Top 10 QBs at this point

[PDay8810]

what a difference 4 weeks can make
philly fans are going to be pissed and they have a 1st round draft pick to boot

 

[DJ]

1. Rodgers
2. Brady
3. Brees
4. Wilson
5. Luck
6. Big Ben
7. Cam Newton
8. Rivers
9. Matt Ryan
10. Matt Stafford

And before anyone asks, I left off Carr on purpose, didn't forget.

I would ask why but you're a KC fan and probably think Smith is better than Carr.

 

[PDay8810]

And before anyone asks, I left off Carr on purpose, didn't forget.

then your list is flawed.
thru 7 games this season is how I read it

 

[Fountain City Blues]

I would ask why but you're a KC fan and probably think Smith is better than Carr.

Sorta like Oakland fans thinking Carr is the MVP. And spoiler alert I think Carr is better.

 

[dkmightyhammer]

Anyone putting Wilson in their top 5-10 based off this year are not being honest or haven't seen many Hawk games. Maybe based off his last game he'd be ranked near the top, but not for the season. He had a pretty rough start.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

then your list is flawed.
thru 7 games this season is how I read it

That's just the catch, that's exactly what I did. Going by process not a sortable table of stats which plagues QB analysis.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Anyone putting Wilson in their top 5-10 based off this year are not being honest or haven't seen many Hawk games. Maybe based off his last game he'd be ranked near the top, but not for the season. He had a pretty rough start.

I am giving him a pass because of injury.

 

[Clayton]

Rodgers is very hard to rank. I know he is a tier 1 guy but the Packers playcalling/receivers/running game/defense is a bit of a mess. Maybe Rodgers has regressed but eh...

Tier 1: Brady, Brees, Wilson
Tier 1.5: Ryan, Stafford, Carr, Dalton
Tier 2: Mariota, Rodgers, Dak, Cam

 

[Clayton]

Anyone putting Wilson in their top 5-10 based off this year are not being honest or haven't seen many Hawk games. Maybe based off his last game he'd be ranked near the top, but not for the season. He had a pretty rough start.

I think you're just too used to seeing a great QB. Watch a few Alex Smith games and come back and watch Wilson 'struggle' and come back to me

 

[DJ]

Sorta like Oakland fans thinking Carr is the MVP. And spoiler alert I think Carr is better.

Carr isn't a possible MVP candidate considering our defense has been less than advertised with all the FA pickups? How else do you explain us being in the middle of the AFC West race?

 

[DJ]

Rodgers is very hard to rank. I know he is a tier 1 guy but the Packers playcalling/receivers/running game/defense is a bit of a mess. Maybe Rodgers has regressed but eh...

Tier 1: Brady, Brees, Wilson
Tier 1.5: Ryan, Stafford, Carr, Dalton
Tier 2: Mariota, Rodgers, Dak, Cam

I can sign off on that although I think he's better than Dalton. Dalton has regressed a little this season.

 

[DJ]

Anyone putting Wilson in their top 5-10 based off this year are not being honest or haven't seen many Hawk games. Maybe based off his last game he'd be ranked near the top, but not for the season. He had a pretty rough start.

He's in my top 10.....that game vs the Pats was awesome.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Anyone putting Wilson in their top 5-10 based off this year are not being honest or haven't seen many Hawk games. Maybe based off his last game he'd be ranked near the top, but not for the season. He had a pretty rough start.

I feel the same about Tom Brady

Seems he is being ranked high due to performances vs the Browns, Bills and Steelers defense

He misses 4 games, faces one team that has any semblance of defense, and looks league average in that game


ESPN was made for the guys on this board

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Carr isn't a possible MVP candidate considering our defense has been less than advertised with all the FA pickups? How else do you explain us being in the middle of the AFC West race?

Thanks to the sub-par day from Matt Ryan, I think Carr and Zeke are currently leading the MVP race by a decent margin

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Carr isn't a possible MVP candidate considering our defense has been less than advertised with all the FA pickups? How else do you explain us being in the middle of the AFC West race?

Best OL outside of Dallas, Cooper/Crabtree, and Latavius Murray if I feel like explaining it in one sentence. He's as protected as it gets as a QB. Reminding me of the Matt Ryan MVP crowd some years back.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Best OL outside of Dallas, Cooper/Crabtree, and Latavius Murray if I feel like explaining it in one sentence. He's as protected as it gets as a QB. Reminding me of the Matt Ryan MVP crowd some years back.

Just as a sidenote, Tennessee quietly has a pretty damn good Oline

 

[DJ]

I feel the same about Tom Brady

Seems he is being ranked high due to performances vs the Browns, Bills and Steelers defense

He misses 4 games, faces one team that has any semblance of defense, and looks league average in that game


ESPN was made for the guys on this board

Why did you leave Carr outta your top 10?

 

[DJ]

Best OL outside of Dallas, Cooper/Crabtree, and Latavius Murray if I feel like explaining it in one sentence. He's as protected as it gets as a QB. Reminding me of the Matt Ryan MVP crowd some years back.

So having a quality OL is a bad thing now.....okay.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Why did you leave Carr outta your top 10?

I did not, I amended my post, I totally forgot about Carr

He is possibly #1 for me now, with Ryan #3 and Dak # 3, as we sit here today

 

[Fountain City Blues]

List of "MVP" candidates I'd take over Carr

No order

Cowboys OL
Zeke
Brady
Brees
Ryan