Eli Manning, the HOF, and my long standing Jim Plunkett comparisom

[megalodon30]

337 touchdowns.

He's played a long time. Good for him. He throws TDs at the same rate as Cam Newton, Jay Cutler, and Derek Carr. For that, you want to crown him King of Quarterbacks?

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

I'd take the weapons Rivers had in a split second over Eli's cast of characters.....

Get outta town

You are not taking Ladanian over Ahmad Bradshaw

Or Gates over Jake Ballard

 

[Rock Strongo]

Don't dis-agree, and I'm ok with him not getting in, I just know he is cause I know what drives voting

and thats fair.

 

[eaglesnut]

I'd take the weapons Rivers had in a split second over Eli's cast of characters.....

Rivers has a good case with a very big hole in it. He could pull an Elway though and get in at the end.

 

[Pure Steel]

Rivers has a good case with a very big hole in it. He could pull an Elway though and get in at the end.

You mean have a RB carry his carcass to two SB titles?

 

[Rock Strongo]

I'd take the weapons Rivers had in a split second over Eli's cast of characters.....

amani toomer was awful, i know
OBJ, terrible
tiki barber, terrible back
hakeem nicks sucked til he got hurt
plaxico, awful

you're absolutely right.

 

[eaglesnut]

He's played a long time. Good for him. He throws TDs at the same rate as Cam Newton, Jay Cutler, and Derek Carr. For that, you want to crown him King of Quarterbacks?

No, nice straw man argument trying to put words in my mouth. He's hall of fame worthy and his massive number of touchdowns is a big plus for him.

 

[megalodon30]

No, nice straw man argument trying to put words in my mouth. He's hall of fame worthy and his massive number of touchdowns is a big plus for him.

LOL, you're funny.

 

[eaglesnut]

You mean have a RB carry his carcass to two SB titles?

There's a retarded bronco fan in this thread.

 

[eaglesnut]

LOL, you're funny.

"B-b-but he played more."

 

[megalodon30]

"B-b-but he played more."

Exactly. If Cam Newton plays as long as Eli, he'll have as many TDs.

#HallOfFame!

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Exactly. If Cam Newton plays as long as Eli, he'll have as many TDs.

#HallOfFame!

He may very well have that chance, all he has to do is win 2 Super Bowls for his team

 

[Wamu]

how did this happen?

The wrong dosages of deer antler spray?

 

[boogiewithstu2007]

Matt Hasselback saw one "moment" his entire 37 year career, and Al Harris is still running the other way with it

He had more blunders than just that moment, Matt wasn’t clutch, that’s why I compared the 2 but then pointed out Manning is more clutch, no doubt about it... I’d take Manning over Hasselbeck, especially in the playoffs ...

 

[eaglesnut]

Exactly. If Cam Newton plays as long as Eli, he'll have as many TDs.

#HallOfFame!

How about the yards and super bowl mvps?

 

[NWPATSFAN]

Stats and Rings is what HOF QBs are measured by

I personally don't care if he's in or not, he has earned his lifetime pass in this city

But there is gonna be a lotta dissapointment out there when he gets in

Wow talk about ball washing. If Eli were anywhere near as great as TB12 we'd never hear anything else from you again. You'd never come up for a breath. Give it a rest.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Wow talk about ball washing. If Eli were anywhere near as great as TB12 we'd never hear anything else from you again. You'd never come up for a breath. Give it a rest.

TB12 LOL

So gay

Guy is an overrated bag of piss

 

[NWPATSFAN]

the last QB to play QB who couldnt throw a football well (mechanically) to be drafted, that i can think of, was browning nagle for the jets.

nagle had one good game in college, a fiesta bowl.

he had one good game in the nfl, his first start.

NY likes their share of inept QBs

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

NY likes their share of inept QBs

Yeah, Tom Brady sure loses a lot of big games to inept QB's

 

[NWPATSFAN]

TB12 LOL

So gay

Guy is an overrated bag of piss

We know Dirt. Eli is great. Won those SBs single handedly.
LOL

Good to see you come up for a breath. Betting Eli doesn't think so?

After this thread just do me a favor? Never Ever call anyone else on the entire hoop a ball washer.