2013 Shanaban thread

[dash]

We need a disciplinary committee (i.e. a panel of three or five guys). There will always be claims of preferential treatment and bias with one person at the helm.

 

[mattola]

stop being logical dash the NHL has no place for logic

 

[mattola]

Edler Suspended 2 Games.

 

[dash]

Edler Suspended 2 Games.

Sorry Matty, you just never know where the Wheel of Justice will land...

 

[mattola]

Sorry Matty, you just never know where the Wheel of Justice will land...

Is what it is dash sigh

 

[KennyBanyeah]

Edler Suspended 2 Games.

 

[mattola]

they never had much credibility but the moment they said Nash would not get a hearing they lost whatever they had left. This league has embarassed itself in how it protects its players and game I agree with dash's idea of a committee to do this

5 guys

ex Ref
2 ex players
2 ex GMS

 

[KennyBanyeah]

they never had much credibility but the moment they said Nash would not get a hearing they lost whatever they had left. This league has embarassed itself in how it protects its players and game I agree with dash's idea of a committee to do this

5 guys

ex Ref
2 ex players
2 ex GMS

That's a lot of coin. The could practically run a team for that much... oh wait.

For Edler to get two for that and Nash to walk is pure, hot, stinking garbage.

 

[esls79]

They lost all credibility to me when they said Perry was a repeat offender for something that happened in 2009 and yet they said when Cooke tore Karlsson's achiles that even if they were to look at the play Cooke wasn't considered a repeat offender.

To me Mike Smith is a repeat offender

 

[dash]

To me Mike Smith is a repeat offender

Nah, but he is a loon.

 

[BOSSMANPC]

they never had much credibility but the moment they said Nash would not get a hearing they lost whatever they had left. This league has embarassed itself in how it protects its players and game I agree with dash's idea of a committee to do this

5 guys

ex Ref
2 ex players
2 ex GMS

I agree, read post 240. :rollseyes:

 

[mattola]

I agree, read post 240. :rollseyes:

 

[forty_three]

they never had much credibility but the moment they said Nash would not get a hearing they lost whatever they had left. This league has embarassed itself in how it protects its players and game I agree with dash's idea of a committee to do this

5 guys

ex Ref
2 ex players
2 ex GMS

Problem with that is some out of work refs:
Frazer
Koharski

Some out of work GMs
Burke
Howson
Milbury
MacLean
Keenan



2 for Edler. Just... Wow.

 

[sabresfaninthesouth]

I like the committee idea, but I'd rather see it be all current GMs.

Whenever there's a questionable hit, all of the GMs other than those of the two teams involved indicate how many games they'd like the suspension to be from 0 to perma-ban.

Actual suspension is the average of those numbers rounded down to the nearest whole game.

 

[sabresfaninthesouth]

Am I missing something with the Edler hit? Is there actually any rule that says that is a penalty? Because that hit is clean as shit if Mike Smith is a skater.

Stay in your fucking crease.

Yes.

The rules are EXTREMELY clear that a goaltender isn't fair game just because he's out of the crease.

 

[forty_three]

Carrie Underwood's official purse holder went through the crease without slowing up and elbowed mason in the head.

Edler got two for a hit on a goalie in the corner. So purse boy gets...


<spin>

 

[KennyBanyeah]

Carrie Underwood's official purse holder went through the crease without slowing up and elbowed mason in the head.

Edler got two for a hit on a goalie in the corner. So purse boy gets...


<spin>

Fish is a generally decent player. I'd like to see this play.

Maybe he's so sportsmanlike that he thought that injuring Mason was a service to the Jackets.

 

[DaBoltsNIsles]

They lost all credibility to me when they said Perry was a repeat offender for something that happened in 2009 and yet they said when Cooke tore Karlsson's achiles that even if they were to look at the play Cooke wasn't considered a repeat offender.

To me Mike Smith is a repeat offender

Yeah that was beyond a joke.

I can't believe Lupol got two games & Nash got nothing. PATHETIC.

 

[KennyBanyeah]

CBC (Ron MacLean) said tonight that the ruling about Nash was so right.

I've been a HUGE supporter of HNIC, but that is ridiculous. It shows a poor knowledge of hockey, at best.

I don't think I can condone this kind of pandering any more.

The CBC needs to relinquish NHL hockey unless they have massive overhauls.

 

[mattola]

CBC (Ron MacLean) said tonight that the ruling about Nash was so right.

I've been a HUGE supporter of HNIC, but that is ridiculous. It shows a poor knowledge of hockey, at best.

I don't think I can condone this kind of pandering any more.

The CBC needs to relinquish NHL hockey unless they have massive overhauls.

i heard on the radio that they were close to a new deal. MacLean is long been a supporter of anything the refs do or the league officiates. I would not judge that. I purposefully stayed away from them for this reason alone this weekend.