Every NFL Team’s Best & Worst Quarterback of All-Time

[Anointed One]

wrong thread

 

[Myles]

Indianapolis Colts
Best - Manning
Worst - Tough one. Mike Pagel or Jeff George

 

[Schmoopy1000]

Indianapolis Colts
Best - Manning
Worst - Tough one. Mike Pagel or Jeff George

I would have thought Art Schlichter, who lost his job to Mike Pagel.

 

[Vegas]

Joe Kapp?

Joe Kapp at his very best.

 

[Vegas]

And I have to say that Bart Starr is still the best Packer QB ever. His 9-1 playoff record and highest ever playoff passer rating sets him above everyone. Considering he played his entire career before the passing rule changes of 1978 and to still have the best rating is really impressive.

 

[Vegas]

For the Eagles I like Randall Cunningham. But to make all you haters happy, I will add that Wentz "Almost" made it. For worst I'm going with a guy named Mike Boryla, who probably no one has heard of.

I remember Boryla well.

 

[Nosferatu]

Joe Kapp?

Another middle of the road guy, but I will give him some credit for always giving it all he had.

 

[GNG]

Another middle of the road guy, but I will give him some credit for always giving it all he had.

 

[CruiseControl]

Joe Kapp?

you think kap is the worst qb the niners ever had? won an nfc championship game, 4-2 playoff record?

that is ridiculous.

Jim Druckenmiller?
Elvis Grbac?
J.T OSullivan?
Blaine Gabbert?

 

[Myles]

I would have thought Art Schlichter, who lost his job to Mike Pagel.

I thought about that. He only played 6 games over 2 seasons though. Wasn't sure that should fit the parameters.

 

[GNG]

Another middle of the road guy, but I will give him some credit for always giving it all he had.

 

[GNG]

you think kap is the worst qb the niners ever had? won an nfc championship game, 4-2 playoff record?

that is ridiculous.

Jim Druckenmiller?
Elvis Grbac?
J.T OSullivan?
Blaine Gabbert?

Kapp played for the Vikings you idiot.

 

[Schmoopy1000]

I thought about that. He only played 6 games over 2 seasons though. Wasn't sure that should fit the parameters.

didnt realize that. Just knew he was a high draft pick on your team for 3 or 4 years LOL

 

[CruiseControl]

Kapp played for the Vikings you idiot.

lol... i thought you meant joe/kapp as in montana/kaepernick.

 

[Myles]

didnt realize that. Just knew he was a high draft pick on your team for 3 or 4 years LOL

Baltimore drafted him 4th in the 1st round. If the question was "bust" he would be in the conversation. I think he is still in jail.

 

[Cedrique]

I remember Boryla well.

So was that a fair assessment? The truth is I was a little kid when Boryla was playing so he could have been a young QB stuck on a bad team. Those mid 70's Eagles teams didn't really have many weapons (mostly just Harold Carmichael). Then after Boryla was gone they got Wilbert Montgomery and they didn't really need many weapons because he could do it all.

 

[Robotech]

Indianapolis Colts
Best - Manning
Worst - Tough one. Mike Pagel or Jeff George

Jack Trudeau really wasn't very good, and he started a significant number of games, IMO.

 

[Robotech]

Indianapolis Colts
Best - Manning
Worst - Tough one. Mike Pagel or Jeff George

And I'll go with Unitas as best.

 

[Robotech]

Bengals makes sense. Wasn't sure if they'd go Anderson or Boomer (even though Dalton probably has them both statistically, but let's be real). Dark horse, and personal "favorite"(helped lead the Bengals out of the despair of the 90's) is Jeff Blake. Worst is a toss up too....between a bunch of applicants.

Comparing Dalton's stats to those of Boomer and Anderson doesn't mean much. The latter two had very good stats for their day, especially Anderson.

 

[Robotech]

Greatest: Ken Anderson/and Andy Dalton tied for best.
Worst avid Klinger

Not sure if you are being serious about Dalton.