Mike Pettine: Russell Wilson is not a top tier QB

[flyerhawk]

I saw the game. There were some big gains after very short passes. Nothing wrong with that, but it wasn't exactly Peyton in his prime out there.

Yeah that was quite a dink and dunk pass to Tyler Locket for 36 on 3rd and 11.

 

[Smart]

Well, we know which games count for Seattle fans. There are 10 of them. You'd never know the other 6 happened.

Wilson's QB Rating was 88.4 or higher in five of those six losses.

Carson Palmer's career QB Rating is 88.3.

 

[Smart]

I was only talking regular season. If you include playoff passing they have the same number of TDs. Wilson has played in 8 playoff games. Luck has played in 6.

OTOH, Russell Wilson has 70 picks and fumbles. Luck has 87 picks and fumbles.

About 15 of Russell's "fumbles" are snaps which were way over his head or off to one side. Those numbers should only be interceptions and fumbles lost.

 

[DunceKaep]

Right NOW, and for years to come.
I will take RW in the playoffs, you can have your regular season mvp candidate (he won't win, Newton will) and ZERO playoff wins, Carson Palmer.

 

[johnson]

Wilson's QB Rating was 88.4 or higher in five of those six losses.

Carson Palmer's career QB Rating is 88.3.

Good thing for us AZ fans we only care about what he is doing this year. Not that how he did on the Bengals 8 years ago isn't interesting. He's had a career year this year.

 

[johnson]

Right NOW, and for years to come.
I will take RW in the playoffs, you can have your regular season mvp candidate (he won't win, Newton will) and ZERO playoff wins, Carson Palmer.

You'd take RW going forward for years to come? I sure hope so. There's a rather substantial age difference between the two. Can't see Palmer slinging it in 2020.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Well, we know which games count for Seattle fans. There are 10 of them. You'd never know the other 6 happened.

How much do you charge Seahawks fans for rent?

 

[johnson]

Yeah that was quite a dink and dunk pass to Tyler Locket for 36 on 3rd and 11.

Yeah, there was that...and then there were the other 18 completions that were dinkers and dunkers. Very nice dinkers and dunkers...don't get me wrong.

 

[johnson]

How much do you charge Seahawks fans for rent?

I wouldn't rent to them, but if they can't think of anything original, I might let them borrow something (like the "12th man")

 

[HaroldSeattle]

I wouldn't rent to them, but if they can't think of anything original, I might let them borrow something (like the "12th man")

You let them use that space in your head for free? Mighty kind of you.

 

[DunceKaep]

You'd take RW going forward for years to come? I sure hope so. There's a rather substantial age difference between the two. Can't see Palmer slinging it in 2020.

Well, you Johnson, and bskballer say the same stupid shit, repeatedly, and bskballer would STILL take Brees over Wilson right now and for years to come, so to think you might like Palmer 5 years from now is not a stretch.

And this year, I STILL take RW in the Playoffs, regardless of your career reg season for zero playoff win Palmer.

 

[johnson]

Well, you Johnson, and bskballer say the same stupid shit, repeatedly, and bskballer would STILL take Brees over Wilson right now and for years to come, so to think you might like Palmer 5 years from now is not a stretch.

And this year, I STILL take RW in the Playoffs, regardless of your career reg season for zero playoff win Palmer.

In 5 years, I'd rather have RW than Palmer. Seems a no-brainer.

This year, I'd definitely prefer Palmer. Can we have the SEA run defense though?

 

[BHF]

Yeah, there was that...and then there were the other 18 completions that were dinkers and dunkers. Very nice dinkers and dunkers...don't get me wrong.

I like it when he drops a dink over a Card DB 25 yards down field for a TD, myself.

 

[johnson]

I like it when he drops a dink over a Card DB 25 yards down field for a TD, myself.

I like it when you post something someone already said. I also like when you post something that happened once to argue against what was a fairly obvious generalization.

 

[flyerhawk]

Yeah, there was that...and then there were the other 18 completions that were dinkers and dunkers. Very nice dinkers and dunkers...don't get me wrong.

Yeah that 25 yard TD pass to Kearse was a total dink and dunk play.

Like I said, bravo on coming up with a way to diminish Wilson's performance.

 

[The Oldtimer]

Ironically, it has put up these stats, for the most part, w/out Marshawn Lynch... Lynch has always been the guy people have stated was the main reason for RW's success in the NFL... That excuse is pretty much debunked now...

Who the fuck is Mike Pettine???

 

[flyerhawk]

In 5 years, I'd rather have RW than Palmer. Seems a no-brainer.

This year, I'd definitely prefer Palmer. Can we have the SEA run defense though?

The Seahawks have the No. 3 run defense. The Cards have the No. 4 run defense.

Now you're not even trying.

 

[johnson]

Yeah that 25 yard TD pass to Kearse was a total dink and dunk play.

Like I said, bravo on coming up with a way to diminish Wilson's performance.

I should realize I have to explain everything in excruciating detail to Seattle people.

He dinked and dunked us to death is a generalization. It did not mean to imply EVERY PASS was of this nature, but certainly the great majority of them (like 18/19 or so).

I guess using your logic the Cardinals won because I would like to focus on their 6 points, ignoring the other 36.

 

[flyerhawk]

Who the fuck is Mike Pettine???

Some dude who briefly was a head coach in the NFL before languishing as a position coach for most of his career.

 

[The Oldtimer]

In 5 years, I'd rather have RW than Palmer. Seems a no-brainer.

This year, I'd definitely prefer Palmer. Can we have the SEA run defense though?

Yeah, good point, the Cards did get 27 yards rushing today..