Really? I just don't see it. Brees was one of those players whose players who people doubted becuase of his limited physical abilities, but his play on the field and fundamentals were great.
First of all, literally everybody I've heard (outside this forum) says that Barkley is a shoe-in for the #1 pick overall. Other than myself, I don't know anyone who has been consistently critical of him.
I have never understood the hype on him. I have been saying that for years. So that makes two of us.