QB question for this week, and ROS

[TREFF]

This week with Romo out, I've grabbed RGIII and Eli off the trash heap.
Eli playing at home against Indy, or
RGIII @ Minn?

And I have to carry 2 QB's..Romo, RGIII, and Eli, which two would you rather have? If it matters in your decision, I also have Dez, Garcon, and ODB Jr.

 

[Chef99]

This week with Romo out, I've grabbed RGIII and Eli off the trash heap.
Eli playing at home against Indy, or
RGIII @ Minn?

And I have to carry 2 QB's..Romo, RGIII, and Eli, which two would you rather have? If it matters in your decision, I also have Dez, Garcon, and ODB Jr.

For this week I think I'd have to go with Eli...Vikes D is getting better and you don't know how RGIII is going to play yet.

I'd have to think long and hard about the second part...my gut says Romo and RGIII.

 

[leftypower]

For this week I think I'd have to go with Eli...Vikes D is getting better and you don't know how RGIII is going to play yet.

I'd have to think long and hard about the second part...my gut says Romo and RGIII.

Not that I've had that great of luck with QB's this year but I tend to agree. .....

 

[Yellow Fuzzies]

I am not trusting RGIII this year, therefore Eli for this week and Romo and Eli for the rest of year.

 

[SteelersPride]

Id go eli, you at least know hes gonna throw, it may not be pretty......but he will........

rg3 is a complete question mark...........

playing indy this week eli should be throwing alot

 

[TKOSpikes]

Yes. What Fuzzy said.

 

[TREFF]

Well so far everything is matching what I'm feeling as well. Start Eli this week and conflicting feelings about ROS.


How about if we take the scoring into account?

5pt bonus for every ten yards out on scoring plays up to a max 35pt play on a passing TD of 61 yards or longer.
Additional 5 pts bonus for "out of position" scores longer than ten yards. ..i.e. a rushing or receiving TD from the QB of 10 yards is five points same as a RB, but from 11 is 15 (10 for a RB), to a max of a 40pt play for a 61yd or longer rushing/receiving TD.

 

[tlance]

I agree that Eli is the play this week.

Long term though RG3 and Romo are who you want. They both have tasty matchups down the stretch and RG3 has the highest upside of the bunch. Still though, I want to see him prove it before starting him in most cases.

Ironically, I am starting RG3 in MBBRL.

 

[wilwhite]

The problem is that both Romo and RGIII are "if things go okay" guys. Normally I'd say both of those, and I have no faith in Eli, but at least Eli sees the field.

On the other hand holding Romo and streaming at QB when he's out isn't crazy. This week I'd probably want Tannehill over Eli... but I have some weird allergy to Eli so take that with a grain of salt.

 

[TREFF]

The problem is that both Romo and RGIII are "if things go okay" guys. Normally I'd say both of those, and I have no faith in Eli, but at least Eli sees the field.

On the other hand holding Romo and streaming at QB when he's out isn't crazy. This week I'd probably want Tannehill over Eli... but I have some weird allergy to Eli so take that with a grain of salt.

You couldn't pay my entry fee for the next decade to get me to start Trannyhill for even one week,. or Alex Smith for that matter. Even if it worked out I'd feel so hypocritical that I might dive into a deep depression

Bad enough that I'm starting Eli.. but I have ride him to the playoffs many years ago, so at least there's that.

 

[TREFF]

I agree that Eli is the play this week.

Long term though RG3 and Romo are who you want. They both have tasty matchups down the stretch and RG3 has the highest upside of the bunch. Still though, I want to see him prove it before starting him in most cases.

Ironically, I am starting RG3 in MBBRL.

And playing me. . Another reason why i really would rather not have him going for my $ league

 

[Sam Sportboy]

I'm on the fence here..............I just keep thinking about the Cincy game (I'm a glass half empty guy) when maybe I should be thinking about what Ben just did to Indy..............that said, this week I'd go Eli but I think I'd go RGIII the rest of the way if I see anything form him at all.

 

[TREFF]

Well in my system Eli had 38, Tranny 50, RGIII 21... list by 19.. so either way I would've lost, but I didn't sell my soul to the devil this way