Wentz or Mayfield: who would you rather have?

[ericd7633]

regardless, you're reaching, have your moment

It's not reaching when I say Baker was shit this season. It's not reaching to suggest part of that culture problem is Baker.

If the roles were reversed this thread would have bumped 2 months ago.

 

[SteelersPride]

It's not reaching when I say Baker was shit this season. It's not reaching to suggest part of that culture problem is Baker.

If the roles were reversed this thread would have bumped 2 months ago.

yep, and it took 4 years to get here, so lets see in 2 more for baker, you still may be right.......but.. a bit hard to compare

 

[droider]

Shit, I may actually have to go with Wince here

 

[ericd7633]

yep, and it took 4 years to get here, so lets see in 2 more for baker, you still may be right.......but.. a bit hard to compare

I guess not for everyone who took Baker before this season?

 

[SteelersPride]

I guess not for everyone who took Baker before this season?

again, 1 season does not equal a career.

 

[ericd7633]

again, 1 season does not equal a career.

No shit. Lol.

 

[megalodon30]

Wentz - 17
Mayfield - 53

I feel proud that I'm one of the few that picked the playoff QB over the scrub that lost to the Broncos.

 

[megalodon30]

I'd take Wentz over Mayfield. Mayfield over a tackling dummy. And a tackling dummy over Flacco.

Flacco hadn't played a down for Denver, yet I nailed it. What a bum.

 

[PickleRick]

Suicide by bleach ingestion.

 

[dtgold88]

Not quitting on Mayfield, tbh.

No doubt...Guy was one of the best rookie QBs we've seen in Haley's offense (and no Haley). Failed in Freddie's.

Just as likely in a better offense more suited to him he's the guy we saw as a rookie.

 

[dtgold88]

I think he will be fine. But the team needs to commit hard in the off-season and like... Practice and stuff. I hear it helps

If he stays will help if Dorsey starts thinking like a GM and not a fan. Don't just go for splash moves and name players. Locker room fit and maturity matters.

 

[dtgold88]

yep, and wentz has played 4 seasons now. baker 2. wentz also was drafted to a team in much better shape than the browns........

Guessing he also plays for a team that designed an offense to try to take advantage of his strengths.

 

[dtgold88]

Yeah throwing to 2 probowl WR's, and having 2 probowl RB's is an awful situation to be in.

It is when the coach/OC has no clue how to use them.

Second time he's limited the PB RB's carries against the worst run D in the league.

At least he didn't use a shovel pass.

 

[dtgold88]

Yeah if only Baker could do something to help culture...hmm...

This is definitely a fair comment. The guy needs to grow up. Last 2 pressers was thinking he took a step. Have to say he played his heart out yesterday. But to get into it with fans is absurd. do what most do and ignore them.

 

[dtgold88]

regardless, you're reaching, have your moment

Nah...I think that was a fair comment. Baker needs to focus on how he can get better. No need to be such a douche.

 

[DJ]

Wentz.

 

[Wamu]

Wentz - 17
Mayfield - 53

I feel proud that I'm one of the few that picked the playoff QB over the scrub that lost to the Broncos.

You picked the playoff QB? No you didn't. Wentz has never played in or won a playoff game. In '17 & '18 Nick Foles was Philly's starting QB during the post season.

 

[ericd7633]

It is when the coach/OC has no clue how to use them.

Second time he's limited the PB RB's carries against the worst run D in the league.

At least he didn't use a shovel pass.

This is a fair assessment. Although I do think his accuracy took a step back this season for whatever reason.

 

[dtgold88]

This is a fair assessment. Although I do think his accuracy took a step back this season for whatever reason.

No argument from me. Too many are harsh critics of Baker or fanboys. Not enough willing to see both sides.

He bares some blame and may, in fact, be closer to what we saw this year. we'll know after next season.

 

[megalodon30]

You picked the playoff QB? No you didn't. Wentz has never played in or won a playoff game. In '17 & '18 Nick Foles was Philly's starting QB during the post season.

Wentz is in the playoffs this year and Mayfield missed them. Wentz is the playoff QB and Mayfield is not. Pretty simple concept to understand.