- Thread starter
- #1
Omar 382
Well-Known Member
It seems like every baseball forum has a thread counting down the top 100 players of all time for each poster. While I don't have time for that this morning, I will count down my top 25, and you can all do the same.
Rules:
Here we go:
Rules:
- Only stats from the AL or NL count. Nothing from the Confederate League, AA, ***** Leagues, etc.
- This is a thread for the greatest players of all time, not the greatest players with potential of all time (sorry Roy Campanella)
- Count contributions for both pitching, hitting, and defense (i.e., you can count how great a pitcher Babe Ruth was)
- Factor in PED's how you'd like
Here we go:
- Babe Ruth
- Barry Bonds
- Ty Cobb
- Willie Mays
- Ted Williams
- Honus Wagner
- Roger Clemens
- Rogers Hornsby
- Cy Young
- Stan Musial
- Tris Speaker
- Hank Aaron
- Walter Johnson
- Eddie Collins
- Lou Gehrig
- Randy Johnson
- Mickey Mantle
- Mike Schmidt
- Mel Ott
- Nap Lajoie
- Frank Robinson
- Rickey Henderson
- Greg Maddux
- Jimmie Foxx
- Roger Connor