Eli manning - elite or 2nd tier QB?

[Clayton]

I'm going on more body of work career wise. He's had elite seasons and he's had bad seasons. He also dealt with some extremely bad run games (This year again) and bad O lines. Anyone rated 6-10 I consider 2nd tier. In a big game I'd take him over quite a few better rated QB's.

Eh, there was a point in time where Jake Delhomme was awesome in big games. I think thats just small sample sizes. Speaking of big games, I forgot Tony Romo (7.9)