POLL Eli Manning vs. Ben Roethlisberger vs. Philip Rivers

[navamind]

Rivers
Ben
Eli

Rivers and Ben are very comparable in terms of TD% / Y/A / INT% / COMP%, but he was also a lot more durable. Ben has 2 rings, but I don't think his postseason stats are any more impressive than Philip's.

 

[Pastafazul]

Neither one would have lasted a week in the NFL , if Jack Lampert was on the other side of them ...

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

For the longest time I was an Eli over Ben guy. However, over these last several years Ben has really pulled away from Eli.

Rivers is and always has been a distant third.

This

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Eli gets "hate" because a lot of people like to pump him up as great, but he isn't. He wasn't just inaccurate and turnover prone late in his career.

Eli gets “hate” caused he wiped his ass with the QB 85% of this board worships as a God

 

[gob]

Eli gets “hate” caused he wiped his ass with the QB 85% of this board worships as a God

Bro, he's not a great QB.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Bro, he's not a great QB.

Oh I agree, and in this poll it’s Ben by far

I just have Eli well ahead of RIvers

Rivers overall prob played on the best rosters of the 3 of them, and is the 1 without even a SB appearance

 

[wings-pens2166]

Oh I agree, and in this poll it’s Ben by far

I just have Eli well ahead of RIvers

Rivers overall prob played on the best rosters of the 3 of them, and is the 1 without even a SB appearance

yeah, I simply don't get the love some have for Rivers. That guy was the epitome of stat compiler....play like total ass for 3 quarters until your team is down big, then put up some useless stats late when the other team is playing prevent and get people to say, "hey, you can't blame Rivers. look at the numbers he put up."

 

[Ojb81]

Rapist
Crybaby
Huckleberry Hound

Fixed it for ya

 

[Pure Steel]

Rivers
Ben
Eli

Rivers and Ben are very comparable in terms of TD% / Y/A / INT% / COMP%, but he was also a lot more durable. Ben has 2 rings, but I don't think his postseason stats are any more impressive than Philip's.

Ben’s three road wins in 2005 are a big reason they made it to the SB.....Then had a bad SB and that’s all that is brought up.....he was also only 23....