The GOAT

[Rock Strongo]

its hysterical to finally see people come around. 69% say yes lol.

debate is over. now its gravy time.

 

[Rock Strongo]

there were 14 teams, dummy

 

[GNG]

Winning the title is always good. But doing it in a 13-team league isn't quite the same as doing it in a 32-team league.

I t was just as or even more difficult because there weren't as many cupcake teams back in the day.

 

[GNG]

there were 14 teams, dummy

I don't care if there were 44 teams. It doesn't make any difference bozo.

 

[Rock Strongo]

I don't care if there were 44 teams. It doesn't make any difference bozo.

sure it does. starr faced less than 1/2 the competition.

its like the celtics beating teams in an 8 team NBA, vs teams like buffalo and KC. old banners need asterisks, and im a C's fan.

 

[GNG]

sure it does. starr faced less than 1/2 the competition.

its like the celtics beating teams in an 8 team NBA, vs teams like buffalo and KC. old banners need asterisks, and im a C's fan.

Take off your homer glasses and try to view the world objectively like I do.

 

[sonnyblack65]

Take off your homer glasses and try to view the world objectively like I do.

Find me 1 list anywhere that has Starr as no#1 now who has the homer glasses? You never give supposedly your team's guy Staubach any love but Starr,Favre and Rodgers. They do have Starr as GB#s 1 QB so your right there

Bart Starr: The greatest QB in Green Bay Packers history

 

[DHoey]

I thought this thread was about Josh McDaniels

 

[Wazmankg]

Without Joe Montana, there probably wouldn't be a Tom Brady

Nah, some other QB would have been his hero.

 

[GNG]

Find me 1 list anywhere that has Starr as no#1 now who has the homer glasses? You never give supposedly your team's guy Staubach any love but Starr,Favre and Rodgers. They do have Starr as GB#s 1 QB so your right there

Bart Starr: The greatest QB in Green Bay Packers history

Staubach never won 5 NFL Championships like Starr did. I'm a die hard Cowboys fan but I give credit where credit is due.

 

[Rock Strongo]

Take off your homer glasses and try to view the world objectively like I do.

i just did. remember when i just said i dont count the old celtics banners in 8 team league?

i do.

there were 14 teams in starrs day. 14. there are 32 now.

 

[sonnyblack65]

Staubach never won 5 NFL Championships like Starr did. I'm a die hard Cowboys fan but I give credit where credit is due.

How many SB's has Favre and Rodgers won each?

 

[GNG]

i just did. remember when i just said i dont count the old celtics banners in 8 team league?

i do.

there were 14 teams in starrs day. 14. there are 32 now.

So what? Do you think there should be an asterisk by the titles?

 

[GNG]

How many SB's has Favre and Rodgers won each?

2 between them but I never claimed Favre or Rodgers are the GOAT.

 

[Rock Strongo]

So what? Do you think there should be an asterisk by the titles?

well, there already is. they arent super bowls, they are title games.

in a 14 team league...

before free agency...

60 years ago...

their lineman are now our kickers, by size comparison.

stop, you look absolutely foolish.

 

[Rock Strongo]

these arguments are dead now, not sure why im bothering. bradys the undisputed GOAT. 5 rings, 7 appearances, in this era of free agency, salary caps, etc.

bart starr lmao

"johnny unitas. theres a haircut you can set your watch to"

 

[sonnyblack65]

2 between them but I never claimed Favre or Rodgers are the GOAT.

Fair enough G&G Staubach won 2 SB's with a 30 team format impressive Captain comeback. Some guys fold under pressure or are headcases and fall apart when behind the 8 ball

 

[GNG]

well, there already is. they arent super bowls, they are title games.

in a 14 team league...

before free agency...

60 years ago...

their lineman are now our kickers, by size comparison.

stop, you look absolutely foolish.

I'm not a homer like you and respect accomplishments of a different era. Do you think Tiger woods is better than Jack Nicklaus because Nicklaus played in a different era?

 

[sonnyblack65]

2 between them but I never claimed Favre or Rodgers are the GOAT.

Guys like Starr, Unitas and Graham are and will prob be always top 10. Legends

 

[GNG]

Fair enough G&G Staubach won 2 SB's with a 30 team format impressive Captain comeback. Some guys fold under pressure or are headcases and fall apart when behind the 8 ball

You should have seen me in high school...