Game Thread: Super Bowl LIX: Chefs vs Elgses

[Clayton]

Mahomes is a good QB he won 3 Super Bowls, oh so what, so this puts him in the GOAT position? Aikman won 3 he's not GOAT,
Mahomes has a lot of years left to make a charge, to even be amongst the 10 best but rings don't make you the best or demand people remember you. Charles Haley? a lot of rings but Reggie White still owns that position ( Bruce Smith too )
Brady with 7 does have an impact but he's not too far away from the field of great QBs either, He did win without superstars ( except Moss ) and that propels him in my book.
Mahomes is good but isn't far ahead of the current field if at all. Hurts has outplayed him both times, barely got by PURDY?
Not that impressed.

I dont really think Super Bowls are a good metric for measuring QBs. Maybe a more advanced 'does he win the games he should win' would be interesting. Mahomes career stats being down by 7 or 10 is off the charts. Comparing to Aikman is pretty easy. Dallas was a devastating run offense. Mahomes has replacement level RBs most of the time and an oline thats maybe very slightly above average.

Drew Brees and Joe Burrow have really struggled to consistently win. Do they suck? Does Dan Marino suck?

The reality is that throughout a huge part of Tom Brady's career that Peyton Manning was considered the better QB by a large number of people. Its the same way now with Mahomes and Lamar Jackson. Steve Young did a pretty good job at replacing Joe Montana. Nick Foles beat Tom Brady in a Super Bowl. At the highest level, football is a team sport.

I'm getting the impression that Mahomes will likely end up as the 3rd best QB of all time. We'll see.

 

[fightinfunbags]

2nd series that Eagles scored TD... McDuffie penalty on 3rd and 5. Unsure if Eagles try and go for it on 4th down. I assume that is play he is talking about and a stop.

View attachment 388759

My bad. I thought that was 2nd down. I stand corrected.

 

[PDay8810]

I'm getting the impression that Mahomes will likely end up as the 3rd best QB of all time. We'll see.

Can you explain why such a subjective topic where stats, nor total championships tell the whole story matters so much?

I'm sorry but this GOAT stuff is just stupid drunk bar conversation crap.

 

[Clayton]

I'm sorry but this GOAT stuff is just stupid drunk bar conversation crap.

And it's what drives engagement online.

If a Bills CB that the average fan has never heard of doesn't get hurt then maybe we're talking about Josh Allen right now instead of Mahomes

 

[PDay8810]

And it's what drives engagement online.

If a Bills CB that the average fan has never heard of doesn't get hurt then maybe we're talking about Josh Allen right now instead of Mahomes

i accept engagement online.

i asked yòu cause I knew others would be butthurt with the question