Martellus Bennett ranks Rodgers ahead of Brady

[NWPATSFAN]

Well, when I stated that I could have read your initial response a little closer, I was already admitting that you were right, but thanks for rubbing it in my face.

Well, when I stated that I could have read your initial response a little closer, I was already admitting that you were right, but thanks for rubbing it in my face.

That wasn't my intent to rub your face in it. I was trying to clarify. Enjoy the game tonight have a brat and a for me. Good luck Sunday I have the Pack in all my pools.

 

[sonnyblack65]

Lucky to be drafted by New England rather than, say, the Browns, so he has a coach and team in place that allows him to flourish? Yes, absolutely.

Somewhat true but the Pats were 5-11 and then 0-2 with same team and coach. AR was lucky to sit 3 years behind a legend and also left with a decent team, both lucky I guess

 

[Great Dayne]

Somewhat true but the Pats were 5-11 and then 0-2 with same team and coach. AR was lucky to sit 3 years behind a legend and also left with a decent team, both lucky I guess

Rodgers would thrive with any team, Brady would be a real estate agent if he wasn't drafted by the Cheatriots.

 

[sonnyblack65]

Rodgers would thrive with any team, Brady would be a real estate agent if he wasn't drafted by the Cheatriots.

Yeah ok kid Rodgers has great mobilty but a primadionna headcase. Rodgers D gets 4 turnovers vs Seattle, GB has a 16-0 lead and we know how that played out. Brady is down 10 in the 4th Q to the same team and throws 2 tds to win or down 25 points to ATL,the same team who blow out Rodgers and wins. Your guy isn't mentality tough, he folds too easy like a cheap suit. Best SB QB one was stocking shelves at a supermarket and one would have been selling real estate.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Rodgers would thrive with any team, Brady would be a real estate agent if he wasn't drafted by the Cheatriots.

Now that's some quality speculation right there. You're starting to remind me of the water boy

 

[The Derski]

Rodgers would thrive with any team, Brady would be a real estate agent if he wasn't drafted by the Cheatriots.

I don't 100% agree with this but I don't 100% disagree either.

 

[Great Dayne]

Yeah ok kid Rodgers has great mobilty but a primadionna headcase. Rodgers D gets 4 turnovers vs Seattle, GB has a 16-0 lead and we know how that played out. Brady is down 10 in the 4th Q to the same team and throws 2 tds to win or down 25 points to ATL,the same team who blow out Rodgers and wins. Your guy isn't mentality tough, he folds too easy like a cheap suit. Best SB QB one was stocking shelves at a supermarket and one would have been selling real estate.

Mobility is just one of many reasons why Rodgers is successful.

A headcase is Ryan Leaf. Rodgers doesn't blow up on his teammates like Slim Shady and he doesn't give stupid quotes like Leaf. He handled the entire Favre situation with class and charm. The dude was boo'd by many Packer fans who wanted Favre back yet he handled every interview perfectly. Now, does he date crazy hollywood women?? Sure, that's just thinking with the D and he's still doing it so he hasn't learned his lesson there but he probably doesn't want some gold digger woman like Tiger and Kobe had so I can see the pro's and cons.

Hawks game as been discussed ad nauseam. If the Packers offensive play calling and defensive play calling stay the same as it was in the first half they win 30+ points to 0. MM is notorious for going into conservative mode as does the D coordinator. This is one cherry picked game and I could do the same to Brady but to blame that on Rodgers is asinine. Feel free to watch that game and see how the play calling changed from the first half to the second half. Packers started running right up the middle on three straight plays. The dropped onside kick, sliding on the int (Mcmuffin told him to slide) when Burnett could've walked in for the game clinching TD, calling prevent defense/soft zone coverage when they were going with aggressive blitzes and bump and run all game, etc, etc.

Brady's defense and James white (the real MVP of the game with a record 20 points) were the hero's of that SB game. The D relinquished 0 points during the comeback and White scored nearly all the points. Brady did just enough in the second half to save face after his embarrassing performance in the first half.

Brady is a smart QB but would fail on many other teams. He's benefited greatly from having the best coach/system ever and obviously the cheating which you will take to your grave no matter what comes out.

 

[GNG]

Your guy isn't mentality tough, he folds too easy like a cheap suit.

I never owned a cheap suit so I wouldn't know.

 

[The Derski]

I never owned a cheap suit so I wouldn't know.

Oh SNAP!

 

[Great Dayne]

I don't 100% agree with this but I don't 100% disagree either.

Besides having multiple top ten scoring defenses, the greatest coach of all time and cheating scandals involved in all but one of the SB's Brady's also had an Oline that gives him enough time to have dinner in the pockett.

Put an nonathletic QB with a mediocre team on a team like oh say the Seahakwks and that guy wouldn't be in the league. This would be either due to injury or lack of production. Hawks have a terrible play caller with no O-line and Brady wouldn't be in the league if he came into the NFL in that type of environment.

Meanwhile, Rodgers has the athleticism, arm talent and intelligence to play well on any team in any system. Obviously the results would drastically change but he would still eventually be recognized as the best overall talent in the game.

 

[sonnyblack65]

Mobility is just one of many reasons why Rodgers is successful.

A headcase is Ryan Leaf. Rodgers doesn't blow up on his teammates like Slim Shady and he doesn't give stupid quotes like Leaf. He handled the entire Favre situation with class and charm. The dude was boo'd by many Packer fans who wanted Favre back yet he handled every interview perfectly. Now, does he date crazy hollywood women?? Sure, that's just thinking with the D and he's still doing it so he hasn't learned his lesson there but he probably doesn't want some gold digger woman like Tiger and Kobe had so I can see the pro's and cons.

Hawks game as been discussed ad nauseam. If the Packers offensive play calling and defensive play calling stay the same as it was in the first half they win 30+ points to 0. MM is notorious for going into conservative mode as does the D coordinator. This is one cherry picked game and I could do the same to Brady but to blame that on Rodgers is asinine. Feel free to watch that game and see how the play calling changed from the first half to the second half. Packers started running right up the middle on three straight plays. The dropped onside kick, sliding on the int (Mcmuffin told him to slide) when Burnett could've walked in for the game clinching TD, calling prevent defense/soft zone coverage when they were going with aggressive blitzes and bump and run all game, etc, etc.

Brady's defense and James white (the real MVP of the game with a record 20 points) were the hero's of that SB game. The D relinquished 0 points during the comeback and White scored nearly all the points. Brady did just enough in the second half to save face after his embarrassing performance in the first half.

Brady is a smart QB but would fail on many other teams. He's benefited greatly from having the best coach/system ever and obviously the cheating which you will take to your grave no matter what comes out.

What system is that? Pats were sucking hind tit , before he took over a 5-13 team and took them to 3 SB's in 4 years. Look at his and AR's no#s since AR started very comparable , Rodgers better legs, Brady smarter and reads D's better. Al lthe teammates that come and go love Brady, he is generous, gives away the last few SB MVP trucks because he knows it;s a team effort, Some of the ex GB said Rodgers is arrogant, thinks he is on his own level and didn't acknowledge them. Your guy is a great QB but another Alex Rodriguez imo. I'm done wasting my time with u

 

[Great Dayne]

Now that's some quality speculation right there. You're starting to remind me of the water boy

I'd take the Water Boy over your boy Shady.

 

[sonnyblack65]

I never owned a cheap suit so I wouldn't know.

Hate to tell you but Polyester suits you sport are cheap. I'll send you some old Armani, Boss, Hart Schafner and Marx, Hickey Freeman, Mani etc . The 2 for $100 at Target don't cut it pal

 

[The Derski]

Besides having multiple top ten scoring defenses, the greatest coach of all time and cheating scandals involved in all but one of the SB's Brady's also had an Oline that gives him enough time to have dinner in the pockett.

Put an nonathletic QB with a mediocre team on a team like oh say the Seahakwks and that guy wouldn't be in the league. This would be either due to injury or lack of production. Hawks have a terrible play caller with no O-line and Brady wouldn't be in the league if he came into the NFL in that type of environment.

Meanwhile, Rodgers has the athleticism, arm talent and intelligence to play well on any team in any system. Obviously the results would drastically change but he would still eventually be recognized as the best overall talent in the game.

Rodgers in a Patriot system with Bilichick would be damn near unstoppable. Brady on the Packers might get us 9 wins. Maybe a WC spot.

 

[Rex Racer]

Lucky to be drafted by New England rather than, say, the Browns, so he has a coach and team in place that allows him to flourish? Yes, absolutely.

Yeah, lucky him that he was taken in the 6th round, by a team that just signed their franchise QB to a $100 million contract.

 

[Rex Racer]

Rodgers would thrive with any team, Brady would be a real estate agent if he wasn't drafted by the Cheatriots.

Puhleeze.

If Rodgers had been drafted by the 40whiners he would have been out of the league in 2 years and would now be the proud owner of the largest chain of bath houses in North America.

 

[Rex Racer]

Rodgers in a Patriot system with Bilichick would be damn near unstoppable. Brady on the Packers might get us 9 wins. Maybe a WC spot.

Belichick would have cut Rodgers after the first year he was a starter. BB has little patience for QB's that can't read a defense.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Besides having multiple top ten scoring defenses, the greatest coach of all time and cheating scandals involved in all but one of the SB's Brady's also had an Oline that gives him enough time to have dinner in the pockett.

Put an nonathletic QB with a mediocre team on a team like oh say the Seahakwks and that guy wouldn't be in the league. This would be either due to injury or lack of production. Hawks have a terrible play caller with no O-line and Brady wouldn't be in the league if he came into the NFL in that type of environment.

Meanwhile, Rodgers has the athleticism, arm talent and intelligence to play well on any team in any system. Obviously the results would drastically change but he would still eventually be recognized as the best overall talent in the game.

Don't forget he has that fake limp every time he's not doing well and get planted on the frozen tundra.
Do you actually believe half the crap you write.

 

[The Derski]

Belichick would have cut Rodgers after the first year he was a starter. BB has little patience for QB's that can't read a defense.

You're talking about the guy who has the best TD/INT ratio and passer rating of all time right?

 

[Rex Racer]

Don't forget he has that fake limp every time he's not doing well and get planted on the frozen tundra.
Do you actually believe half the crap you write.

Dayne is cool, he doesn't believe anything he types.