Trade Advice Thread

[redseat]

I was offered:

Scott Kazmir
Adrian Beltre

For

Kyle Schwarber


H2h 14 team league Points


Personally I would like to keep Schwarber as he is one of my keepers but Beltre has been pretty good at 3rd (and points wise) Lately but I feel as if he is due for a let down..... Right now I don't have a 3rd baseman..... So that's not a bad one...

 

[redseat]

I welcome opinions.... I am thinking I should use this thread to keep all the trades and potential trades I have in my one league to see what you guys think

 

[TKOSpikes]

Not even close!

Beltre is on his final legs.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Agree with TKO... That is a bad trade for you... Shwarber may be overvalued, but as long as he still has catcher eligibility he is a great keep...

 

[Chef99]

Plus, Kazmir was always one of Zep's more overrated songs, imo.

 

[redseat]

Yeah as I mentioned I really wanted to keep Schwarber and it would certainly have to be a huge steal in my favor for me to move him.

 

[redseat]

Another trade (same league) I was offered:

I TRADE:

9th round pick (115th overall)
11th Round pick (141st overall)

FOR:

Jonathan Lucroy
Maikel Franco
Jered Weaver
24th Round pick (325th overall)
25th Round pick ((348th overall)

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Another trade (same league) I was offered:

I TRADE:

9th round pick (115th overall)
11th Round pick (141st overall)

FOR:

Jonathan Lucroy
Maikel Franco
Jered Weaver
24th Round pick (325th overall)
25th Round pick ((348th overall)

How does this affect your keepers??

 

[redseat]

How does this affect your keepers??

I'm only keeping 3 now.. EE,DeGrom and Schwarber (though people are pushing HARD to get him)

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I'm only keeping 3 now.. EE,DeGrom and Schwarber (though people are pushing HARD to get him)

How does your keepers work, I know you can keep up to 8 but what do keepers count as??

 

[redseat]

How does your keepers work, I know you can keep up to 8 but what do keepers count as??

Honestly not sure....... I believe it is those would be your first 1 picks...but honestly not sure since this is the league I took over late late last year and I am still trying to figure it out...

 

[MilkSpiller22]

but without that I cant give advice... the players you are getting are not top 5 round players, but there values are pretty good for what you are giving up...

 

[TKOSpikes]

Weaver is irrelevant and you cannot make him a keeper.... especially a 6th round keeper. Franco and Lucroy I could get behind.... not sure why he's offering them for such low picks... I assume it forces you to keep Weaver, which would be a deal killer for me.

 

[redseat]

my understanding is: who ever gets "players" in a trade are keeping them for THIS YEAR only

 

[tlance]

That is a hard no Red.

He is offering you those players for draft pick upgrades because he can't keep them.

If you want those guys, you can simply draft them in rounds 4-8 when your potential partner is not picking. Keep your picks.

 

[molsaniceman]

Another trade (same league) I was offered:

I TRADE:

9th round pick (115th overall)
11th Round pick (141st overall)

FOR:

Jonathan Lucroy
Maikel Franco
Jered Weaver
24th Round pick (325th overall)
25th Round pick ((348th overall)

Why a 2nd catcher? Schwarber will play every day
Is franco a keeper?ADP 147 RD 12
Weaver for sure is not ADP 242
So i vote no

 

[redseat]

Why a 2nd catcher? Schwarber will play every day
Is franco a keeper?ADP 147 RD 12
Weaver for sure is not ADP 242
So i vote no

I don't know that is the offer that was sent to me... I thinking Weaver will choke it away this year