So let's say Wisconsin wins the Big 10 Championship

[TheRobotDevil]

I agree!

Did you notice in my 6 Playoff team seeding scenario that Ohio State would play Penn State?

I mean, what better way to say once and for all who deserves to play for a possible National Championship but to line 'em up on the field once more?

Yes I liked that seeding. It would determine that the PSU win wasn't a fluke. Apparently blocked field goals returned for TD's.Are not part of college football now either They really need to revise the system if this is the result. The past two years may have worked because the play off teams were all conference champions. But putting any team in over a team that beat them head to head and won the same division they play in. Thats a really weak argument.And a bad judgement call

 

[Gopherfan84]

You obviously haven't been reading this thread GD.

tOSU is a lock! A LOCK!

So was Hillary. Just saying.

 

[Shanemansj13]

The only thing that would accomplish.Is taking away the possibility of Ohio State failing to win their divisions again. If anything this year is a prime example of the need for play off expansion. That moves the politics .And provides a solution that ensures the "best" teams are in. The only teams that wouldnt want this are afraid of the added competition imo

You should listen to how Herbie described how the committee views the teams when it comes down to it H2H, non-conference, Winning your conference, etc. isnt what it comes down too. Like I have been saying it is everything and mainly key wins and you cant have bad bad losses.

It has nothing to do with politics or prestige it depends on your resume, that's why Michigan and UW are very close at 4 and 5. You obviously are just confused and havent been watching for the last 3 years now lol.

Now, the easiest solution is to get rid of the divisions in conferences. They dont need to expand to 4 or 8 or definitely anymore than that.

 

[TheRobotDevil]

You should listen to how Herbie described how the committee views the teams when it comes down to it H2H, non-conference, Winning your conference, etc. isnt what it comes down too. Like I have been saying it is everything and mainly key wins and you cant have bad bad losses.

It has nothing to do with politics or prestige it depends on your resume, that's why Michigan and UW are very close at 4 and 5. You obviously are just confused and havent been watching for the last 3 years now lol.

Now, the easiest solution is to get rid of the divisions in conferences. They dont need to expand to 4 or 8 or definitely anymore than that.

I stopped reading at listen to Herbstreit and spit coffee laughing

 

[Shanemansj13]

I dont know why people want more teams in it takes away looking at the best resumes and the best teams. If they went to 6, two or three teams would still be bitching (btw he havent much bitching yet honestly bc the format works). Keep it at four or shit will get out of hand. No reason for anymore than four at least for the next couple years.

 

[Shanemansj13]

I stopped reading at listen to Herbstreit and spit coffee laughing

Well as much as you want to say he is bias he tells it how it is just like the committee.

It's ok you have embarrassed yourself enough in this thread saying Penn St will get in if they win You sure probably pay attention more instead of blurting out bs for future reference

 

[TheRobotDevil]

I dont know why people want more teams in it takes away looking at the best resumes and the best teams. If they went to 6, two or three teams would still be bitching (btw he havent much bitching yet honestly bc the format works). Keep it at four or shit will get out of hand. No reason for anymore than four at least for the next couple years.

I really hope you aren't serious listen to Herbstreit? That is hysterical. Its ok you can make excuses and pretend Ohio State is the "better" team based on a judgement call rather than facts. And I don't blame you for fearing play off expansion.It wouldn't be beneficial to OSU.To have to compete

 

[TheRobotDevil]

Well as much as you want to say he is bias he tells it how it is just like the committee.

It's ok you have embarrassed yourself enough in this thread saying Penn St will get in if they win You sure probably pay attention more instead of blurting out bs for future reference

Yes lets pretend Penn State didnt beat Ohio State and go by ESPN and Herbstreit. Thats definitely fact. Why are you afraid of an expanded play off?

 

[Shanemansj13]

I really hope you aren't serious listen to Herbstreit? That is hysterical. Its ok you can make excuses and pretend Ohio State is the "better" team based on a judgement call rather than facts. And I don't blame you for fearing play off expansion.It wouldn't be beneficial to OSU.To have to compete

So the committe isnt going off facts lol. Just admit it you were way off base. It's ok people are wrong sometimes and this time you were WAAAAAY off

 

[Shanemansj13]

Yes lets pretend Penn State didnt beat Ohio State and go by ESPN and Herbstreit. Thats definitely fact. Why are you afraid of an expanded play off?

Afraid? I think you are awarding teams teams to get in that normally wouldnt. 4 is perfect and we have had zero problems so far. I think everyone can agree with that

 

[TheRobotDevil]

So the committe isnt going off facts lol. Just admit it you were way off base. It's ok people are wrong sometimes and this time you were WAAAAAY off

Based on your scenario its a judgement call.Which is not based on facts. The fact is Ohio State lost to Penn State and failed to win their division. That is black and white. All you're doing is sounding a lot like the Michigan coach you all complain about

 

[TheRobotDevil]

Afraid? I think you are awarding teams teams to get in that normally wouldnt. 4 is perfect and we have had zero problems so far. I think everyone can agree with that

So far all 4 teams have won their conferences. Awarding teams who failed to win their conference.And lost to a team head to head. Because you FEEL they are the best team ................ Are you done Harbaugh shall we make more excuses for losing the PSU game?

 

[TheRobotDevil]

So far all 4 teams have won their conferences. Awarding teams who failed to win their conference.And lost to a team head to head. Because you FEEL they are the best team ................ Are you done Harbaugh shall we make more excuses for losing the PSU game?

I'll save some time and make the excuses for you.

But that game was a fluke they blocked a field goal

But we are better than the team that beat us

But we don't need divisions Notre Dame doesn't

But conference championships only mean they're the best team in our conference

But we don't need play off expansion competition is scary

But Herbstreit told me Penn State is the Debil........

 

[Vitamike]

I'll save some time and make the excuses for you.

But that game was a fluke they blocked a field goal

But we are better than the team that beat us

But we don't need divisions Notre Dame doesn't

But conference championships only mean they're the best team in our conference

But we don't need play off expansion competition is scary

But Herbstreit told me Penn State is the Debil........

You forgot a couple...

It was a night game....

They had a bye the week before....

 

[Vitamike]

Afraid? I think you are awarding teams teams to get in that normally wouldnt. 4 is perfect and we have had zero problems so far. I think everyone can agree with that

2015 Houston & 2014 TCU says Hi!

 

[TheRobotDevil]

You forgot a couple...

It was a night game....

They had a bye the week before....

You're right I forgot No bright lights,Don't get Herbstreit wet and never feed Urban Meyer after midnight

 

[LoftonPack80]

I really hope you aren't serious listen to Herbstreit? That is hysterical. Its ok you can make excuses and pretend Ohio State is the "better" team based on a judgement call rather than facts. And I don't blame you for fearing play off expansion.It wouldn't be beneficial to OSU.To have to compete

So is the committee chairman saying last night when the committee compares OSU and Penn State it's "not even close" is that good enough?

Big Ten champ ain't getting in without Washington and Clemson losing and that's that

 

[Shanemansj13]

I'll save some time and make the excuses for you.

But that game was a fluke they blocked a field goal

But we are better than the team that beat us

But we don't need divisions Notre Dame doesn't

But conference championships only mean they're the best team in our conference

But we don't need play off expansion competition is scary

But Herbstreit told me Penn State is the Debil........

The game wasn't a fluke but you cant sit here and tell me Ohio St doesn't have the better resume lol. You are lying to yourself.

 

[Shanemansj13]

2015 Houston & 2014 TCU says Hi!

Sorry but didn't Baylor end up 5th. Houston Nice one.

 

[Shanemansj13]

I'll save some time and make the excuses for you.

But that game was a fluke they blocked a field goal

But we are better than the team that beat us

But we don't need divisions Notre Dame doesn't

But conference championships only mean they're the best team in our conference

But we don't need play off expansion competition is scary

But Herbstreit told me Penn State is the Debil........

You obviously continue to not listen to the committee lol

Go ahead and ignore the facts it isn't helping your case

Based on your scenario its a judgement call.Which is not based on facts. The fact is Ohio State lost to Penn State and failed to win their division. That is black and white. All you're doing is sounding a lot like the Michigan coach you all complain about

I never once complained. I have been saying to you how the committee will view based on how they have viewed previous situations and I was right, you were wrong. Accept it dude. It doesn't matter to me either way, it just doesn't look good on you.