In a head to head competition, you have to give up 1 band- PF or LZ. Which one and why?

[Omar 382]

You are tasked with wiping out the entire catalogs and history of either Pink Floyd or Led Zeppelin. Which one is more influential and overall better than the other?

 

[beardown07]

You are tasked with wiping out the entire catalogs and history of either Pink Floyd or Led Zeppelin. Which one is more influential and overall better than the other?

Is there LSD and adolescence in this make-believe world?

 

[blindbaby]

Which one?: Nickleback
Why?: because I felt like saying Nickleback

 

[Omar 382]

Is there LSD and adolescence in this make-believe world?

Everything else is the same. Just one of these bands never existed.

 

[shopson67]

Which one?: Nickleback
Why?: because I felt like saying Nickleback

It only works if you spell the name correctly. You likely just killed off a terrible cover band.

 

[shopson67]

You are tasked with wiping out the entire catalogs and history of either Pink Floyd or Led Zeppelin. Which one is more influential and overall better than the other?

Led Zeppelin, easily. I love Gilmour's playing and the early Sid singles too much.

Besides, gives GVF a lot more material to release without anyone complaining...

 

[Tai Chi≈Surfing]

 

[Omar 382]

Led Zeppelin, easily. I love Gilmour's playing and the early Sid singles too much.

Besides, gives GVF a lot more material to release without anyone complaining...

I think Waters' vocals are more important than Gilmour's guitar work. Ok, probably not, but I do definitely dislike Gilmour's vocals and love Waters'.

 

[shopson67]

I think Waters' vocals are more important than Gilmour's guitar work. Ok, probably not, but I do definitely dislike Gilmour's vocals and love Waters'.

I've never been a lyrics guy. I listen to the music and melody much more than actual lyrical content.