Game time

[tzill]

Just answer the question. You obviously know who I am referring to...

I'm not sure; hence the question.

 

[tzill]

My guess would be Fister, but I don't remember the Giants drafting him.

 

[calsnowskier]

My guess would be Fister, but I don't remember the Giants drafting him.

They did. In the 49th round as a draft and watch (and as a first baseman).

You're up...

 

[tzill]

I am an 18 time All-Star. Played for two teams in my 19 year career. ROY and later an MVP. Four playoffs, and the Orioles knocked me out three times, the Brewers once. Never played in a WS.

I am not Jewish.

 

[calsnowskier]

Aaron?

 

[tzill]

Aaron?

Nope

 

[calsnowskier]

Never mind...

 

[Mays-Fan]

Aaron?

Hah - clever guess. Closer than you think, but in an obscure way.

 

[jwolt92]

I am an 18 time All-Star. Played for two teams in my 19 year career. ROY and later an MVP. Four playoffs, and the Orioles knocked me out three times, the Brewers once. Never played in a WS.

I am not Jewish.

If I'm not a Giants fan can I play? lol been watching and enjoying this

 

[LHG]

I am an 18 time All-Star. Played for two teams in my 19 year career. ROY and later an MVP. Four playoffs, and the Orioles knocked me out three times, the Brewers once. Never played in a WS.

I am not Jewish.

I would guess this player to be in the AL for at least part of his career and probably played between the 60s and 80s. However, most of the guys I'm thinking of played for more than two teams. I feel like the answer will be obvious, but, of course, I will miss it.

I will guess Carlton Fisk.

 

[LHG]

Hah - clever guess. Closer than you think, but in an obscure way.

Wait, why aren't you guessing an answer?

 

[LHG]

If I'm not a Giants fan can I play? lol been watching and enjoying this

Venture forth an answer, and if the mods don't like it, they can let you know.

 

[jwolt92]

my guess would be Rod Carew. I know he made a ton of all-star teams, not sure if it's 18 or not. Or if he's Jewish or not.

 

[calsnowskier]

my guess would be Rod Carew. I know he made a ton of all-star teams, not sure if it's 18 or not. Or if he's Jewish or not.

Carew is famously Jewish (unless there is some kind of odd loophole in the clue)...

 

[calsnowskier]

Wait, why aren't you guessing an answer?

I was wondering this as well. Maybe he looked it up, so is taking himself out of the competition??

 

[Stokes1931]

my guess would be Rod Carew. I know he made a ton of all-star teams, not sure if it's 18 or not. Or if he's Jewish or not.

I would venture Carew as a guess, too. Not many 18-time All-Stars. I grew up in MN, and the Twins lost twice to the O's in the playoffs, and the Angels lost to the O's once as well. Don't remember anything about the Brewers, unless it was the 1982 team with Yount and Molitor.

 

[Mays-Fan]

Wait, why aren't you guessing an answer?

Because I cheated. That is a no-no for any lurkers out there.

 

[Mays-Fan]

Carew is famously Jewish (unless there is some kind of odd loophole in the clue)...

Carew was "outed" as a Jew in an Adam Sandler parody song. The "outing' was strictly a spoof - probably needed his name to rhyme something else, like "Jew" maybe?.

 

[tzill]

I would guess this player to be in the AL for at least part of his career and probably played between the 60s and 80s. However, most of the guys I'm thinking of played for more than two teams. I feel like the answer will be obvious, but, of course, I will miss it.

I will guess Carlton Fisk.

Nope.

 

[tzill]

my guess would be Rod Carew. I know he made a ton of all-star teams, not sure if it's 18 or not. Or if he's Jewish or not.

Correct. He ALMOST converted, but is not Jewish.

Played for Twins and Angels. ROY 1967; MVP 1977. 4 ALCS but never in the WS.

You are up.