sf1giantfan
Well-Known Member
Does anyone think Snell or Chap wants to stay with the Giants after this season? Or do they want to sign with another team even if the Giants offer them a long term contract (not saying they will).
Yaz could get a decent return as well. Not a blue chipper, but maybe multiple lotto tix.I've resigned myself to the fact that Soler isn't movable.
Chapman, Snell and Forto absolutely should be traded though.
Chappy has been rumored to the Giants for years. I don’t think it is impossible to imagine him opting out and resigning with the Giants.Does anyone think Snell or Chap wants to stay with the Giants after this season? Or do they want to sign with another team even if the Giants offer them a long term contract (not saying they will).
So the question is, is it worth it to not trade them at the deadline if they both have shown interest in staying?Chappy has been rumored to the Giants for years. I don’t think it is impossible to imagine him opting out and resigning with the Giants.
Same, but to a lessor extant with Snell.
Snell has not shown any interest that I am aware of. I just think the Giants make sense for HIM to want to settle down with. And if they opt out, trading them does not eliminate the Giants as a landing spot.So the question is, is it worth it to not trade them at the deadline if they both have shown interest in staying?
My memory is hazy on this, but didn't the Yankees trade one of their players a few years ago for some prospects and then re-signed him that very offseason?Snell has not shown any interest that I am aware of. I just think the Giants make sense for HIM to want to settle down with. And if they opt out, trading them does not eliminate the Giants as a landing spot.
Aroldis Chapman to the Cubs in ‘16My memory is hazy on this, but didn't the Yankees trade one of their players a few years ago for some prospects and then re-signed him that very offseason?
Thanks I just remembered and was about to update my post. And they got Gleyber Torres in the trade as well.Aroldis Chapman to the Cubs in ‘16
Cubs paid a very high price for a rental, but I think they are more than happy with the results.Thanks I just remembered and was about to update my post. And they got Gleyber Torres in the trade as well.
The Giants did it with Andres Torres. Not the same level as what we are talking about here, but it happened nonetheless.
Those are a different scenarios (as you mentioned with Torres). Chapman is an example of trading a guy off in his walk year for prospects, during the season, and then signing him back off the free agent market that very offseason.Kinda did it with Ruf as well.
Yup. It happens REALLY rarely, but it does happen and there are no rules against it (as there are in the NBA)Those are a different scenarios (as you mentioned with Torres). Chapman is an example of trading a guy off in his walk year for prospects, during the season, and then signing him back off the free agent market that very offseason.
I'm ok either way on Yaz. Hes due for a raise in arb so....Yaz could get a decent return as well. Not a blue chipper, but maybe multiple lotto tix.