Martellus Bennett ranks Rodgers ahead of Brady

[DirtDirtDirt]

Paul O'Neil > Derek Jeter

LOL

No prob, an all time fave of mine

Im not a Jeter Lover, I wont put up much of a fight

 

[Ricky Roma]

We may be asking this question about Jimmy in a decade

Why wait? Someone sat behind Drew Bledsoe, who was far less accomplished than Favre, and the only reason Brady saw the field the time he did was due to injury.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Be serious.

Drop back, read the D and get the ball out to the open man. Brady's ability to do this simple, fundamental function of the quarterbacking is why he is considered the greatest to ever play the game and your pickle puffing QB's inability to do it is why Green Bay fans will end up bragging about how Rodgers ran for more yards than Mike Vick.

LOL...Brady doesnt move because he has the athleticism of an elephant

When Rodgers moves, we call that "Extending plays", buying time where most other QB's are on their backs already

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Why wait? Someone sat behind Drew Bledsoe, who was far less accomplished than Favre, and the only reason Brady saw the field the time he did was due to injury.

Mariano Rivera was in the Yankee BP for 3 years before they realized "Maybe this guy can close"

 

[black francis]

Maybe someone can tell me why Rodgers rode the pines behind a washed up interception machine for 3 years if he is so great?

Because he doesnt cheat?

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

No but what accounts for that is that since 2009 the majority of the elite QB play has been in the NFC. Sure that sucks for Rodgers but it doesn't mean his D has been bad on a whole. Other than Ben and Peyton there really hasn't been high level QB play in the AFC ( save Brady ) since Tom started playing . You could argue Rivers as well I suppose but in 3 of those 4 losses you mentioned GB was playing HOF/fringe HOF guys and 1 other loss came to a young guy who is on his way to that status. Shit you could argue 9 of Rodgers 17 career playoff games have been facing fringe HOF QBs or better

Real desperate response.......All you have to do is watch in January to see how bad GB's D fails them time and time again......For Jeters sake, Rodgers had to fight for his life in Dallas last season after giving his defense a 31-10 lead

 

[Rex Racer]

Are you really that stupid or or you just stirring the pot?

Who holds the NFL record for interceptions thrown? 59 more than the next closest guy on the list

Who rode the pines for his first 3 years while the aforementioned drug addled, interception machine started ahead of him?

 

[Brees#1]

Because the falcons beat Rodgers and lost to Brady(not my logic).

 

[Rex Racer]

LOL

No prob, an all time fave of mine

Im not a Jeter Lover, I wont put up much of a fight

Shit, I should have gone with Bernie Williams

 

[sonnyblack65]

The Pats have a better team surrounding Brady than the Packers have surrounding Rodgers. Take Brady off the Pats and they'd still make the playoffs. The same can't be said for Green Bay.

Both years Brady wasn't starting they didn't make the playoffs. Flynn did ok for a few games with GB. He threw for 6tds vs Detroit

 

[rmilia1]

Real desperate response.......All you have to do is watch in January to see how bad GB's D fails them time and time again......For Jeters sake, Rodgers had to fight for his life in Dallas last season after giving his defense a 31-10 lead

Not desperate it's reality. More than half if Rodgers games have been vs top flight QB play. 15 of Bradys 34 have but 5 of those are in Super Bowls so 8/16 for Rodgers in NFC play and 10/27 for Brady. That's why the numbers discrepancy. Flip the script and the results would be the opposite

 

[SeizeTheCarp]

Be serious.

Drop back, read the D and get the ball out to the open man. Brady's ability to do this simple, fundamental function of the quarterbacking is why he is considered the greatest to ever play the game and your pickle puffing QB's inability to do it is why Green Bay fans will end up bragging about how Rodgers ran for more yards than Mike Vick.

Rodgers without any doubt, has that ability. I think he may looking for the home run ball a little too often rather than taking what's underneath, but getting rid of the ball quickly when he wants to, has never been an issue.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Not desperate it's reality. More than half if Rodgers games have been vs top flight QB play. 15 of Bradys 34 have but 5 of those are in Super Bowls so 8/16 for Rodgers in NFC play and 10/27 for Brady. That's why the numbers discrepancy. Flip the script and the results would be the opposite

if youre flipping head coaches

Theres a guy that stopped the greatest show on turf

He also kicked in Peyton Mannings dick about 800 times while the COlts were setting records offensively

Mike Mccarthy cant get the Falcons to punt

 

[Rex Racer]

Real desperate response.......All you have to do is watch in January to see how bad GB's D fails them time and time again......For Jeters sake, Rodgers had to fight for his life in Dallas last season after giving his defense a 31-10 lead

All I have to do is watch the NFL playoffs to see that Rodgers fails time and time again while the other guy overcomes his defense's shortcomings and wins

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Both years Brady wasn't starting they didn't make the playoffs. Flynn did ok for a few games with GB. He threw for 6tds vs Detroit

Flynn Made a lot of mooolah off that game

 

[sonnyblack65]

Brady = Jeter

product of the system who put up weaker numbers in the playoffs than in the regular season

Yet people call them clutch

True Jeter has hit 70 hrs in a season and 200 hits

 

[Rex Racer]

Because he doesnt cheat?

Sorry, the correct answer is Moe Lewis.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

All I have to do is watch the NFL playoffs to see that Rodgers fails time and time again while the other guy overcomes his defense's shortcomings and wins

You don't.......

Green Bay loses to Atlanta, Falcons dont punt all day long - Rodgers fault

NE beats Atlanta, defense holds them to 7 second half points, makes enormous play after enormous play - Brady wins

Dont get me wrong, Brady was great, but he needed his Defense to come up with huge play after huge play to win that Super Bowl

 

[Rex Racer]

Flynn Made a lot of mooolah off that game

Seattle

 

[Rex Racer]

You don't.......

Green Bay loses to Atlanta, Falcons dont punt all day long - Rodgers fault

NE beats Atlanta, defense holds them to 7 second half points, makes enormous play after enormous play - Brady wins

Dont get me wrong, Brady was great, but he needed his Defense to come up with huge play after huge play to win that Super Bowl

31 unanswered points and it was the defense ......... OY