Every NFL Team’s Best & Worst Quarterback of All-Time

[broncosmitty]

Kinda feel bad for Weeden.


Tough spot as a 36 year old rookie.

 

[TP76]

Pats Worst: Matt Cavenaugh or Hugh Millen - take your pick.

 

[Robotech]

What criteria are we using for the worst QB? Has to be a minimum number of starts, IMO.

 

[Schmoopy1000]

What criteria are we using for the worst QB? Has to be a minimum number of starts, IMO.

I agree.
That is why Eddie Lebaron is unquestionably the worst for the Cowboys. hutch played what? a half a season?

 

[boogiewithstu2007]

Best .... Wilson
Worst ... Legendary Dan McGwire..

 

[NinerSickness]

Maybe not statistically, but GOAT for Niners & Jags:

 

[Pattersonca65]

well could add joe kapp 17 picks in 10 games

Always remember him in the Longest Yard

 

[pachyderm]

View attachment 221572

Lol.
That's not Stafford though...

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

Seahawks best is easy and obvious with RW but worst is a toss-up. I can't really include all the guys that played a game here or there like Senaca Wallace and the Charlie's. Probably Stan Gelbaugh in 92. That was atrocious. But for full time starters, likely Rick Mirer. Dude was a great passer to the other team, lol. HM to Trent Dilfer.

 

[gob]

Bengals makes sense. Wasn't sure if they'd go Anderson or Boomer (even though Dalton probably has them both statistically, but let's be real). Dark horse, and personal "favorite"(helped lead the Bengals out of the despair of the 90's) is Jeff Blake. Worst is a toss up too....between a bunch of applicants.

 

[Manster7588]

Bengals makes sense. Wasn't sure if they'd go Anderson or Boomer (even though Dalton probably has them both statistically, but let's be real). Dark horse, and personal "favorite"(helped lead the Bengals out of the despair of the 90's) is Jeff Blake. Worst is a toss up too....between a bunch of applicants.

I think there is a Mrs. on here who might put you on a hit list.

 

[cowboycolors]

Cowboys Roger was the best
And Quincy was the worst
Had to play at least 1 full season

 

[dkmightyhammer]

Seahawks best is easy and obvious with RW but worst is a toss-up. I can't really include all the guys that played a game here or there like Senaca Wallace and the Charlie's. Probably Stan Gelbaugh in 92. That was atrocious. But for full time starters, likely Rick Mirer. Dude was a great passer to the other team, lol. HM to Trent Dilfer.

Trent Dilfer wasn't as bad as everyone says. That notion just kind of took on a life of it's own and became something that people agree with sort of same way that so many people say that Nickelback sucks without really knowing why they think that way. Honestly, Dilfer wasn't a world beater as a QB but he wasn't anywhere near the worst either. He wouldn't be the guy to put the team on his back and win the game for you, but he was a decent enough game manager that if you put a really good team around him he wouldn't lose you the game either.

 

[mrschaney]

Greatest: Ken Anderson/and Andy Dalton tied for best.
Worst avid Klinger

 

[Superbelt]

Steelers:

Best:
The Original TB 12

Worst:
O'Donnell, who actively lost a Superbowl. I could say Malone, he sucked, or any number of other guys who suited up in the early suck or 80's dark years. But O'Donnell is actively hated for making a SB MVP of Larry Brown.


A guy named Dick Shiner used to play QB for the Steelers.

 

[mrschaney]

Steelers:

Best:
The Original TB 12

Worst:
O'Donnell, who actively lost a Superbowl. I could say Malone, he sucked, or any number of other guys who suited up in the early suck or 80's dark years. But O'Donnell is actively hated for making a SB MVP of Larry Brown.

O'Donnell can be added as one of the Bengals worst as well.

 

[ATL96Steeler]

Steelers:

Best:
The Original TB 12

Worst:
O'Donnell, who actively lost a Superbowl. I could say Malone, he sucked, or any number of other guys who suited up in the early suck or 80's dark years. But O'Donnell is actively hated for making a SB MVP of Larry Brown.


A guy named Dick Shiner used to play QB for the Steelers.

Different era, but I'm going Ben over Terry for the best....Bradshaw was clearly just along for the ride for 1st two SBs...have to give him credit for winning the last two of the 70s era.

Worst...Malone and David Woodley tie for me...Woodley won more games but his performance was about as bad as Malone's.

O'Donnell is known for blowing that SB vs DAL, but comparatively speaking, he was better than either Malone or Woodley.

Shiner I don't remember, but '72 was my 1st yr of fandom.

 

[Superbelt]

Different era, but I'm going Ben over Terry for the best....Bradshaw was clearly just along for the ride for 1st two SBs...have to give him credit for winning the last two of the 70s era.

Worst...Malone and David Woodley tie for me...Woodley won more games but his performance was about as bad as Malone's.

O'Donnell is known for blowing that SB vs DAL, but comparatively speaking, he was better than either Malone or Woodley.

Shiner I don't remember, but '72 was my 1st yr of fandom.

Before my time too. Shiner was the guy who Bradshaw replaced.

If we wanted to go absolute worst, we could do worse than Malone and Woodley, too. Laundry Jones.
But there is a special burning hatred for someone who threw interceptions directly at Larry Brown in the Superbowl.

 

[Yankee Traveler]

pats
best= brady
worst=plunkett

EASON!!!

 

[Yankee Traveler]

No love for Steve Young?

I'll give you 4-1 odds it's a no.