WilltheThrill
Well-Known Member
No they shouldn't.....they had plenty of opportunities to have won that game and - if I'm reading you correctly - you're basing Detroit's "should have" based on one play with 4 minutes left to go in the game. Their QB had lead them to 6 points in the final 3 quarters. That's a problem, much more so than one blown call - YES it was a horrid call. But it didn't cost them the game IMO.
And no they shouldn't either......they had so many opportunities to have scored and didn't it was amazing. When you have 1st and goal at the one with the best QB in ball and come out with a FG, that isn't good. Or if their running dumb-ass DL doesn't get a 15 yd penalty for taunting when your team had the ball at the 4 for a first down, and again only came away with a FG, as two of several examples.
Ok, you are way over-analyzing my statement there. And you could say "no they shouldn't have" about any game ever played if you use the whole "well, team X didn't execute and therefore they didn't win" argument. But when someone says that team X should have beaten team Y, he means that team Y caught a lot of breaks.
So yes, given normal circumstances, Detroit should have beaten Dallas. That flag being picked up was a random occurrence and a big deal. It didn't beat Detroit, but it did shift momentum. And Detroit then failed to stop Dallas and then fumbled twice on the attempted game-winning drive. In other words, a lot went wrong for them that normally probably wouldn't. If any of those things don't happen, Detroit wins.
If the TE for Green Bay follows his simple assignment on that onside kick attempt and blocks instead of trying to catch the ball, Jordy Nelson likely makes the easy uncontested catch, Seattle doesn't recover, and Green Bay is in the Super Bowl. 99 times out of 100 that would have happened. Seattle caught a major unexpected break, just like Dallas did.
If you want to get technical about things, then no loser ever should have won because that's not what happened. I was speaking more in general terms and referring mostly to teams having a win within their grasp and letting it slip away.