Bosh or Love?

[lebron23james]

It is a video game ranking.

Does not mean a damn thing.

They get a group of unbiased NBA experts and old NBA coaches to come up with it. What is your expertise to challenge it? Womans little league basketball coach?

 

[SJ76]

They get a group of unbiased NBA experts and old NBA coaches to come up with it. What is your expertise to challenge it? Womans little league basketball coach?

What experts and what coaches?


You’re unbiased poll starts on page 1 of this thread

 

[lebron23james]

What experts and what coaches?


You’re unbiased poll starts on page 1 of this thread

This Is How NBA 2K Determines Player Rankings

"But the process of rating these players is not some backstage popularity contest, where the developers assign final ratings based on their gut instinct. It is a scientific process intended to eliminate as much bias as possible."

And no the poll in this thread was a joke. The fact that it was so dramatic kinda proves that it is not accurate and bias when comparing 2 very similar players. Hold the L

 

[SJ76]

This Is How NBA 2K Determines Player Rankings

"But the process of rating these players is not some backstage popularity contest, where the developers assign final ratings based on their gut instinct. It is a scientific process intended to eliminate as much bias as possible."

And no the poll in this thread was a joke. The fact that it was so dramatic kinda proves that it is not accurate and bias when comparing 2 very similar players. Hold the L

So who are the coaches and experts? I’m wondering if it’s the Mel Kiper type experts and wondering who the coaches are.


Dramatic polls

 

[lebron23james]

So who are the coaches and experts? I’m wondering if it’s the Mel Kiper type experts and wondering who the coaches are.


Dramatic polls

They have a few that work for the company and help in the rating process as well as consultants. Have you ever read about 2k the highest selling NBA game? It's not just some random slapped together game lol

In fact a lot of people from 2k have been hired by the NBA to help their teams...

Explain how they were so wrong but this poll is so right? Based on what? The morons on this site?

 

[dtgold88]

That pretty much settles. Let's see how the haters spin this unbiased ranking.

They'll say it doesn't matter.....though they didn't point this out when it was noted whiteside had a better ranking than TT.

 

[dtgold88]

It is a video game ranking.

Does not mean a damn thing.

don't really disagree agree.....though means as much or more than random fans' opinions.

 

[Black Adam]

"but-but-but the video game numbers. y'all just hating on the Cavs. even you guys that post on the NBA boards that regularly"...

 

[SJ76]

They have a few that work for the company and help in the rating process as well as consultants. Have you ever read about 2k the highest selling NBA game? It's not just some random slapped together game lol

In fact a lot of people from 2k have been hired by the NBA to help their teams...

Explain how they were so wrong but this poll is so right? Based on what? The morons on this site?

^^

This is one of the problems of the nba fan today. Thinks the game of basketball can be compared to a video game.

 

[lebron23james]

"but-but-but the video game numbers. y'all just hating on the Cavs. even you guys that post on the NBA boards that regularly"...

It is true tho, same way we will be hating on your lakers, and would appropriately fill out a poll that way

That is why it can't be taken seriously, just like this poll...

 

[Black Adam]

It is true tho, same way we will be hating on your lakers, and would appropriately fill out a poll that way

That is why it can't be taken seriously, just like this poll...

I just find it a little funny that y'all are trying so hard to change people's minds...

 

[lebron23james]

don't really disagree agree.....though means as much or more than random fans' opinions.

Paid professionals who's opinions matter and NBA players respect and wait desperately for>>>Random fan opinion who nobody knows on a random message board lol

 

[lebron23james]

I just find it a little funny that y'all are trying so hard to change people's minds...

I am just here to spread the truth lol

 

[Black Adam]

I am just here to spread the truth lol

that 24>10...?

 

[SJ76]

I am just here to spread the truth lol

I can see where you are coming from but basing a players “rating” on so many variables is pretty stupid.

If you weigh all those individual rankings all the same you are saying each player is based off a robot.

Truth is a players strength or IQ or shooting or quickness/speed are a lot more important than some of the other rankings. Love dribbling > Bosh dribbling

But even if you wanted to act like those rankings were set in stone and all correct, It’s still closer than shit so this whole entire thread really is silly.

The defending of your stance on Love is silly. Both players are dam close to each other so lets move on to another silly thread.

 

[dtgold88]

"but-but-but the video game numbers. y'all just hating on the Cavs. even you guys that post on the NBA boards that regularly"...

you do realize these numbers in the game are based on their real numbers?

 

[dtgold88]

^^

This is one of the problems of the nba fan today. Thinks the game of basketball can be compared to a video game.

The video game is based on their actual performance and numbers.

 

[dtgold88]

I just find it a little funny that y'all are trying so hard to change people's minds...

Hope I'm not part of the "y'all" as I said it's very close and could understand if someone picks Bosh...I expected more would here.

 

[SJ76]

The video game is based on their actual performance and numbers.

How? Do you have any calculations?

Is the dribbling attribute really that big for guys like Bosh and Love?

Lmao this is hilarious that anyone would even think these evaluations make another player better. At least now we know who the video game gurus are.

And I love video games btw just no time to play.

 

[SJ76]

“These are people who are paid to rate the players. “


—but we don’t know how they do it or who they are.




I would love to know how they rate players. I used to love making my own player on madden. Hell let’s look at how many recent NFL players are satisfied with their own Madden rankings.

Too many grey areas to take a video game’s rating as fact.