Current HOF players

[jwolt92]

U didn’t bring really anything. Plus the hof is body of work, not whose “better”.
Tony Boswell i is better than Orlando pace imho one is in one is out

I brought stats. All you brought was sensationalism.. aka Skip Bayless

 

[jwolt92]

Really ? Make this argument to the committee

This is a clown statement bro

 

[rmilia1]

Ryan has also attempted nearly 50 passes more per game than Rivers. And that's a great story about Gates but he's averaged less than 10 games per season since 2010

So get throws it 3 times per game more than Rivers ?

Ryan also has a better win %, better completion % and a lower INT % ( despite throwing it more )

It's not close . Pretty much every metric favors Ryan and by their career end the raw numbers will as well ( barring something weird like Rivers playing til hes 45)

All that said I still think Rivers has a shot

 

[Judge Fudge]

Wilson ( how he changed the game for scrambling Quarterbacks)
Mahomes ( how he is using different throwing styles)
AD
Brady
Brees
Rodgers
Rivers( not right away but maybe 10 or 20 years)

AD
Barkley

Fitzgerald
Brown
Hill( if he gets his head straight on return)
Julio Jones

Gronk
Gates
Kelce
Witten

Thomas
Peters

JJ Swat
Donald
Suggs
Richardson
Garrett

Wagner
Kichkley( Carolina)
Jack

Lattimore
Sherman
Ramsey
Denzel Ward
Peterson( read rivers)

Earl Thomas
Kam( read rivers and Peterson)
Weddle

That is a start. Maybe a clearer head will help me tomorrow after I get some sleep

 

[PhoenixEagles1]

Jason Peters first ballot lock.

 

[Tapey]

Lol cam newton has the same chance to get into the hall as Matt Ryan

 

[Tapey]

 

[gobigred]

Since becoming the full time starter, and never missing a game, Rivers has averaged close to 30 touchdowns per game and 15 interceptions.

Rivers > Big Ben > Eli

30 touchdowns per game is damn impressive although the 15 interceptions a game is pretty awful

 

[Shane_O_Mac812]

Lol. Ryan has had 1 great receiver . Julio . Rivers had LT and both had HoF TEs ( Rivers his whole career ) and no he hasn't averaged better numbers . Ryan has averaged more yards , more TDs and has a better QB rating in both the regular season and the playoffs.

Ryan also had Roddy White who was a beast earlier in Ryan's career. Also had Tony Gonzales for a few years as well.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Rivers is so much better than Eli it aint funny. The debate should be Ben vs Rivers, if anything.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Lol cam newton has the same chance to get into the hall as Matt Ryan

Matt Ryan has a statistical argument as a 1st ballot entry

 

[SteelersPride]

This is a clown statement bro

how so ? its valid? the committee and past decision matter, its not what YOU think

 

[SteelersPride]

I brought stats. All you brought was sensationalism.. aka Skip Bayless

got it

 

[SteelersPride]

There is no maybe about it.

he just was never the "best" i can see him getting in jhust not first ballot

 

[SteelersPride]

Wilson ( how he changed the game for scrambling Quarterbacks) nope, not even close yet
Mahomes ( how he is using different throwing styles) nope hes played one season
AD yes
Brady yes
Brees yes
Rodgers yes
Rivers( not right away but maybe 10 or 20 years) replace with eli

AD twice?
Barkley again not yet, one season

Fitzgerald yep
Brown probably
Hill( if he gets his head straight on return) seriously? haha
Julio Jones getting there

Gronk yes
Gates yes
Kelce nope not yet
Witten yes

Thomas yes
Peters yes

JJ Swat yep
Donald needs a few more years but yes
Suggs yes
Richardson sheldon ?umm no
Garrett nope not even close yet

Wagner dont think so
Kichkley( Carolina) more likely than wagner
Jack lol not even close yet

i stopped here you have a ton of guys with a few good years Denzel ward is a hall of famer?

Lattimore
Sherman
Ramsey
Denzel Ward
Peterson( read rivers)

Earl Thomas
Kam( read rivers and Peterson)
Weddle

That is a start. Maybe a clearer head will help me tomorrow after I get some sleep

 

[Manster7588]

he just was never the "best" i can see him getting in jhust not first ballot

I never said first ballot and the thread doesn't say first ballot.

It just asks for players who will be in the HOF. Witten is a 100% Lock for the HOF.

 

[SteelersPride]

I never said first ballot and the thread doesn't say first ballot.

It just asks for players who will be in the HOF. Witten is a 100% Lock for the HOF.

meh i guess, and no ur right it didnt. Is he more of a lock than wentz?

 

[Manster7588]

meh i guess, and no ur right it didnt. Is he more of a lock than wentz?

Good question. Wentz is a Super Star and all.

 

[Myles]

Rivers should not get in. No playoff success. He wasn't considered a top 3 QB in any season.

 

[SteelersPride]

Good question. Wentz is a Super Star and all.

1st team all pro 10 years and coming, pro bowler, league mvp, hall of famer