Top 10 QBs at this point

[DJ]

Carr's been a quality QB since he got into the league and this year has been the only one where he had a top 5-10 OL.

 

[DJ]

I did not, I amended my post, I totally forgot about Carr

He is possibly #1 for me now, with Ryan #3 and Dak # 3, as we sit here today

Sorry. Didn't see the amendment.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

So having a quality OL is a bad thing now.....okay.

Only if we want to ignore that Carr handles what little pressure he gets poorly.

 

[DJ]

Anyone putting Wilson in their top 5-10 based off this year are not being honest or haven't seen many Hawk games. Maybe based off his last game he'd be ranked near the top, but not for the season. He had a pretty rough start.

His OL hasn't been helpful at all...

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Carr's been a quality QB since he got into the league and this year has been the only one where he had a top 5-10 OL.

The latter is definitely false. It was a top 10 line last year and was probably closer to top 5 in pass protection. Runblocking was the bugaboo.

 

[DJ]

Only if we want to ignore that Carr handles what little pressure he gets poorly.

He has 9-10 comeback wins since coming into the league, that's top 3 among QB's.

 

[DJ]

The latter is definitely false. It was a top 10 line last year and was probably closer to top 5 in pass protection. Runblocking was the bugaboo.

You're a hater......got it. Moving on.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

He has 9-10 comeback wins since coming into the league, that's top 3 among QB's.

That's a stat that just tells me he's behind in games a lot.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

You're a hater......got it. Moving on.

That's what Fitzpatrick homers told me this offseason...

I had Carr 11th and has a pretty good shot at being 8th at the end of the year or so. Somehow criticism is bad now. Got it.

 

[PDay8810]

So having a quality OL is a bad thing now.....okay.

LOL
Yes...yes it is IF you're propping up your QB or RB.

some do indeed smell worse than others

 

[Fountain City Blues]

LOL
Yes...yes it is IF you're propping up your QB or RB.

some do indeed smell worse than others

I wonder if people still are trying to figure out the unnamed Giants center who doesn't wipe that Eli called out.

 

[PDay8810]

I wonder if people still are trying to figure out the unnamed Giants center who doesn't wipe that Eli called out.

no question....Team Sport!

 

[DJ]

Only if we want to ignore that Carr handles what little pressure he gets poorly.

Please explain. He's cool and calm when the pressure is on and is as clutch as a QB can get.

 

[cowboys5xsbs]

This year Only
1)Tom Brady
2)Matt Ryan
3)David Carr
4)Dak Prescott
5)Eli Manning
6)Marcus Mariota
7)Stafford
8)Wilson
9)Brees
10)Big Ben

Is David Carr back in the league again

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Please explain. He's cool and calm when the pressure is on and is as clutch as a QB can get.

That's a question that requires an answer I am not going to be able to make via phone. I'll explain in more detail once I am back from class.

 

[DJ]

Is David Carr back in the league again

He's an analyst on the NFL Network....when he's not taking PTSD classes.

 

[DJ]

That's a question that requires an answer I am not going to be able to make via phone. I'll explain in more detail once I am back from class.

Okay, Moose......sorry I snapped at you. We've always been civil. I need coffee, I'm out and need to buy some.

 

[fordman84]

Didn't expect to see Dak up there. I think he is great, but has a 9 game resume. I think he needs a full year at least, and preferably 2 before I start saying he is at the top. Around 10-12 would be a good spot to have him, just outside the 10 best in the league.

 

[purguy12]

Is David Carr back in the league again

LOL my bad.

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

I hate ranking guys based on the first half. How many times have we seen guys in this league come out of the chute flying only to fade down the back stretch while others who look just "meh" turn it on around Thanksgiving and lead their team into the play-offs.
All the MVP front-runners have looked great but some guys have proven track records while the younger guys still have to prove they are more than just the team in front of them. And still others need to overcome past failures to show they are indeed, worthy of being considered, one of the best in the game.