Top 10 poll: #3 player ever

[Nosferatu]

Run off!!

(Yes, I changed my vote to make it a tie!)

Here's one of our old drafts you were in.




Lineup:
1. R - Rickey Henderson - 1970
2. L – Joe Morgan - 1960
3. R – Jimmie Foxx - 1920
4. L – David Ortiz - 1990
5. R – Dwight Evans - 1970
6. L – Carl Yastrzemski - 1960
7. R – Ernie Lombardi - 1930
8. L – Wade Boggs - 1980
9. R – Cal Ripken - 1980

Bench:
IF- R – Harmon Killebrew - 1950
IF- R – Bobby Doerr - 1930
IF- R – Nomar Garciaparra - 1990
OF- L – Larry Doby - 1940
OF- L – Vida Pinson - 1950
OF- L – Fred Lynn - 1970

Rotation:
L – Lefty Grove – 1920
R – Robin Roberts – 1940
L – Johan Santana – 2000
R – Adam Wainwright – 2000
L – Chris Sale – 2010

Bullpen:
CL – R – Mariano Rivera – 1990
SU – R – Jonathan Papelbon – 2000
Long – R – John Smoltz – 1980
RH – Kenley Jansen – 2010
LH – Ron Perranoski – 1960

 

[steveringo]

Here's one of our old drafts you were in.

View attachment 382893


Lineup:
1. R - Rickey Henderson - 1970
2. L – Joe Morgan - 1960
3. R – Jimmie Foxx - 1920
4. L – David Ortiz - 1990
5. R – Dwight Evans - 1970
6. L – Carl Yastrzemski - 1960
7. R – Ernie Lombardi - 1930
8. L – Wade Boggs - 1980
9. R – Cal Ripken - 1980

Bench:
IF- R – Harmon Killebrew - 1950
IF- R – Bobby Doerr - 1930
IF- R – Nomar Garciaparra - 1990
OF- L – Larry Doby - 1940
OF- L – Vida Pinson - 1950
OF- L – Fred Lynn - 1970

Rotation:
L – Lefty Grove – 1920
R – Robin Roberts – 1940
L – Johan Santana – 2000
R – Adam Wainwright – 2000
L – Chris Sale – 2010

Bullpen:
CL – R – Mariano Rivera – 1990
SU – R – Jonathan Papelbon – 2000
Long – R – John Smoltz – 1980
RH – Kenley Jansen – 2010
LH – Ron Perranoski – 1960

Holy shit! That's awesome! You got to pick the year you wanted!

I guess I like the Red Sox!

 

[Clayton]

Was that with us?

Yeah. I just searched the board for me and Willie Mays because I figured I hadnt talked about him much and I remember thinking it was odd I got him in a draft at pick 5. Looking back, I think my one change would have been getting another modern pitcher in there

MLB Dynasty Draft

I was going to do batting order and maybe a small paragraph explaining the team's overall strategy and justification I wouldnt mind that but not everyone will do the paragraph...

sportshoop.la

 

[calsnowskier]

Still a few hours remaining, but I think it is fair to call the runoff between Bonds and Williams. I will wait a few more hours before p make the runoff thread, though.

 

[Shanemansj13]

If it was greatest hitter…Teddy would be #1. I think if you account for everything Bonds > Teddy

 

[calsnowskier]

This poll is closed. Bonds and Williams will move to the runoff.

Bonds - 20
Williams - 20
Cobb - 7
Gehrig - 6
Aaron - 6
Ohtani - 4
Mantle - 4
Griffey Jr, Hornsby, Young, Musial - 2
Schmidt, Wagner, W Johnson, Martinez, Rodriguez, Clemente, Mathewson - 1

Top 10 poll #3: #3 player in history - Runoff

https://sportshoop.la/threads/top-10-poll-3-player-ever.342367/ Runoff for #3 player in baseball history. @navamind @tzill @LHG @Stokes1931 @steveringo @broncosmitty @packerzrule @Shanemansj13 @jarntt @redseat @trojanfan12 @black francis @molsaniceman @Fountain City Blues @Used 2 B Hu...

sportshoop.la