tpaulus_2
Top-5 Arm Chair GM
I think not running at the combine really hurt him. I wouldn't be the one to pull the trigger on him in the 1st, that's for sure. He could be a back we look at 5 years from now that we look at and go "damn, we could have had him" but he could also be the next Doug Martin or David Wilson. For me the injury risk is too much.Holy crap would I. He is a good player but absolutely not a 1st rd pick. I don't know where the other draft analysts rank him but he is tied for 5th best RB by Mayock (who I personally think is the best of the group).
RB's that are viewed as elite are first rd picks, RB's tied for 5th positional best are lucky to get into the second rd, which is the only spot I would take Coleman at.
The reason I wouldn't be totally pissed if we did pick him, though, is that I think he's one of four backs in this draft, along with Gurley, Gordon, and David Johnson, who can be a "franchise" type RB. Coleman reminds me a ton of Peterson with his build and running style. I don't think he's quite as big as Peterson, though, and he doesn't seem quite as physical.
I'd much rather have Johnson in the 3rd than Coleman in the 1st, for what that's worth.