- Thread starter
- #41
blstoker
Bill Bergen for HoF!
After 5 years of having talking heads completely whiff on what the Seahawks are going to do in the draft, especially in the first round, because they've got their own idea of what the Seahawks should do that isn't on the same wavelength with Schneider and Carroll, I don't care what those guys think anymore. They're gonna be wrong, the Seahawks are gonna do something none of them expect or think the Seahawks should have done and we'll see ridiculously bad grades for another draft that turns out to be good at worst.
IDK, Seattle has pretty much earned a lot of those low grades. People tend to forgive the misses that PC/JS have because they've pulled some brilliance in the later rounds (and UDFA).
2010. Okung was a gimme, everyone and their dog knew Seattle had to take him if he was there. The big drama was Earl Thomas over Taylor Mays (whose career has been so blah that I didn't even realize he was still in the league), which turned out to be no decision at all. Golden Tate was mediocre (or flat out a bust) the first three years and looked like he'd never truly learn the WR position and I wasn't even upset that he left for any reason other than PR. Walter Thurmond is made of glass. EJ Wilson made it two seasons. Then the cream of the crop - Kam Chancellor has been a stud. Anthony McCoy looked like a solid pick until he got on the Walter Thurmand training program. Sexter Davis made it three years. Jameson Konz has played one game.
PC/JS best draft to date. Kiper, who everyone seems to hate because he hasn't liked the Seahawks draft, gave the draft an A.
2011. James Carpenter was a bad pick, even with his vastly improved season this year it doesn't seem to be enough to save them from this pick. John Moffitt was even worse, and was traded after two seasons. KJ Wright has been a solid starting LB. Kris Durham couldn't even make the team with this team's horrible receivers. Richard Sherman has become a stud, but if PC & JS knew this is what he was going to be, they'd have drafted him sooner. Mark LeGree never played a game. Byron Maxwell started slow but turned in a solid year and a half as a starter and will cash in this off season for it. Lazarius Levingston played 7 NFL games. Malcolm Smith has been a solid 4th LB with a Super MVP in his trophy room.
This is the start of the drafts that have Seahawks fans hating Mel Kiper. The D- he gave the Seahawks was the lowest of any team, but in honesty they whiffed big on their first 3 rounds. There has been plenty of ire coming the way of Seattle's first half of that draft, deservedly so, and if not for the late round miracles it would have been a massively disappointing draft class.
2012. Bruce Irvin was good at LB this year, but after three years people are still not sure what we have with him (partially the position change's fault). Bobby Wagner has been one of the best MLB in football. Russell Wilson has been spectacular - but was stated by Kiper at the time that if he'd been just a couple inches taller he'd've gone in the early first round. Robert Turbin, stuck behind Lynch is nothing more than a role player. Jay Howard, played 16 of his career 21 games in 2014 for Kansas City. Korey Toomer, amounts to nothing more than ST and depth. Jeremy Lane, solid but turning out to be injury prone. Winston Guy has played 21 games for 3 teams. JR Sweezy, seems to be settling into his position change, but doesn't appear to be anything special. Greg Scruggs - depth.
I know on cbs everyone thought Bruce Irvin was a massive reach - especially since he was a single move pass rusher. Wagner and Wilson make this draft, without them then there is no class. Kiper gave the Hawks a C- this year, and since most draft grades are tied into the first round (if a team has one) then it's no surprise why it was so low.
2013. Christine Michael hasn't proven anything and maybe won't ever be able to beat out Turbin. Jordan Hill has put together a solid 6 game stretch. Chris Harper was a complete bust. Jesse Williams still hasn't seen the field. Tharold Simon missed all of last year and has been constantly injured even when healthy. Luke Willson has been flash at times, but is inconsistent. Spencer Ware never worked out. Ryan Seymour is added depth for Cleveland. Ty Powell plays for the Bills. Jared Smith hasn't seen the field. Michael Bowie has looked good at times, but has looked horrible at others.
Seattle had botched the last two 1st round picks so bad, I was sure they had done a better job by trading their's to Minny for Harvin, which turned out to be wrong, they couldn't even trade the first round pick away right. Overall, 2013 has been underwhelming, but there have been some flashes here and there, but not enough, yet. Hill looks like he will be the cream of this crop, and Willson may have a decent career yet. Kiper gave the draft a B.
2014. Paul Richardson was just looking like he was getting into the swing of things when he went down. Britt looks like he will be a good RT with more experience. Cassius Marsh looks promising as long as he stays healthy. Kevin Norwood is an unknown as yet. Kevin Pierre-Louis has added some depth. Jimmy Staten, Garrett Scott and Eric Pinkins have all not seen any action. Kiero Small has started at FB for Cleveland.
Kiper gave this class a C+, and though it really hasn't had time to show anything, it hasn't exactly excelled either. Given time it could look better, but right now it looks like Britt will be the only long time starter out of the group.
The point I'm trying to make is that Pete Carroll and John Schneider have been average at best in the first 3 rounds of the draft. They've been great (or lucky, however you want to see it) with the late round picks in the past, but it's been since 2012 since they picked up a starter (Sweezy) and since 2011 since a pro bowler (Sherman) in the fifth or later. A draftnick's job is to keep people talking up to and after the draft. But, even though they are for the most part not football guys, they hit and miss on players about as often as the actual teams do.