Every NFL Team’s Best & Worst Quarterback of All-Time

[Pattersonca65]

I'd say Tim Rattay or J.T. O'Sullivan.

I think Drunkenmiller and Giovanni Carmazzi are at the top. But those two were pretty bad also

 

[Pattersonca65]

No love for Steve Young?

Love Steve Young. I actually defended him in the early 90s when other fans were blaming him for the losses to Dallas but he is still no #2 to Montana

 

[Pattersonca65]

spurrier

That was a bad one for sure.

 

[molsaniceman]

Really, with the likes of Tommy Hodgson (sp), Hugh Millen, Rohan Davey taking snaps, you chose Plunkett?

well could add joe kapp 17 picks in 10 games

 

[pachyderm]

RAIDERS

Best, IMHO, Plunkett. No data to back it up just my heart.

Worst: Jay Schroeder

Spoiler

Yeah, Gannon and Stabler were probably greater than Plunkett.

 

[Anointed One]

Surprised Ryan Leaf wasn't higher on that list...

 

[pachyderm]

Surprised Ryan Leaf wasn't higher on that list...

 

[poewelch84]

I'd say Tim Rattay or J.T. O'Sullivan.

Those two were he first that came to mind for me. Another one could be Ken Dorsey.

 

[Rex Racer]

RAIDERS

Best, IMHO, Plunkett. No data to back it up just my heart.

Worst: Jay Schroeder

Spoiler

Yeah, Gannon and Stabler were probably greater than Plunkett.

1. Stabler

2. Plunkett

Gannon, a distant 3rd

 

[Scooby-Doo]

Ouch

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

Are telling me you are trying to forget Dan McGuire?

My bad if I made you remember him

Brutal, just brutal. Stan Gelbaugh is right up there.

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

RAIDERS

Best, IMHO, Plunkett. No data to back it up just my heart.

Worst: Jay Schroeder

Spoiler

Yeah, Gannon and Stabler were probably greater than Plunkett.

Jamarcus Russell?

 

[TheRangerDude]

Cowboys:
Best - Romo
Worst - Romo

 

[RobToxin]

Ladies and gentlemen, we are sad to announce that the Worst Quarterback in Houston Texans history (yes, even worse than David Carr) just announced his retirement this month,

Thanks for the nightmares. Bork Asswiper.

 

[LambeauLegs]

Does the Packers say Seneca Wallace?

No it was Randy Wright which I did not really agree with

 

[Robotech]

For the 49ers, the best is easy. Joe Montana. The link didn't work but would be interesting to see who they choose as the worst. Choosing the worst is much harder. I am not sure who that would be after a 40 year history when the bad ones are forgotten over time.

I pick Montana, too, but Young has a strong case, so it's not that easy in my mind.

 

[LambeauLegs]

The link that gets messed up on this site has for these teams:

This is dated Feb of 2019

AZ Cards Best = Jim Hart and worst = Ryan Lindley

Atlanta = Matt Ryan as best and worst Randy Johnson

Baltimore = Joe Flacco as best and Elvis Grbac as worst

Buffalo = Jim Kelly best and Alex Van Pelt as worst

Carolina = Cam Newton and best and Jimmy Clausen as worst

Chicago = Best Sid Luckman and worst Bob Avellini

Bengals = Ken Anderson as best and Akili Smith as the worst

Cleveland = Otto Graham the best and Brandon Weeden the worst

Dallas = Roger Staubach best and Chad Huchison as worst

Denver = John Elway the best and Steve Tensi the worst

Lions = Best Bobby Lane and worst is Joey Harrington

Green Bay = best Favre and worst Randy Wright

Houston = best Matt Schaub and worst Dave Carr

Colts = best Manning and worst Curtis Painter

Jags = best Brunnell and worst Blaine Gabbert

KC = best Len Dawson and worst Todd Blackledge

Chargers = best Dan Fouts and worst Ryan Leaf

Rams - Best Jurt Warner and worst Dan Pastorini

Miami = best Marino and worst Rick Norton

Vikings = best Tarkenton and worst Spergon Wynn

Patriots = best Brady and worst Mike Taliaferro

Saints = best Breese and worst Heath Shuler

Giants = best ELi Manning and worst Dave Brown

Jets = Best Namath and worst Browning Nagle

Raiders = best Stabler and worst Jamarcuss Russel

Eagles = best McNabb and worst Bobby Hoying

Steelers = best Bradshaw and worst Mark Malone

San Fran = best Montana and worst Steve Spurier

Seahawks = best R Wilson and worst Stan Gelbaugh

Tampa = best Brad JOhnson and worst old Vinny Testaverde

Titans = best Waren Moon and worst Billy Joe Tolliver

Redskins = best Sammy Baugh and worst Ralph Guglielmi

 

[Winged_Wheel88]

Detroit:

Best - Matthew Stafford
Worst - Matthew Stafford

 

[broncosmitty]

Detroit:

Best - Matthew Stafford
Worst - Matthew Stafford

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

The link that gets messed up on this site has for these teams:

This is dated Feb of 2019

AZ Cards Best = Jim Hart and worst = Ryan Lindley

Atlanta = Matt Ryan as best and worst Randy Johnson

Baltimore = Joe Flacco as best and Elvis Grbac as worst

Buffalo = Jim Kelly best and Alex Van Pelt as worst

Carolina = Cam Newton and best and Jimmy Clausen as worst

Chicago = Best Sid Luckman and worst Bob Avellini

Bengals = Ken Anderson as best and Akili Smith as the worst

Cleveland = Otto Graham the best and Brandon Weeden the worst

Dallas = Roger Staubach best and Chad Huchison as worst

Denver = John Elway the best and Steve Tensi the worst

Lions = Best Bobby Lane and worst is Joey Harrington

Green Bay = best Favre and worst Randy Wright

Houston = best Matt Schaub and worst Dave Carr

Colts = best Manning and worst Curtis Painter

Jags = best Brunnell and worst Blaine Gabbert

KC = best Len Dawson and worst Todd Blackledge

Chargers = best Dan Fouts and worst Ryan Leaf

Rams - Best Jurt Warner and worst Dan Pastorini

Miami = best Marino and worst Rick Norton

Vikings = best Tarkenton and worst Spergon Wynn

Patriots = best Brady and worst Mike Taliaferro

Saints = best Breese and worst Heath Shuler

Giants = best ELi Manning and worst Dave Brown

Jets = Best Namath and worst Browning Nagle

Raiders = best Stabler and worst Jamarcuss Russel

Eagles = best McNabb and worst Bobby Hoying

Steelers = best Bradshaw and worst Mark Malone

San Fran = best Montana and worst Steve Spurier

Seahawks = best R Wilson and worst Stan Gelbaugh

Tampa = best Brad JOhnson and worst old Vinny Testaverde

Titans = best Waren Moon and worst Billy Joe Tolliver

Redskins = best Sammy Baugh and worst Ralph Guglielmi

Stan Gelbaugh did make the list! That's classic!