Wentz is that even if he is the 21st or 22nd best QB in the league then a team with a top 3 oline, top 10 defense, and a top 3 running game is being held back but not enough to improve at QB.

Eagles dumped Wentz for a QB project and improved. That's all you really need to know about Wentz.

 

[PDay8810]

Now keep in mind that I'm one of the Browns fans who isn't a Mayfield fan. But if he's a trash QB what does that make Wentz? No playoff wins.

And speaking of Wentz it's funny you have him ranked higher than Jimmy G. Here's a quick comparison of the two.

Jimmy G: 33-14 & 4-1 in the playoffs

Wentz- 44-40-1 & 0-1 in the playoffs

Also it was hilarious that you guaranteed the Eagles would win their final 8 games this season. Sometimes you're more full of shit than a clogged toilet.

I remain absolutely sure, Koy appreciates your contributions towards the attention he seeks.

 

[Wamu]

Wentz is better than both Mayfield and Jimmy G. Browns and 49ers would be better with Wentz than Mayfield and Jimmy G. Wentz has issues and I don't have him rated that high but he is still better than those two.

If Wentz is so good why did the Eagles dump him for Hurts? If he's so good why didn't the Colts make the playoffs?

 

[Wamu]

I remain absolutely sure, Koy appreciates your contributions towards the attention he seeks.

I just want him to think he's relevant. But most of what he says is pretty damn funny.