Every NFL Team’s Best & Worst Quarterback of All-Time

[ATL96Steeler]

Before my time too. Shiner was the guy who Bradshaw replaced.

If we wanted to go absolute worst, we could do worse than Malone and Woodley, too. Laundry Jones.
But there is a special burning hatred for someone who threw interceptions directly at Larry Brown in the Superbowl.

I wonder if the city ever forgave him?...ya know, BOS forgave Bill Buckner...which was good to see before he passed.

I thought I heard from someone in the 'Burgh that he was welcomed back, but I don't remember it.

Jones was never really considered the starter, but for QBs who have started at least 3 games...statistically he would be better than Woodley and Malone.

 

[Yankee Traveler]

For the Pats, Brady.

Then a big drop to Bledsoe, a smaller drop to Grogan and Flutie.

Then a cliff to a bunch of forgettable names.

FIFY

 

[Pure Steel]

Steelers:

Best:
The Original TB 12

Worst:
O'Donnell, who actively lost a Superbowl. I could say Malone, he sucked, or any number of other guys who suited up in the early suck or 80's dark years. But O'Donnell is actively hated for making a SB MVP of Larry Brown.


A guy named Dick Shiner used to play QB for the Steelers.

I can see the hatred for O'Donnell that lots of Steeler fans have, but he isn't close to the worst.....He had a 81 QB rating as a Steeler, low interception % (oh the irony) and outside of giving the SB away on two mind boggling bad throws, he's light years ahead of Malone, Woodley, and Tomczak of the forgettable 80's.....I saw him at a local bar years after that SB, lives a few towns over from me, I had my Steeler hat on, I wanted to gently punch him.....

 

[Schmoopy1000]

Greatest: Ken Anderson/and Andy Dalton tied for best.
Worst avid Klinger

you have lost your mind girl!

 

[Vegas]

Does the Packers say Seneca Wallace?

Got to be Jerry Tagge. Wasted 1st round draft pick. One of several moves Dan Devine made to get a QB. He traded two #2 picks for Jim Del Gaizo. He wasted a #1 on Tagge. Then he made the worst trade in NFL history for a washed up John Hadl. It was known as the "Lawrence Welk Trade." A one and a two and a one two three. Eight total draft picks for 3 terrible QBs.

 

[Robotech]

Steelers:

Best:
The Original TB 12

Worst:
O'Donnell, who actively lost a Superbowl. I could say Malone, he sucked, or any number of other guys who suited up in the early suck or 80's dark years. But O'Donnell is actively hated for making a SB MVP of Larry Brown.


A guy named Dick Shiner used to play QB for the Steelers.

Does anyone remember the Married With Children episode where Al Bundy meets Larry Brown and tells him that O'Donnell basically gave him the ball? Then Larry Brown says something like, "Shush, the Raiders don't know that." LMAO!!!!!!!

 

[Jiddy]

Poor Bob Avellini...Granted, I never hear the old time Bears fans whine about him. Bobby Douglass, however....Hooo boy.

 

[Nosferatu]

Vikes

Best - Warren Moon
Worst - Tarvaris Jackson

 

[Jiddy]

I don't remember Elvis Grbac being horrendous or anything...Flacco playing for 50 years must have something to do with that.

 

[Jiddy]

Vikes

Best - Warren Moon
Worst - Tarvaris Jackson

Joe Webb should get an honorable mention or something. That was the dumbest sh*t ever.

 

[Schmoopy1000]

Vikes

Best - Warren Moon
Worst - Tarvaris Jackson

kind of surprising.
While Warren Moon was a bad ass. His short time with the team vs. longevity of some of your older QBs. kinda surprises me you go with Moon.

 

[boogiewithstu2007]

The link that gets messed up on this site has for these teams:

This is dated Feb of 2019

AZ Cards Best = Jim Hart and worst = Ryan Lindley

Atlanta = Matt Ryan as best and worst Randy Johnson

Baltimore = Joe Flacco as best and Elvis Grbac as worst

Buffalo = Jim Kelly best and Alex Van Pelt as worst

Carolina = Cam Newton and best and Jimmy Clausen as worst

Chicago = Best Sid Luckman and worst Bob Avellini

Bengals = Ken Anderson as best and Akili Smith as the worst

Cleveland = Otto Graham the best and Brandon Weeden the worst

Dallas = Roger Staubach best and Chad Huchison as worst

Denver = John Elway the best and Steve Tensi the worst

Lions = Best Bobby Lane and worst is Joey Harrington

Green Bay = best Favre and worst Randy Wright

Houston = best Matt Schaub and worst Dave Carr

Colts = best Manning and worst Curtis Painter

Jags = best Brunnell and worst Blaine Gabbert

KC = best Len Dawson and worst Todd Blackledge

Chargers = best Dan Fouts and worst Ryan Leaf

Rams - Best Jurt Warner and worst Dan Pastorini

Miami = best Marino and worst Rick Norton

Vikings = best Tarkenton and worst Spergon Wynn

Patriots = best Brady and worst Mike Taliaferro

Saints = best Breese and worst Heath Shuler

Giants = best ELi Manning and worst Dave Brown

Jets = Best Namath and worst Browning Nagle

Raiders = best Stabler and worst Jamarcuss Russel

Eagles = best McNabb and worst Bobby Hoying

Steelers = best Bradshaw and worst Mark Malone

San Fran = best Montana and worst Steve Spurier

Seahawks = best R Wilson and worst Stan Gelbaugh

Tampa = best Brad JOhnson and worst old Vinny Testaverde

Titans = best Waren Moon and worst Billy Joe Tolliver

Redskins = best Sammy Baugh and worst Ralph Guglielmi


Stan the man!! He actually did pretty good for us under the circumstance he was put in, I actually liked Stan.... McGwire was our worst, he was a 1st round pick #16 and a total flop that did nothing but get sacked OVER and OVER ... And what makes it even worse, we drafted McGwire ahead of Favre... OUCH... Chuck Knox at the time lobbied like hell to get Favre but he was overruled by Behring ...

 

[Nosferatu]

kind of surprising.
While Warren Moon was a bad ass. His short time with the team vs. longevity of some of your older QBs. kinda surprises me you go with Moon.

Like the hugely overrated Tarkenton? Eh, he sucked when it mattered. What else did we have? Wade Wilson, Tommy Kramer, Dante Culpepper, Christian Laettner, Brad Johnson, that's a lot of not real good. Moon wasn't the best quarterback for the Vikings but he's the best quarterback that ever played for the Vikings, in my opinion anyhow... Cunningham and Favre were real good for one year...

 

[Cedrique]

For the Eagles I like Randall Cunningham. But to make all you haters happy, I will add that Wentz "Almost" made it. For worst I'm going with a guy named Mike Boryla, who probably no one has heard of.

 

[Schmoopy1000]

Like the hugely overrated Tarkenton? Eh, he sucked when it mattered. What else did we have? Wade Wilson, Tommy Kramer, Dante Culpepper, Christian Laettner, Brad Johnson, that's a lot of not real good. Moon wasn't the best quarterback for the Vikings but he's the best quarterback that ever played for the Vikings, in my opinion anyhow... Cunningham and Favre were real good for one year...

not making an argument. Its your team. Just food for thought.

BTW I liked Kramer back in the day.

 

[Nosferatu]

not making an argument. Its your team. Just food for thought.

BTW I liked Kramer back in the day.

He was very streaky.

 

[Myles]

Greatest: Ken Anderson/and Andy Dalton tied for best.
Worst avid Klinger

Dalton?

 

[Pure Steel]

not making an argument. Its your team. Just food for thought.

BTW I liked Kramer back in the day.

And booze liked him......

 

[Myles]

kind of surprising.
While Warren Moon was a bad ass. His short time with the team vs. longevity of some of your older QBs. kinda surprises me you go with Moon.

I would of went with Culpepper. That one year where he threw for over 4700 yards, completed 70% of his passes and threw for 39 TD's with only 11 INT's was an incredible season.

 

[GNG]

Vikes

Best - Warren Moon
Worst - Tarvaris Jackson

Joe Kapp?