- Thread starter
- #1
Mistaken4193
REGISTERED GUMP!!!
I say yes. Best defensive CF Ive ever seen. Should have won the MVP in 05(He carried that team to the playoffs)
I say yes. Best defensive CF Ive ever seen. Should have won the MVP in 05(He carried that team to the playoffs)
Good player .... Absolutely. Hall of Famer ... No.
Since a defensive "Wizard" like Ozzie Smith is in the HOF, no question AJ should get in too. His amazing D was a huge contributing factor to Glavine, Maddux and Smoltz making the Hall.
My criteria for the HOF of any sport, is if I have to think about it, it's a no.
Jones belongs in the Hall of very good, he was probably 2 more great seasons away from the Hall, but he regressed early in age.
There's plenty of worse players than Andruw in the Hall.
And better ones that aren't.There's plenty of worse players than Andruw in the Hall.
And better ones that aren't.
Egh.None better defensively.
Egh.
Nobody knows that.
Defensive stats for anyone pre80's are mostly conjecture.
I'm not knocking his defense.I won't pretend to understand the advanced defensive stats. I do trust my eyes though, and that sumbitch could cover the entire outfield by himself(pretty well had to for the couple of seasons when Chipper was in left field and Gary Sheffield was in right, still blame those couple of seasons Chipper spent in LF for those leg problems that plagued him for years afterwards. Fuck Vinny Castilla)
And better ones that aren't.