SF backfield or AJ Green?

[TREFF]

assume a dynasty setting, regardless of the rest of the roster, would you prefer McKinnon and Brieda, or AJ Green?

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Curious to see what folks think about this. I traded Linsay for Green late last season. Course I was RB heavy and weak at WR.

 

[Sam Sportboy]

assume a dynasty setting, regardless of the rest of the roster, would you prefer McKinnon and Brieda, or AJ Green?

My first thought was SF backfield............then I thought what if by some huge ass miracle all parties stay healthy.........I'm taking the Green side cuz Brieda and McKinnon would probably split carries and when Green is healthy he is without a doubt the man.............

 

[Sam Sportboy]

Curious to see what folks think about this. I traded Linsay for Green late last season. Course I was RB heavy and weak at WR.

I think you got a steal there.........

 

[Bandit]

Right now I say Green because his situation isn't going to change. There's way too much talk about San Francisco and how they could end up with Bell, so I wouldn't take a chance on Breida and McKinnon until you know for sure that San Francisco is out of the Bell sweepstakes, but by then it will probably be too late.

 

[TREFF]

any concerns about AJ Green ending up on IR the previous 2 years and soon to be 31?

 

[Sam Sportboy]

any concerns about AJ Green ending up on IR the previous 2 years and soon to be 31?

I honestly think all 3 players have legit injury concerns and that's why I flipped after giving it a minute of thought.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

any concerns about AJ Green ending up on IR the previous 2 years and soon to be 31?

Yes it’s a concern. Green is for rosters ready to win now. While healthy he’s a stud still.

 

[TREFF]

I honestly think all 3 players have legit injury concerns and that's why I flipped after giving it a minute of thought.

No doubts..but my point of view if all players land in that category is...what's easier replace in the lineup, a RB or a WR?

I'm torn

 

[huskers1217]

Right now I say Green because his situation isn't going to change. There's way too much talk about San Francisco and how they could end up with Bell, so I wouldn't take a chance on Breida and McKinnon until you know for sure that San Francisco is out of the Bell sweepstakes, but by then it will probably be too late.

yes..but does he get bell if bell goes there

 

[huskers1217]

No doubts..but my point of view if all players land in that category is...what's easier replace in the lineup, a RB or a WR?

I'm torn

When you say SF Running backs. is it a collective score or are you using 2 roster spots. collectively, I'm going SF RB's - it also begs the question i asked before.

 

[TREFF]

no it's the 2 players, I just put the "sf backfield" for S's & G's

 

[SteelersPride]

I’m going backfield they paid McKinnon if he’s healthy he’s getting fed

If not Breida is now healthy I’ll roll the dice

They never let breida heal last year

 

[TREFF]

the team QB or team RB leagues are communist IMHO

 

[tlance]

Green is getting up there. How many years of elite production does he have left?

The answer might be 0.

I take the SF backfield here because I think both players have enough upside + youth that you should get more longtime use out of a harder to replace position.

 

[averagejoe]

I think Bandit has the best argument.

I'll also add that Shanahan was OC in Atlanta and Tevin Coleman is a free agent. Could SF be a possible landing spot? Ya never know.

Gimme Green.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

I think Bandit has the best argument.

I'll also add that Shanahan was OC in Atlanta and Tevin Coleman is a free agent. Could SF be a possible landing spot? Ya never know.

Gimme Green.

Didn’t think about Coleman. Could happen.

 

[tlance]

I think Bandit has the best argument.

I'll also add that Shanahan was OC in Atlanta and Tevin Coleman is a free agent. Could SF be a possible landing spot? Ya never know.

Gimme Green.

Yeah. I don't buy it.

SF invested way too much money in McKinnon to go out and pay another FA RB before he even takes his first snap.

 

[SteelersPride]

i dont see them paying for a back, they invested in mckinnon. Also arent gonna sign bell for the same reason

 

[TREFF]

Yea, I'm more in the Tlance/SP camp on that area. I could see a depth type signing or drafting of a RB..but between those two, Wilson and Mostert, there's no reason to add a luxury like Bell, especially given what they're already on the hook for with McKinnon and Jimmy G. That kind of money could and should, be better invested elsewhere.
I think those rumors have no more legs under them than the Bell going to Denver whispers do.