Fountain City Blues
Love Everybody
True, I am just wondering out loud what said average actually is in a park such as Kauffman or Coors versus say Minute Maid. If there is a data set I can look at to be able to tease the answer out in a more refined way, that'd be lovely.It's playing the averages, and obviously, if an extreme shift allows triples and/or runs to score, that's going to be more memorable to us fans than instances of shifts robbing hitters, which does happen quite a bit. It's like someone playing blackjack by "the book" - he's increasing his chances of winning if he's playing thousands of hands, but view one hand in a vacuum, and those averages don't do shit.
Of course, when a team plays "by the book" in an important game and it ends badly, people who are afraid to know things cry, "see, moneyball doesn't work!" I think Vice mentioned "moneyball not working" for the A's, which is clearly not the case.
Playing the averages can have disastrous or remarkable results when looking at one specific situation. For example, stolen bases. It's been pretty widely proven that, over the course of a season, if your team is not stealing bases at a 75% success rate or better, they're better off not trying to steal. As such, the 2004 Red Sox had very few SB attempts, but when they needed it, they went against the averages and sent Dave Roberts out to swipe 2nd. It paid off and everyone remembers it.