tOfficial "Tom Brady & the New England Patriots" Superthread

[HammerDown]

My 2013 QB list:

1. Manning
2. Manning
3. Manning
4. Rivers
5. Rodgers
6. Brees
7. Wilson
8. Stafford
9. Locker
10. Dalton
11. Ryan
12. Luck
13. Alex Smith
14. Tannehill
15. Romo
16. Flacco
17. Roethlisberger
18. Vick
19. Bradford
20. Manuel
21. Griffin
22. Glennon
23. Pryor
24. Schaub
25. Henne
26. Brady

 

[Tai Chi≈Surfing]

 

[Octoberfest23]

Given what he has to work with...he's still top 2-3. Obviously Peyton is MVP this year but look at the weapons he has. Brady is working with guys that wouldn't start for the browns.

 

[Octoberfest23]

My 2013 QB list:

1. Manning
2. Manning
3. Manning
4. Rivers
5. Rodgers
6. Brees
7. Wilson
8. Stafford
9. Locker
10. Dalton
11. Ryan
12. Luck
13. Alex Smith
14. Tannehill
15. Romo
16. Flacco
17. Roethlisberger
18. Vick
19. Bradford
20. Manuel
21. Griffin
22. Glennon
23. Pryor
24. Schaub
25. Henne
26. Brady

9. Locker!?!?!?! Roflmao!!! C'mon man!

 

[broncosmitty]

Hahahaha

 

[broncosmitty]

My 2013 QB list:

1. Manning
2. Manning
3. Manning
4. Rivers
5. Rodgers
6. Brees
7. Wilson
8. Stafford
9. Locker
10. Dalton
11. Ryan
12. Luck
13. Alex Smith
14. Tannehill
15. Romo
16. Flacco
17. Roethlisberger
18. Vick
19. Bradford
20. Manuel
21. Griffin
22. Glennon
23. Pryor
24. Schaub
25. Henne
26. Brady

I have Carson Palmer and Jay Cutler flip flopped, but otherwise it's a good list.

 

[Golden Spur]

My 2013 QB list:

1. Manning
2. Manning
3. Manning
4. Rivers
5. Rodgers
6. Brees
7. Wilson
8. Stafford
9. Locker
10. Dalton
11. Ryan
12. Luck
13. Alex Smith
14. Tannehill
15. Romo
16. Flacco
17. Roethlisberger
18. Vick
19. Bradford
20. Manuel
21. Griffin
22. Glennon
23. Pryor
24. Schaub
25. Henne
26. Brady

I have Carson Palmer and Jay Cutler flip flopped, but otherwise it's a good list.

Unless you're going for the funny. Yeah man, Glennon, Pryor, Schaub, Henne, Vick, Ben, Bradford, Tannehill, Locker, Manuel, Griffin, and Henne have been better than Cam. LMFAO!

 

[HammerDown]

Unless you're going for the funny. Yeah man, Glennon, Pryor, Schaub, Henne, Vick, Ben, Bradford, Tannehill, Locker, Griffin, and Henne have been better than Cam. LMFAO!

I messed my list up by accidentally deleting Cutler, Palmer and Newton when I was switching some players around. Since I left them off, just removed Brady at the bottom and take off the extra Mannings to make room.

 

[broncosmitty]

Unless you're going for the funny. Yeah man, Glennon, Pryor, Schaub, Henne, Vick, Ben, Bradford, Tannehill, Locker, Manuel, Griffin, and Henne have been better than Cam. LMFAO!

I like Cam Newton tbh.(didn't notice he wasn't listed) I just hate Cutler and Palmer. And I get a kick out of Pats fans love of Tom Terrific. (Big fan of Scott Dreisbach back in the day.... Tom not so much). I didn't take HD's triple Manning list overly serious. (I'd complain about Staff being ranked over Luck. And I'd have Russel Wilson lower, Alex Smith higher, Locker waaaay lower, Glennon below Josh Freeman, Thad Lewis over somebody, Brian Hoyer somewhere, etc...)

 

[NinerSickness]

Football fans love their lists & power rankings don't they?

 

[cwood]

Given what he has to work with...he's still top 2-3. Obviously Peyton is MVP this year but look at the weapons he has. Brady is working with guys that wouldn't start for the browns.

Not sure how you can say that. He hasn't had much to work with but it's not like he's even been average. He's been horrible. Rodgers has just played the better part of two games with Nelson, 2 undrafted free agent receivers who had a combined 5 career receptions 2 weeks ago, no 4th receiver, and a backup tight end. That's worse than anything Brady has been dealing with.

 

[hockey878]

Peyton with Reggie, Blair WHite, Austin COllie, and Jacob Tamme, worst running game in the NFL.

"He has so many great weapons"

Brady with Gronk, Amendola, Edelman, Collie, Dobson, Thompkins, solid running game.

"He is doing what he can with what he has"

Every WR that has ever played significant time with Peyton has produced. ANd many have struggled after they left. (Dallas Clark, Collie, White, Garcon). Guess who was also a no-name coming into this year? Julius Thomas! Now suddenly people rave about him being so good. Weird how that works! Last year Stokley was as stud. The years before that he was a bench warmer.

Why can't brady do the same?

 

[RegentDenali]

I think this should impact his ranking. Appears Mr. Bundchen was supposed to be a lion, but Giselle made him wear something that had him look like a cast member from the Broadway show "Cats".

And of course his job for the evening was to carry her purse around.

 

[Nipsey]

Gotcha. So let's praise the guy because they eeked out wins against bad teams. The wins are on him, the losses are on the D. Right.

Did you watch any of those games? Would you say that Brady played like an elite QB in any of them, or are you just going to stick with the ole "wins and losses" bullshit that does nothing but prove that Alex Smith is the best QB in the league?

There are at least a dozen college QBs I can think of off the top of my head who are more accurate passers than Tom Brady.

"Oh, well that's the receivers."

Tom Brady has great receivers.

"He can make ANYONE a superstar."

Tom Brady has bad receivers.

"It's not HIS fault they're terrible!"

The Brady knob-slobbing is unparalleled in sports.

"Brady is nowhere near his receivers on almost all passes this season cause he's trying to make them work harder. No QB does that!!!"

Beyond belief...

 

[Ryanballa]

I do think Brady will get it going eventually,maybe even this week. But here lately he has not been himself and NE is lucky they have been winning. I am actually starting Andy Dalton over him on my fantasy football team.

 

[Manning2Luck_uJelly]

this YEAR, Tom brady is not a top 5 QB. Heck, he's not even Top 10.

 

[Bulldog]

Brady is worth $100M, is married to a supermodel and lives in the biggest mansion in Beverly Hills. And Bulldog is so fucking intelligent that he was able to surmise that I'm jealous of Tom Brady. Wow, how insightful you are, Bulldog! No one ever accused you of being bright, did they?

Is my "eye sight" impaired or is Brady's? Something is making him miss his receivers by a mile and they need to figure out what it is or he's going to lead the lead in INTs and lowest completion %.

You're a poor excuse for a human being when jealousy overrides your common sense. You don't have to listen to what I say our anyone else says about Tom Brady. However, when his career is over and is analyzed by football experts he will be ranked in the top 5 greatest that ever played the game, maybe even the top 3.

By the way I don't see many people offering you an invitation to mensa, but then again your a self proclaimed genious.

 

[Bulldog]

I messed my list up by accidentally deleting Cutler, Palmer and Newton when I was switching some players around. Since I left them off, just removed Brady at the bottom and take off the extra Mannings to make room.

After looking at your list I would say you messed your pants and that explains the list.

 

[Blitzville]

You're a poor excuse for a human being when jealousy overrides your common sense. You don't have to listen to what I say our anyone else says about Tom Brady. However, when his career is over and is analyzed by football experts he will be ranked in the top 5 greatest that ever played the game, maybe even the top 3.

By the way I don't see many people offering you an invitation to mensa, but then again your a self proclaimed genious.

You're the only one in this thread that can't seem to understand that we're talking about this season. Maybe Hammer is right about you.

 

[MrMoJoRisin63]

Bottom line Brady is not a top 10 QB this year, hell may not be top 15. IMO he has done as well as can be expected seeing as he basically lost everything but Edelman the first six weeks.